Friday, April 29, 2016


The decline of America and the rise of Donald Trump fill David Brooks with despair:
According to a Pew Research poll, 75 percent of Trump voters say that life has gotten worse for people like them over the last half century.

... The suicide rate has surged to a 30-year high.... A record number of Americans believe the American dream is out of reach. And for millennials, social trust is at historic lows.

Trump’s success grew out of that pain, but he is not the right response to it. The job for the rest of us is to figure out the right response.
So what does Brooks plan to do?
That means first it’s necessary to go out into the pain. I was surprised by Trump’s success because I’ve slipped into a bad pattern, spending large chunks of my life in the bourgeois strata -- in professional circles with people with similar status and demographics to my own. It takes an act of will to rip yourself out of that and go where you feel least comfortable. But this column is going to try to do that over the next months and years. We all have some responsibility to do one activity that leaps across the chasms of segmentation that afflict this country.
In other words, this:

That's not going to end well. It's probably not going to end up with Brooks on a chain gang, amusing as that might be. More likely it'll resemble a project Brooks praises in his column:
James Fallows had a story in The Atlantic recently noting that while we’re dysfunctional at the national level you see local renaissances dotted across the country. Fallows went around asking, “Who makes this town go?” and found local patriots creating radical schools, arts festivals, public-private partnerships that give, say, high school dropouts computer skills.
I respect Fallows more than I do Brooks, but what Fallows did was literally drop from the sky onto struggling communities, much in the manner of Donald Trump, but with a smaller private aircraft:
This article appears in the March print edition alongside the cover story, “Can America Put Itself Back Together?” -- a summation of James and Deb Fallows’s 54,000-mile journey around America in a single-engine plane.
Fallows celebrates such interventions as this:
In Holland, Michigan, the family-owned Padnos scrap-recycling company works with a local ministry called 70x7 Life Recovery to hire ex-prisoners who would otherwise have trouble reentering the workforce.
That sounds like a way to stop the bleeding in a struggling community; it doesn't sound like a way to nurse a community back to robust health.

But at least Fallows is talking about changes that are concrete. There's one thing you can count on with Brooks, and this won't change even if he boards a Greyhound in Pittsburgh to look for America: his "solutions" will always be gaseous abstractions.
We’ll probably need a new national story. Up until now, America’s story has been some version of the rags-to-riches story, the lone individual who rises from the bottom through pluck and work. But that story isn’t working for people anymore, especially for people who think the system is rigged.
Of course, that's not true for a lot of Americans, who trace their roots in this country back to forebears who were passionate union members, and sometimes actual socialists. In any case, what was driving them wasn't a "story" as much as it was a concrete desire to feed their families. Maybe they came over here believing a tale of streets paved with gold, but they were disabused of that notion right away. But at least there were jobs -- and good jobs are what's missing now, not some sort of common national myth.

We’ll also need to rebuild the sense that we’re all in this together. The author R. R. Reno has argued that what we’re really facing these days is a “crisis of solidarity.” Many people, as the writers David and Amber Lapp note, feel pervasively betrayed: by for-profit job-training outfits that left them awash in debt, by spouses and stepparents, by people who collect federal benefits but don’t work. They’ve stopped even expecting loyalty from their employers. The big flashing lights say: NO TRUST. That leads to an everyone-out-for-himself mentality and Trump’s politics of suspicion. We’ll need a communitarianism.
Notice what's missing here? An assessment of blame. The problem, according to Brooks, is dispersed evenly: we're all inadequately communitarian. The problem isn't that people with jobs to offer screw their workers over, or that people who claim they'll train you for a job just take your money and leave you in the lurch. It's all just a general malaise, and your annoying spouse is just as much to blame as the company that shipped all the local jobs overseas.

Brooks can't make sense of this because his conservatism prevents him from blaming people with power more than people who don't have any. So he falls back on states of mind and ascribes them to everyone in society equally. Blaming everyone means blaming no one -- there's just a miasma, and we're all breathing it.

That's not right. Someone's winning right now, and doing so by wielding power to the detriment of the people who are losing. Brooks will be exposed to that fact on his travels to the Real America -- but he'll refuse to see it.


Feud Turgidson said...

Plus there's all these great perks from spending a chunk or two over the next 6 months (It won't end up anywhere near 6 months total dumpster time for Our Misser Brooks; if he proves able to commit to more than 6 weeks of this claptrap, I'll be surprised.) Lost In America.

Perk The Forst: an hiatus from regular Friday appearances on the PBS NewsHour for the dubious pleasure of listening as longtime burn-out Mark Shields repeats, again and again, at every chance, him conditional pity.

Perk The Sequel: there's a book in this, we all know it, a book-ender to Bobo's Travels: Fairly Not Awful Applebee's I Have Survived. This time it'll be the All (mostly all; okay, several) Holiday Inn Tour, with special trips to retrace all of Hank Kingsley's steps as the Hankster Broke Bread and Baked Pies With the Little People (not to mention 'comforting' the often under-appreciated Little Woman or several) in The Hey Now & Again Tour (Be sure no to miss Brooks' graveside (Don't ask who.) interview with broadcasting legend Jim Brockmire, reliving his notorious Breakdown Game following being personal witness to some stranger's testicles disappearing deep into his former spouse's cloacal region.

Perk The Turd: That Wizard of Oz bit Colbert has going about this presidential passion play finally fills the desperately lonely role of Fake Campaign Scribe. Now Colbert will be able to conduct flack-to-hack fake interviews with the substanceless ego-fueled pronouncements of Cartoon Candidate Donald Trump followed by the smugly superior phonalysis of Cartoon Pundit David Brooks.

Also: it'll involve a travel bus - maybe one of those left available from the recent death of Merle, assuming they can fumigate it and at least identify some of the mystery stains - but with a valet, a fitness director, a fully stocked wine compartment and a salad bar; and it'll only be occupied by Brooks for short stints between frequent first-class flights back to DC and NYC.

Victor said...

What's lacking, is a notice on all of his idiotic scribbling, saying, "This Hell-scape is brought to you by modern Conservatism - of which I am a well-paid pimp."

I can only hope that Bobo ends up on a chain-gang, like the hero in "Sullivan's Travels," one of my all time favorite movies!
And one can only hope that - instead of a Micky Mouse cartoon - they show a few episodes of "The Simpson's," where they skewer blithering and blathering elite jackasses like like him!

But sadly, that's not to be.

He'll 'rough it' by staying in Holiday Inn Express's around the country - if he even bothers to travel - and eating in the local chain-restaurants, and say, "I know how it feels like to be a __________________ in _______________, because I stayed in a Holiday Inn Express last night!"

Why doesn't 'spontaneous combustion' ever happen to the people who actually deserve to die in the fucking flames of their own making?

The FSM flambe-ing Bobo is something I'd pay to see!

Ken_L said...

Oh God, Brooks is going out into the world to talk to Ordinary Americans. Has anyone warned the taxi drivers?

Bob M said...

David it's been done - years and years ago:
“But our trip was different. It was a classic affirmation of everything right and true and decent in the national character. It was a gross, physical salute to the fantastic possibilities of life in this country-but only for those with true grit. And we were chock full of that.”
― Hunter S. Thompson, Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas

Unknown said...

MOST WANTED paypal - fitness you x - sex x SEXTAMINA - sex xx - orchids orchidaceae phalaenopsis care - dog food x - baby potty xx - options trading xx - forex fx xx - fat loss xx - betting money xx
mesothelioma master xx - fat loss sexy

MOST WANTED FOR YOU paypal - fitness you x BOOMBU - sex xx SEXTAMINA
aceofbeauty - fat loss sexy - sex xx BESTBUYX - orchids orchidaceae phalaenopsis care THEORCHIDX - dog food xx BABXYZ - baby potty xx BABYSOLVE - options trading xx SUWANDRI - forex fx xx GOOGLECLICKBANK - fat loss xx JELEMA - betting money xx BESTBUYGAMEGUIDE
mesothelioma master xx - fat loss sexy ACEOFBEAUTY

MOST WANTED FOR YOU paypal - fitness you x BOOMBU - sex xx SEXTAMINA
aceofbeauty - fat loss sexy - sex xx BESTBUYX - orchids orchidaceae phalaenopsis care THEORCHIDX - dog food xx BABXYZ - baby potty xx BABYSOLVE - options trading xx SUWANDRI - forex fx xx GOOGLECLICKBANK - fat loss xx JELEMA - betting money xx BESTBUYGAMEGUIDE
mesothelioma master xx - fat loss sexy ACEOFBEAUTY

bt1138 said...

One little line from Brooks make me especially wretch.

Calling people who act decently and constructively in society "PATRIOTS".

This really boils down the constant manipulative labeling and name-calling that goes on with the GOP. It like the "FAMILY VALUES" thing - as in - they've got them and you don't. This crap really spooled up during the Gingrich ascendancy.