Tuesday, July 15, 2008
To some extent, what's in the new ABC/Wasington Post poll is an understandable reaction to the two candidates' life histories. But that's not the full explanation. It also results from the fact that we're following the same script we follow just about every election year:
...Seventy-two percent of Americans -- even most Democrats -- say [McCain would] be a good commander-in-chief of the military.
By contrast, fewer than half, 48 percent, say Obama would be a good commander-in-chief, a significant weakness on this measure. (McCain's rating is much improved from his unsuccessful campaign for the Republican presidential nomination in 2000, when 56 percent said he'd be a good commander-in-chief -- no more than said so, at the time, about George W. Bush.)...
Did you follow that? McCain's C-in-C number now is much higher than it was during the 2000 Republican primaries, but even then his number was higher than Obama's is now -- and so was George W. Bush's! That's right: More people thought Bush was qualified to be commander-in-chief eight years ago than think Obama is now.
I think that's because we're back in the same swamp we're always in, one in which Republicans are always presumed to be steady, stable, normal people who have America's best interests in mind, while there's always a lingering suspicion that the Democrat is an elitist with freakish ideas and a desire to destroy America.
For eight years, of course, we've had a president who actually was an elitist with freakish ideas and who made significant progress toward the destruction of America, and now we have a Republican candidate who promises to Xerox that president's policies on nearly every important issue. Yet the cloud of suspicion hangs over Obama; Obama is the one who might take us beyond the pale.
No, it's not just because it's McCain. Mitt Romney and Fred Thompson wouldn't be at 72% on the C-in-C question, but they'd be over 50%, because they're never portrayed as anything but normal; theirs would be steady, manly hands on the tiller. And as for Giuliani -- if the GOP had gone for Rudy, he'd be the Messiah of this general election campaign (though Obama would still be the one accused of trying to be the Messiah), and his C-in-C number really might be as high as McCain's. (Yes, I know he became a punchline when he lost, but if he hadn't lost, he'd still be the hero on a white charger.)
And no, it's not just because it's Obama. It might seem as if Hillary Clinton would have gone into the general election looking like a potentially strong C-in-C, but what we saw in the last few months of the primaries was not what we would have seen if the Republicans thought she had a chance to win the nomination. Instead of actually enabling her candidacy, they would have been attacking her as the Tie-Dyed Barefoot Goddess of Woodstock -- which is precisely how John McCain was attacking her back when the primaries were just getting under way.
Of course, Clinton might have done somewhat better on this question because her primary opponent wasn't using the right's memes to bash her. But the GOP would have her on the defensive by now. And we'd be in the same Groundhog Day election cycle we're always in.
****
ON THE OTHER HAND: A new Quinnipiac poll has Obama up by 9 nationally. So maybe the fear factor really isn't working this year.
Monday, July 14, 2008
It's election season, and you know what that means: it's time for the vote-Republican-or-we're-all-gonna-die billboards to start cropping up. Here's a new one in Orange County, Florida, which features the burning Twin Towers:

Notice something odd about this one? Notice the prominent URL at the bottom of the ad? What's up with that? A local news operation explains:
...The man behind the billboard is Mike Meehan, a St. Cloud businessman and musician. His website advertises a CD and music video titled "The Republican Song," with the chorus, "Don't vote for a Democrat." He's selling CDs for $5....
Here's Mike's Web site, and here's a video of the lyrically clumsy, utterly predictable song, which -- yes -- you can purchase on CD ... presumably because the dead of 9/11 would want you to:
Partial lyrics:
The Democrat secular progressive move,
political correctness is killing us too....
Now we're trying to win a war and wipe out the terrorists,
We're not fightin for oil we got plenty if we drill it....
Compared to this, the Right Brothers are Hank freaking Williams.
What's Mike Meehan's story? Well, as he tells us here, he studied music, worked in a factory, then saved up enough money to start a music store, while playing gigs around Orlando.
I also opened concerts for some world known artists, and even took the place of the famous "Jerry Lee Lewis" when he wasn't able to attend a concert at the Orlando Civic Center.
(Yes, "Jerry Lee Lewis" is in quotes -- presumably it was an ironic Jerry Lee Lewis who failed to show up for that show, not the real one. Oh, sorry, I was just being a snarky liberal elitist, wasn't I?)
Mike eventually "put the music to the side and ventured into a new business" -- he's now a painting contractor. But then, well, 9/11 Changed Everything:
For the love of my country, I later became interested in its direction. especially after 911. I became interested in news and wanting answers for a lot that wasn’t being told on the normal Liberal TV News stations. I started listening to talk radio stations and started reading a few books about politics, though I still appreciated the information from Fox New Network. It didn’t take too long after, I realized the danger of liberalism, and where it’s taking us today.
I decided to take the guitar out of the closet and began writing, "The Republican Song," "Please Don't Vote for a Democrat." Realizing the big election was coming up, I found it important to get the message out.
Yeah, it was a selfless act motivated exclusively by love of country. It had nothing whatsoever to do with the fact that guitar-pickin' dreams die hard and working a day job sucks.
Oh, and Mike's offer of contact information in case you want to book an appearance is also presumably motivated by love of country and nothing more.
Oh, and Mike has "written 14 Christian songs since, and plan[s] on recording them as well." I'm sure that's a selfless gift to America, too.
John Kerry is up for reelection this year, and while he's never been my favorite elected official, I struggle to see the urgency of driving him from office. I might have thought his 100 rating from the NAACP, 95 rating from the AFL-CIO, 93 rating from the League of Conservation Voters, and 90 ratings from NARAL and Americans for Democratic Action, just to pick a few choice stats (not to mention his 4 rating from the American Conservative Union and F- from the Gun Owners of America), would have secured his position as a rather progressive member of Congress. Apparently not -- he has a primary challenger named Ed O'Reilly, and O'Reilly has been endorsed by Progressive Democrats of America. (O'Reilly has qualified for the ballot; he's Kerry's first primary challenger in 23 years.)
Oh, and O'Reilly's been endorsed not only by PDA-MA, but by Professor Heidi Li Feldman of Georgetown -- a much-admired PUMA who, when she's not telling CQ Politics that Hillary Clinton could still win a convention vote in Denver (and running full-page newspaper ads urging just such a vote), is actively touting O'Reilly's candidacy and asserting that "he deserves the support of all those who believe in the goal of The Denver Group" ("Denver Group" being one of the billion or so different organizational names used by the PUMAs).
I don't think this is anywhere near enough to defeat Kerry -- but if there are Democratic donors and campaign workers out there and they're giving money and/or time to O'Reilly rather than to some Democrat anywhere in America whose election might represent a genuine change in direction, that's money and time utterly squandered.
I don't know if this is genuine progressive cluelessness or Rovian rat-fucking using an army of extraordinarily cynical Democratic fund-raisers.
All I know is that if Democrats screw up this election year, we should just break up the party and all join the GOP en masse -- obviously our skill at self-sabotage is so great that it can overcome any advantage, so maybe we can put it to some positive use by joining, infiltrating, and, inevitably, destroying the most powerful and dangerous political machine of our time.
If your satire needs footnotes, I'd say you didn't do a very good job of getting your point across in the first place. And this...
... clearly needed a footnote from the cartoonist before some people (left, right, and center) got it:
I think the idea that the Obamas are branded as unpatriotic [let alone as terrorists] in certain sectors is preposterous. It seemed to me that depicting the concept would show it as the fear-mongering ridiculousness that it is.
Or maybe I'm being stodgily pre-post-modern, or pre-post-Web-2.0, or something like that. I'm focusing on the cover illustration in isolation, when, in fact, the cartoon plus the artist's explanation of the cartoon plus everyone's reaction to the cartoon, including what I'm typing right now, is the totality of the work, a Cross-Platform Satire-Based Marketing Event, and we're all just shilling for Conde Nast whatever the hell we say about it. The combination of outrageousness and incoherence is what's brilliant about it, because we wouldn't keep talking about it if it actually got its point across. And we are talking about it. We may not like it, but we're soaking in it.
That's one reason I don't think it's a good idea to dwell on the damn thing. Another is that expressions of outrage -- ours and (especially) the Obama camp's -- are just gifts handed to Obama critics. What was Maureen Dowd just calling Obama? Oh yeah -- an "orchid" and a "hothouse flower." It does Obama no good to suggest that he's too fragile to shrug off stuff like this. If he were a Republican, of course, it would be no problem -- starting with Nixon, Republicans have mastered the art of playing the victim card and the macho-man card simultaneously, and Americans now just accept it as perfectly logical and consistent that their GOP heroes on white steeds are forever whining about bearded college professors and the liberal media. But Obama doesn't have that luxury. So he'd do well to treat this as beneath him and shrug it off.
Sunday, July 13, 2008
In today's New York Times Magazine, Matt Bai writes about the critiques of our politics by John McCain and Barack Obama -- and, well, wouldn't you know it, the two fit precisely into their parties' stereotypes:
...Both men criticize a lack of responsiveness of government to its people, caused primarily by the influence of "special interests." McCain, however, takes a personal and confrontational approach toward reform, which he sees fundamentally as a matter of overhauling the rules that govern Washington. By this thinking, a Rough-Rider-type leader should press for tough measures -- publicizing earmarks, for example -- that insulate legislators from moneyed interests.
Obama, on the other hand, casts reform as something that primarily congeals outside Washington, which is why he started to sound a little like the Doobie Brothers during the primaries, invoking a movement that was taking it to the streets. In his view, politics is saved not by some solitary crusade but by encouraging local activists to rise up. Perhaps befitting the mythologies of their generations, McCain offers himself up as the sheriff on the Potomac, while Obama seems to envision himself more as the organizer in chief....
Never mind the fact that Obama's actual generation -- the one that graduated college in the early 1980s -- wasn't interested in organizing and collective action at all, its main goal being to make as much money as humanly possible after leaving school; that's irrelevant to Bai because, as far as he's concerned, all Democrats are automatically members of the Woodstock Generation, and everything about them is always reminiscent of peace signs and roach clips.
And never mind the fact it's impossible to imagine how a "Rough-Rider-type leader" would deal with the culture of Washington, because when Teddy Roosevelt was a Rough Rider, he was a soldier, not an elected official. And I don't know what either of these has to do with being a sheriff. But sheriffs and Rough Riders are armed and on horseback and manly, as, in Bai's view, all Republicans are, even the ones who've gone years without holding any weapon more dangerous than barbecue tongs.
What's neat about this is that you could do it the opposite way, too. If Obama were primarily talking about "overhauling the rules that govern Washington," he'd be a typical wonky-wussy Democrat elitist -- one whose whole world is government and who thinks the solution to every problem is more regulation. And if McCain were the one who "casts reform as something that primarily congeals outside Washington," he'd be the regular guy who disdains D.C. and thinks there's much more wisdom on Main Street U.S.A. than on Pennsylvania Avenue.
I will give Bai credit for referencing the Doobs rather than resorting to the usual "hold hands and sing 'Kumbaya'" in reference to the Democrat -- but maybe this is in response to some new directive at the Times, one that urges columnists to go for the cliche, but in a way that seems vaguely new and different; see also the recent David Brooks column in which, instead of "under the bus," he said (how daring!) "under the truck."
Here's everything you need to know about Maureen Dowd's feminism. Writing about the Access Hollywood interview of the Obama family, she tells us this:
The girls were impossibly cute and charming and a tribute to the Obamas' parenting. When Malia said she enjoyed decorating and was most excited about a possible move to the White House because she'd have a new bedroom to dress up, it made me want to see the Obama girls in the White House no matter who wins.
"Yes! Finally! At long last, I may have a D.C. female to write about who knows her proper role in life -- to be a princess! Oh, sure, she's still only ten years old, and she'll probably screw me over by getting tattoos as a teenager and wanting to be Samantha Power when she grows up, rather than sitting by the phone overeating and waiting for some hedge-fund manager to call her back -- but for now, GIRLY STEREOTYPES ROCK!"
This is all in a column in which Dowd rescues the non-scandal of the Obama kids' interview from the trash heap of irrelevance to which a sane American public had consigned it, and finds a way to fit the interview into her Heatherish ongoing critique of Barack Obama:
Barack Obama may make it to the Rose Garden, but he'll still be an orchid. For all his attempts to act like a sturdy American perennial, he's a genuine hothouse flower, and everything he is and does is cultivated....
He looked frustrated [during the Access Hollywood interview] when Sasha revealed that "my dad doesn't like sweets" and that he preferred "minty gum" to bubble gum. She then began singsonging "Everybody should like ice cream" before pointing a finger at the person who doesn't: "Except Daddy!"
As Margaret Carlson told Mike Barnicle on "Hardball," in a segment called "Is Obama Too Cool?," about whether he relates to average Americans, sometimes you just want to tell the guy, "Eat the doughnut." ...
I hate these people. I know there isn't a just God because all three of them -- Dowd, Carlson, and Barnicle -- are still walking around; not one of them has been painfully and publicly struck down by lightning.
It always comes down to the same thing -- phony, incredibly image-conscious people who successfully fake ordinariness telling the Democratic candidate that he's (or she's) not genuine. And, of course, what makes Obama not genuine is a genuine desire not to do what everybody else does, because he sincrely doesn't feel like it.
Saturday, July 12, 2008
A new Newsweek poll shows Barack Obama's lead over John McCain down to 3 points (although other polls show Obama with a noticeably bigger lead). Cultivated dumbassery appears to be the reason for the tightness of the race:
The new poll suggests white voters continue to be a challenge for Obama, with McCain leading the Democrat in that category 48 to 36 percent. Some of Obama's lag in white support may be explained by continual confusion over his religious identity. Twelve percent of voters surveyed said that Obama was sworn in as a United States senator on a Qur'an, while 26 percent believe the Democratic candidate was raised as a Muslim and 39 percent believe he attended an Islamic school as a child growing up in Indonesia. None of these things is true.... 85 percent of undecided voters are non-Hispanic whites and only 22 percent of those undecideds have a four-year college degree.
This year's Karl Rove is a spammer (or group of spammers) spreading this nonsense to people who are sure they aren't gullible precisely because they believe ridiculous rumors and think they're really getting the inside skinny.
Yesterday I predicted that it would only be a matter of hours before some right-winger declared that Phil Gramm was correct about the robustness of the U.S. economy, based on the fact that the number of people who still have money for new iPhones is greater than zero (if America's disposable income hasn't disappeared completely, we can't possibly be in an economic downturn!).
And here we go, just as I predicted:
Whining about waiting in line
... let's do a little comparison of a mental recession with an economic depression.
Below is a photo (courtesy Yahoo!News) in which we see people queued up... waiting....
Now take a look at a photo (courtesy National Park Service) in which we see another group of people queued up... waiting....
The difference?
In the first photo, the people are waiting to buy the latest iPhone (circa 2008), while in the second photo, the people are waiting to be given something to eat (circa 1930s)....
Emphasis in the original (of course). Google also yields this, which I can't get to load but which reads in part,
Phil Gramm is Right. We are a Nation of
...Why is Apple projected to sell 40 MILLION iphones? Why is Facebook, Google and Myspace seeing record traffic and revenues? So much for a recession. Americans have tons of purchasing power, credit, and huge liquidity....
The right-wing pros should be leaping in any minute now.
Friday, July 11, 2008
It would just be so wrong for people on our side to monkey with this process -- wouldn't it?
The Republican National Committee today will unveil a web site, www.gopplatform2008.com, that will allow individuals to log on and share their suggestions and opinions on what should be included in the party's platform....
Starting Friday, an individual can log on to the site and upload their written comments or video comments....
Republican officials say they hope this site will be a 24/7 town hall where people can look at other submissions on the site and share their views without ever leaving their home....
Yes it would definitely be wrong.
On the other hand, Rush Limbaugh is recommending that right-wingers monkey with the Democratic platform:
Rush Limbaugh, opening the second phase of his "Operation Chaos" campaign to make mischief within the Democratic Party, called on his millions of listeners Wednesday to take part in the Sen. Barack Obama campaign’s effort to democratize the party platform.
...Limbaugh ... urged his audience to attend open meetings at which the Democratic platform will be discussed.
... This week, the Obama campaign and the Democratic National Committee announced plans to hold meetings in all 50 states to get voters involved in planning the document which details the principles, philosophies and goals of the party.
..."In coming days, we will tell you exactly how you can participate in writing the Democrat party platform, at the request of the Most Merciful Lord Barack Obama." ...
So if you feel you must, you can register to make recommendations for the Republican platform (and, presumably, get yourself on multiple GOP contact lists for the rest of your life) here. Even though it's wrong.
Just wondering how soon we'll see the first right-wing column or blog post titled "Phil Gramm Was Right" in which the existence of lines outside stores selling iPhones is offered as proof that our economy is hunky-dory, just the way Gramm said it is.
Because, of course, if anyone anywhere in America makes any purchase that isn't absolutely necessary for basic human survival, it's not an economic downturn.
John McCain has a new ad in which he pays tribute to deceased Vietnam veterans -- and Ed Morrissey of Hot Air has declared it "monumentally stupid."
Jim Geraghty of National Review very much agrees.
... Um, I probably should have mentioned a detail that apparently makes it OK to attack this ad -- it's about dead Hispanic veterans, and current Hispanic troops who aren't all citizens. You see, it's an ad by the good John McCain, the one who once supported a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants, and who threw himself under the bus a while back, but appears now to have extricated himself:
If prominent online lefties were -- for any reason -- using the word "stupid" to refer to an ad that panned the Wall and talked about Vietnam veterans who'd died in action (assuming the ad met with Republicans' favor), we'd hear howls from here to Rush Limbaugh's bunker and back again, wouldn't we? But it's OK, as usual, if you're a Republican.
I'm in a bad mood and I don't really feel like thinking seriously about anything, so here's some irresponsible idle speculation:
There's a front-page story in today's New York Times about the fact that Congressman Charlie Rangel has managed to wangle four rent-controlled apartments in Harlem. It doesn't surprise me -- he's always been a last-of-a-dying-breed type in two senses, both an unreconstructed New Deal/Great Society Democrat and an old-fashioned big-city machine pol, a real operator. (William Greider goes on at length about him as the latter in his 1992 book Who Will Tell the People.)
But I'm wondering why the story is breaking now. I have absolutely no basis for this, but I can't help wondering whether Team Clinton is miffed that Rangel, a Clinton supporter until the last primary, pressured her to give up her nomination fight and to back off from open pursuit of the #2 slot, while publicly questioning her judgment after her non-concession speech on June 3.
I know Senator Clinton is being a very good soldier, but clearly all in Hillaryland is not sweetness and light -- here's James Carville on CNN calling some Obamaites "amateurs" and "children that are playing with matches"; over there is the endless parade of PUMAs (is something I'm not aware of preventing Senator Clinton from urging these people a bit more insistently to back the hell off?). And was Clinton's vote on FISA a dig at Obama?
As I said, idle speculation -- and wondering whether a Clintonite might want to slip embarrassing information about Rangel's leases to the Times is very idle speculation, and quite irresponsible of me. But, hell, it's my blog, so there you go.
Thursday, July 10, 2008
Added to the blogroll: The United States of Jamerica and Applesauce.
Look who's upset that Barack Obama said, "You know, it's embarrassing when Europeans come over here, they all speak English, they speak French, they speak German. And then we go over to Europe, and all we can say [is], 'Merci beaucoup.'" Why, it's Mitt Romney:
...The occasion for the latest insinuations about Obama's American-ness is the Illinois Senator's recent claim that Americans should learn a second language....
"I do think that, frankly, Barack Obama looks toward Europe for a lot of his inspiration," top McCain supporter Mitt Romney told Fox News on Tuesday. "I think John McCain is going to make sure that America stays America." ...
Yes, Mitt Romney -- the guy on the left in this photo, which was taken in 1968 in, er, France, where Romney honed his skills in, er, French while doing Mormon missionary work (and, conveniently, avoiding the Vietnam-era draft):
Yes, Mitt Romney -- the guy who made this video encouraging volunteers for the Salt Lake City Olympics to speak, er, French, delivering the pitch in fluent French:
We know Romney doesn't like Europe, particularly France. Familiarity breeds contempt?
Via Politico, I see that Phil Gramm, John McCain's top economic adviser, has told The Washington Times that tough economic times are all in our heads because we're squishy and brainwashed:
..."You've heard of mental depression; this is a mental recession," he said....
"We have sort of become a nation of whiners," he said. "You just hear this constant whining, complaining about a loss of competitiveness, America in decline" despite a major export boom that is the primary reason that growth continues in the economy, he said....
Mr. Gramm said the constant drubbing of the media on the economy's problems is one reason people have lost confidence....
"Misery sells newspapers," Mr. Gramm said. "Thank God the economy is not as bad as you read in the newspaper every day." ...
The problem is, one of the whiny people who believes the brainwashing is Gramm's own candidate.
On Tuesday, John McCain told MSNBC's Joe Scarborough, "The fact is Americans are hurting, they’re hurting badly."
McCain's latest ad says the economy is "in shambles."
So McCain is weak-spined and susceptible to propaganda. You heard it from his own camp.
These should be depressing times for Dick Morris -- his white whales, the Clintons, were speared by somebody else while he wasn't looking, thus depriving him of his one reason for living, and the latest book he's written with his wife (a follow-up to such masterpieces of insight as Condi vs. Hillary: The Next Great Presidential Race) has a title that seems, well, unappealingly scattershot and unfocused: Fleeced: How Barack Obama, Media Mockery of Terrorist Threats, Liberals Who Want to Kill Talk Radio, the Do-Nothing Congress, Companies That Help Iran, and Washington Lobbyists for Foreign Governments Are Scamming Us ... and What to Do About It.
(And readers would be forgiven if they have trouble distinguishing this from the last Morris book, which was called Outrage: How Illegal Immigration, the United Nations, Congressional Ripoffs, Student Loan Overcharges, Tobacco Companies, Trade Protection, and Drug Companies Are Ripping Us Off ... and What to Do About It. Don't worry, none of this will be on the final.)
But as it turns out, the new book (Fleeced, etc., etc. -- remember?) is #2 on the New York Times bestseller list, second only to the latest book by the hugely popular David Sedaris. How did that happen?
Well, notice the little punctuation mark that follows the description of the book on the Times list: (†). The fine print at the bottom of the list explains:
A dagger (†) indicates that some bookstores report receiving bulk orders.
So Dick is bulk-buying his way to (nearly) the top of the charts.
I realize that many of you believe no right-wing book ever makes it onto the bestseller list without bulk buying. I've often questioned that theory -- in a country where the White House has gone to the GOP in seven of the last ten elections, and where Fox is the #1 cable news channel and Rush and Sean and their imitators dominate radio ratings, it seems perfectly reasonable that many right-wing chart-toppers are legit. (And if every wingnut book is bulk-bought in huge numbers, why did Ann Coulter's last book bomb?)
In fact, I haven't seen a dagger on the Times list for a right-wing bestseller in quite a while -- not even for #1's like Jonah Goldberg's Liberal Fascism and Glenn Beck's An Inconvenient Book.
But Dick Morris is old school. For Dick Morris, it will always be the 1990s, and in the 1990s, bulk-buying was what you did to succeed. And, well, Dick Morris is a sad, bitter resentment junkie who doesn't really have a lot to offer, even by wingnut-pundit standards, except increasingly irrelevant Clinton-hate (a particular problem now that the right likes Hillary).
So if he and his publisher (Rupert Murdoch's HarperCollins) want him on the charts, he probably didn't have any other choice.
Wednesday, July 09, 2008
I don't how you get from this to castration (if you don't know what I'm talking about, read the story and watch the video), but Jesse Jackson has never liked the faith-based provision of government services, or at least he's never liked the George W. Bush version: he told The Washington Post shortly before Bush was inaugurated, "I know the subplot: This is an attempt to play one group against the other," and a few weeks after the inauguration, according to the Chicago Sun-Times, he "issued warnings about faith-based social service programs funded by the government...[He said the] 'church must not...compromise its independence.'" So his criticism of Obama isn't surprising. (His imagery is another matter.)
My first reaction was something like Andrew Sullivan's: "Obama gets his Sistah Souljah moment handed to him on a plate."
But my second thought was that this could hit certain semi-racist hot buttons in some white voters. Remember the talk about Hillary Clinton and whether America was ready to endure the Clinton "soap opera" again? It seems possible that, for some whites, the appearance of Jesse Jackson in connection with Obama is roughly equivalent to the "soap opera." I'm thinking of whites who don't like Jackson (and Al Sharpton, who's twinned with Jackson in some whites' minds) and who, after seeing this, will think Jackson is an inevitable part of the "baggage" that comes along with having an African-American candidate. (Yes, I know -- Jackson was criticizing Obama, but he's since apologized.)
But my third thought is that most white people simply don't think all that much about Jackson and Sharpton, and that the ones who do are hardcore wingnuts. Looking at the blogosphere reaction to all this, I see wingnuts disproportionately represented. And, of course, it's Fox News that's making hay of all this.
As for black voters, I think they'll see this as just normal political debate with some unusually salty language, which is basically what it is. No big deal.
So I figure this will all blow over in about eighteen hours -- although the right-wing media will try to keep it going by saying Obama has offended yet another liberal. (New Fox drinking game: Everybody take a sip when you hear the phrase "under the bus.")
And hey, who knew Jesse Jackson had a little bit of Bada-Bing in him?
The best part of stories like this one is always the (semi-)apology:
A banner slogan on the Pemberton Republican Club's Web site that said, "Obama loves America like O.J. loved Nicole," disappeared yesterday after local Democrats alleged racist campaign tactics.
The Web master, Ed Kuck, a recently elected Republican County committeeman, said he had seen the slogan on an Internet site and copied it onto the club's Web page about a month ago as "a joke."
He removed it yesterday from the site, http://homewebs.net/pem, after a community person told him it would offend people, he said.
"I found out it was inappropriate, and I took it down," Kuck said, adding: "I just want to apologize to anybody who was offended, because that wasn't our intention at all." ...
That's right -- he found out it was inappropriate. The inappropriateness had been unknowable to him, but then a wise and well-informed person revealed obscure, arcane knowledge that opened his eyes and allowed him, for the first time, to grasp the inappropriateness.
It was, as they say, a teachable moment.
Via Blue Jersey, here's a screenshot:

The Pemberton Repubs have taken down not just the illustration but their entire site.
Is Barack Obama now really being called an "elitist" ... by Lady Lynn Forester de Rothschild, a Hillary Clinton supporter and the wife of the British financier Sir Evelyn Robert Adrian de Rothschild?
Yup. This is not a joke.
Good grief.
****
UPDATE: It occurs to me, as I'm reading "Obama Donors Aren’t Rushing to Aid Clinton" in today's New York Times, that maybe one way for Team Clinton to get more contributions out of Obama's big donors is to get the endless parade of Clinton-or-death zealots the hell off Fox News (and the rest of the cable blathersphere). If I were a wealthy Obama backer, I might be trying to grasp why I should help Clinton when my donor peers in her camp are calling my candidate a crack-smoking elitist murderer, or whatever it is they're saying this week.
Or maybe I'm looking at this the wrong way around -- maybe the Clintonites are using the PUMAs, threatening to keep them on the air until her debt is paid off. If so, and if Obama keeps leading in the polls despite the PUMA howling, they may be waiting a long time.

From one L.F. Eason III:
RALEIGH -- L.F. Eason III gave up the only job he'd ever had rather than lower a flag to honor former U.S. Sen. Jesse Helms.
Eason, a 29-year veteran of the state Department of Agriculture, instructed his staff at a small Raleigh lab not to fly the U.S. or North Carolina flags at half-staff Monday, as called for in a directive to all state agencies by Gov. Mike Easley.
When a superior ordered the lab to follow the directive, Eason decided to retire rather than pay tribute to Helms. After several hours' delay, one of Eason's employees hung the flags at half-staff.
...He told his staff that he did not think it was appropriate to honor Helms because of his "doctrine of negativity, hate, and prejudice" and his opposition to civil rights bills and the federal Martin Luther King Jr. holiday....
Helms was a hatemonger, not just a garden-variety partisan, so in a better world he wouldn't be honored by the state. (In a better world, obviously, he wouldn't have been elected repeatedly for decades.) So my hat's off to Eason.
It's an ironically appropriate tribute, too -- a guy who regularly patted himself on the back for blocking consensus being denied a statewide honor, if only temporarily, by one man who just said "No."
Tuesday, July 08, 2008
This whole thing is making me cranky; all I can say is: what Steve Benen said.
If you want primary sources, here's Obama on FISA and Obama on every other "lurch to the right."
I don't know what some progressives thought -- that Obama was a clone of themselves, exactly as far to the left on every issue? He wasn't. That it was possible for him to be elected president without ever wavering or waffling? It isn't -- though one so-called rightward move is just a misreading of an unfortunately worded remark (Iraq), another is non-left-wing thinking that we should have known about going in (Obama "appeared to endorse the death penalty for child rapists" in The Audacity of Hope), and another is more complicated than it appears (Bob Herbert, denouncing Obama's position on religious-group provision of government services as a clone of Bush's position, apparently didn't read the article in his own paper that cited Obama's insistence on non-discrimination in hiring by religious recipient groups as a poison pill that infuriated the likes of the Catholic League and the Family Research Council).
I know I'm supposed to be up in arms about FISA, but there are just too damn many impediments to a win here -- the genie who was supposed to wave a wand and magically eliminate the influence of big money in politics is clearly stuck in traffic; red-state Democrats still, for some reason, think it's in their best interests politically to be to the right of Jane Hamsher and Glenn Greenwald; and Republicans, bafflingly, still portray Democrats as weak on security issues even though voters only fall for that about two-thirds of the time. Snark aside, the big problem is that the public isn't with us on this; on Iraq, on Katrina, on the economy, on Terri Schiavo, the vast majority of America is on our side -- but on dirty, nasty things done in the shadows in the name of security, Americans are still at the wrong end of the learning curve. I'm not sure the 120 days before a presidential election are the right time for a cram course, and that's what I think Obama is thinking, too; it's regrettable, but I don't blame him.
Can anyone explain to me what the hell is going on in this new McCain ad? Specifically, can anyone explain what the end of it has to do with the beginning? And if there's no connection, can anyone explain why it's so difficult for the McCain people to stick to one subject, or even a series of genuinely related subjects, for, y'know, an entire minute?
Here's the script:
ANNCR: It was a time of uncertainty, hope and change. The "Summer Of Love." Half a world away, another kind of love -- of country. John McCain: Shot down. Bayoneted. Tortured. Offered early release, he said, "No." He'd sworn an oath. Home, he turned to public service. His philosophy: before party, polls and self ... America. A maverick, John McCain tackled campaign reform, military reform, spending reform. He took on presidents, partisans and popular opinion. He believes our world is dangerous, our economy in shambles. John McCain doesn't always tell us what we "hope" to hear. Beautiful words cannot make our lives better. But a man who has always put his country and her people before self, before politics can. Don't "hope" for a better life. Vote for one. McCain.
JOHN MCCAIN: I'm John McCain and I approved this message.
What was the thought process on this? I'll venture a guess. Back in the fall, the McCain people must have been quite proud of their attack on Hillary Clinton for supporting a Woodstock Museum -- after all, they made two ads about it. But now they're not running against Hillary Clinton -- and they want her voters. But they couldn't bear to let the peacenik/POW compare-and-contrast go. So they decided to equate McCain in Nam with the Summer of Love -- sort of. It's all about luv. Hey, that oughta resonate with those back-in-the-day hippies!
But, er, where does the guy McCain is actually running against fit into all this? Oh, yeah -- "hope." "Hope" is kinda like "love," isn't it? It's an abstract noun. It has four letters, two of which are o and e. Close enough, right? And Barack Obama could be a sixties archetype ... if he had about five hundred times more hair, wore dashikis instead of suits, and hadn't been six years old during the actual Summer of Love.
Whatever!
In short, a mess, as usual for Team McCain.
Ron Kall reported this a couple of days ago at the Huffington Post:
Libertarian Legacy? Ron Paul's Campaign Manager, 49, Dies Uninsured, Of Pneumonia, Leaving family $400,000 Debt
What a testament to the Libertarian creed, which abhors the idea of universal health care. This loyal, passionate man who died too young left his family a debt of $400,000 in medical bills. And who knows whether he put off getting treatment for the pneumonia that killed him because he was uninsured.
Kent Snyder did some amazing work on the Ron Paul Campaign....
The poor guy raised tens of millions of dollars and couldn't afford the $300-$600 a month that COBRA medical insurance would have cost....
(I think it would have been a bit more than $300-$600 a month -- The Kansas City Star reports that Snyder "was uninsured, his sister Michelle Caskey said, because a pre-existing condition made the premiums too expensive.")
More from Kall:
A website has been created to help raise the $400,000 to pay the medical bills.
Unfortunately, that website, which seeks $400,000 by July 17, still has about $381,000 to go. Hey, come on Paulites, where's your Love Revolution? In the words of your candidate (who, of course, is an M.D.), "We have a moral obligation to help our fellow man."
But I should put that Paul quote in context:
A major problem with today's society, according to Paul, is the confusion of "needs" and "rights": "We have rights to our lives and liberty and we have a right to pursue our happiness and we should have the right to keep the fruits of our labor. We have a moral obligation to help our fellow man." That doesn't mean, however, that we have a right to affordable health care.
Paul noted that because of all these governmental programs "charity work doesn't seem to exist anymore; yet there was a time when there was substantial charity work....We've gotten this way because the government put us this way."
So it seems that Ron Paul's vision is one in which people are supposed to be on the brink of destitution as a result of medical bills, only to be saved from bankruptcy by their friends and neighbors. To Paul, that kind of crisis isn't a bug, it's a feature.
Well, Paulites, you're the ones whose minds are supposedly not colonized by the insidious desire to be servile to (ick!) government, right? So go to that website and pony up.
Monday, July 07, 2008
Chances are you've already read "The Jesse Helms You Should Remember," an op-ed in The Washington Post by Marc Thiessen, a former Helms speechwriter. If so, you know Thiessen's argument -- that Helms was a lone voice for conservatism until more and more people saw the light. We read about the brave Jesse who, in the 1970s, "often took to the floor as the lonely opposition in 99-to-1 votes." And even after Ronald Reagan won a 49-state landslide, Jesse was apparently the only conservative in Washington -- or so Thiessen would have you believe:
What made Helms stand out was his willingness to stand up for his beliefs before they were widely held -- even if it meant challenging those closest to him. In 1985, his dear friend Ronald Reagan was preparing for his first summit with Mikhail Gorbachev when a Ukrainian sailor named Miroslav Medvid twice jumped off a Soviet ship into the Mississippi River seeking political asylum. The Soviets insisted that Medvid had accidentally fallen off -- twice. The State Department did not want an international incident on the eve of the summit. But Helms believed it was wrong to send a man back behind the Iron Curtain -- no matter the cost to superpower diplomacy. He tried to block the ship's departure by requiring the sailor to appear before the Senate Agriculture Committee, which he chaired then -- and he had the subpoena delivered to the ship's unwitting captain in a carton of North Carolina cigarettes.
Despite Helms's efforts, the ship was allowed to leave for the Soviet Union with the Ukrainian sailor aboard.
Except that brave ol' Jesse wasn't "stand[ing] up for his beliefs before they were widely held" -- in fact, the two newspapers he probably loathed the most, the twins of the "liberal media," agreed with him:
The Washington Post (November 25,1985) ran an editorial entitled "No More Medvids" and declared that the Border Patrol officials who returned Medvid to the Soviets had been guilty of "a serious failure of judgment." The New York Times (November 9, 1985) was more scathing, stating that initially Medvid's case was handled "disastrously" by officials who "acted with relentless ignorance."
So this wasn't Jesse against a liberal juggernaut; it was Jesse and quite a bit of establishment opinion against the administration of the #1 right-wing saint, Ronald Reagan, who didn't want to screw up a summit.
*****
One passage in Thiessen's op-ed stuck out for Tom Hilton:
What his critics could not appreciate is that, by the time he left office, Jesse Helms had become a mainstream conservative. And it was not because Helms had moved toward the mainstream -- it was because the mainstream moved toward him.
That's certainly true in one way, as noted in the New York Times obituary for Helms:
His bruising style and right-wing politics won him many friends in his home state and across the nation, but he also created a legion of enemies. Millions of dollars were raised outside North Carolina both from those who flocked to his ideological banner and from those who ached to see him defeated. He never won more than 55 percent of the vote in five campaigns for the Senate.
"He was a very polarizing politician," said Ferrel Guillory, a veteran North Carolina journalist. "He was not a consensus builder. He didn't want everybody to vote for him. He just wanted enough."
And in The Boston Globe:
Sen. Alan Cranston (D-Calif.), said in the early '80s, "Since Jesse Helms started his warfare against those who disagree with him, there's a meanness in the Senate now that I don't think has been seen since the days of Joe McCarthy."
In that way, Helms was George W. Bush before Bush was, or at least he was the pre-Rove Rove. The politics we despise now, the politics of the relentless pursuit of wedge issues and utter unwillingness to compromise, was the politics of Helms. A mainstream conservative now is precisely what Helms was, someone who routinely grandstands and draws lines in the sand. They called Helms "Senator No," but now the entire GOP is the Party of No -- we see that every time a bill in the Senate needs 60 votes to break a filibuster. So yes, it really is his party now.
VDH after reading the Rush Limbaugh cover story in The New York Times Magazine:
[Limbaugh] is not impressed by the Columbia School of Journalism types who, for all their degrees, write so many silly and untrue things for Newsweek or the New York Times. And he doesn’t think being a CBS or NBC anchor is de facto proof of any Edward R. Murrow gravitas.
Er, not exactly. This is from the story itself:
In 1988, Limbaugh moved to New York and took his show national. He came to the city with the usual make-it-there, make-it-anywhere expectations. The show, carried locally on WABC-AM, was a national hit. But socially, he flopped.
"I assumed there was a fraternity of broadcasting guys in New York," he told me. "I thought my success would launch me into a circle of accomplished people. Look, I admired these people. Peter Jennings, Tom Brokaw, Dan Rather -- people watched these guys. I thought they would welcome me as one of them. I was wrong."
Boo-hoo.
****
Apart from that and a couple of other fleeting passages, however, the story was -- as RedState put it -- a "puff piece." Limbaugh himself calls it "a nice piece."
And we shouldn't be surprised. Limbaugh's no idiot, after all, so he fed the writer of the piece, Zev Chafets, his undiluted myth of himself, and Chafets swallowed it whole, and regurgitated exactly what he was fed.
Limbaugh is skilled at what he does. I'm not defending him morally; I'm just saying it takes certain skills to be the #1 mountebank of your generation, and he's got those skills. His ideas are wrong, but they're not stupid wrong; his belief system is internally consistent and he knows how the news of the day fits into it. He's mixes cornball and mean-spiritedness in a way that, to a lot of people, seems convivial and jolly and entertaining and edifying. He's a lot better than Kanye West or most pro wrestlers at fake-but-not-really-fake bombastic egomania. It's a clever package.
Chafets clearly went into the story underestimating Limbaugh, found him a larger, more significant figure than he expected, then wrote that up.
The thing is, Limbaugh is good, but he's not that good; a great deal of his success comes from the fact that he gets treated this way -- i.e., as a marginal figure -- so he turns that to his advantage, persuading his audience that they're consuming a product that comes from well off the beaten path, something the powers that be consider dangerous and illicit, which makes listeners feel they're part of some daringly countercultural movement. If big-league media and political types actually took Limbaugh seriously -- if they covered him regularly and picked apart his arguments and generally demystified him -- he'd shrink in stature. But no elitist ever listens to him or even reads transcripts of his broadcasts; no one knows what his philosophy is or his shtick is. So he thrives on being underestimated, year in and year out.
Chafets clearly didn't know anything about Limbaugh going in. He showed little interest in the content of the show and barely engaged Limbaugh on politics; he was much more interested in Limbaugh's wealth and home furnishings, and in the fact that Limbaugh is an elusive "get" -- in fact, the peg of Chafets's story was his own success, as a mainstream journalist, in getting Limbaugh to agree to an interview.
Thus, Limbaugh played Chafets for a sucker. Chafets traveled to the strange land known as Florida, far outside the centers of the media universe, and found that people don't walk on their knuckles there, and one man in particular has money and fancy cars and goes to restaurants where he tips generously and everyone loves him. And Chafets came away impressed. So now Limbaugh can say he impressed the fancy-schmancy guy from the MSM. Which is exactly what happened.
When Jesse Helms died, Tom quoted John Miller's reaction to a line in the New York Times obituary:
He "opposed civil rights"? Uh, no. He opposed a particular vision of them.
Miller didn't elaborate on that point -- but if you want a sense of what he might have meant, read a few passages from Helms's memoir, Here's Where I Stand. Let me remind you that this wasn't published in 1955 or 1965 -- it was published in 2005. It just sounds as if it emerges from the rankest swamps of the past. Four decades after the civil rights era, Helms still believed that the Jim Crow South was a place of happiness and harmony, an Eden destroyed by Big Gummint and "outside agitators." Oh, and some of his best friends were ... well, read for yourself:
... I did not advocate segregation, and I did not advocate aggravation. By that I mean that I thought it was wrong for people who did not know, and who did not care, about the relationships between neighbors and friends to force their ideas about how communities should work on the people who had built those communities in the first place. I believed right would prevail as people followed their consciences.
... I have always counted many blacks among my friends and believe that friendship was returned. We did not always agree about matters like demonstrations and the heavy-handed involvement of the government in shaping social policy -- because I believe those things slow true progress rather than help it. We did agree, however, that we are all people, made in the image of God and worthy of mutual respect.
During the turbulent times in the civil rights struggle, people from outside the South totally misunderstood the nature and intent of many Southerners. They thought opposition to the proposed laws meant hostility toward blacks. That simply was not true.
Many good people who supported the principle of progress for everyone could not agree to the destruction of one citizen's freedom in order to convey questionable "rights" to another. They believed forced social engineering was hazardous to the freedom we all deserve.
...It was one thing to work for the advancement of citizens throughout the nation; it was quite another to make of this a political issue and create difficult situations that fostered hatred and bigotry by polarizing the very people who most needed to work together for the good of their communities.
I felt that the citizens of my community, my state, and my region of the country were being battered by this new form of bigotry. I simply could not stay silent in the face of this assault -- and I didn't.
It has always been my belief that people of goodwill on all sides of an issue can resolve their differences without the intervention of the government. We will never know how integration might have been achieved in neighborhoods across our land, because the opportunity was snatched away by outside agitators who had their own agendas to advance. We certainly do know the price paid by the stirring of hatred, the encouragement of violence, the suspicion and distrust....
Yes, that's right -- it was all the fault of integrationists, for stirring up all that hatred, which wouldn't have existed otherwise. Why couldn't they have seen that people with no rights could have just sat around the cracker barrel with the people who had all the rights and just worked things out in a friendly manner?
Oh, and as for the Martin Luther King holiday, in 2005 Jesse Helms was still opposed to it:
...Dr. King was not always careful about his associates or his associations. Unfortunately, some of those associates were opposed to all that most Americans revere. When Dr. King was warned about these people and their records, he chose to let them remain in his circle of advisors.
Similarly, Dr. King was drawn into the Vietnam debate and went on record describing his own country as "the greatest purveyor of violence in the world today." At one point he likened this country to Nazi Germany.
... with all this, I simply could not go along. My remarks on the floor of the Senate on October 3, 1983, sum up why, to this day, I believe we were wrong in establishing this particular holiday.
...How much better it would have been for all Americans -- especially for those whose ancestors came to this country against their will -- to establish a day to honor the history of those generations of people who gave their all, as they worked, as they served in our military, as they built strong families and established communities, and as they embraced for themselves the miracle of America and encouraged their children to pursue their dreams.
In our emphasis on one man who emphasized discontent, we have overlooked the millions of people whose determination to look ahead instead of backward have done so much for us all. These are the people who deserve the parades and the holiday.
Funny how, as soon as we get it into our heads to honor a black man of greatness, it suddenly occurs to the Helmses of the world that we should make our next holiday some sort of Everybody Gets a Prize Day, because this honoring-the-great thing is a bad idea.
And I guess, y'know, "I have a dream" and all that weren't enough to qualify Dr. King as someone with a "determination to look ahead."
I'm told that this is "creeping shariah" in England, and the next step is that there won't be any more pork pies in the country, or Christian churches, and everyone will have to go around speaking Moslem all day:
Police sniffer dogs will have to wear bootees when searching the homes of Muslims so as not to cause offence.
Guidelines being drawn up by the Association of Chief Police Officers (Acpo) urge awareness of religious sensitivities when using dogs to search for drugs and explosives. The guidelines, to be published this year, were designed to cover mosques but have been extended to include other buildings.
Where Muslims object, officers will be obliged to use sniffer dogs only in exceptional cases. Where dogs are used, they will have to wear bootees with rubber soles....
Caroline Kisko, of the Kennel Club, said: "We would not condone any attempt to make search dogs wear special clothing, which could cause them distress."
Except, er, they were already wearing special clothing at times:
Police dogs at present are issued with footwear only at scenes of explosions to prevent them injuring their paws on broken glass.
Hmmm, explosions. Does this mean that dogs wore bootees at Ground Zero? On the most hallowed American ground imaginable? Yup.
Oh, and it's widely assumed here in New York that you have to put bootees on your dog all winter, because the salt tossed onto sidewalks to melt snow and ice is believed to be very irritating to dogs' paws.
So there may be some dispute about whether bootees are a necessary concession to religious sensitivities --
...Ibrahim Mogra, one of Britain's leading imams, said the measures were unnecessary: "In Islamic law the dog is not regarded as impure, only its saliva is. Most Islamic schools of law agree on that...."
-- but this strikes me as a minor adjustment at worst, more of a nuisance for dog handlers than dogs. And if it helps you get the job done, then do it.
*****
...Oh, and I guess this all happened after an ad giving the new telephone number of the police in Tayside, Scotland, was rejected by a few Muslim shopkeepers -- they didn't want to put it in their shop windows because it depicted a puppy. Well, fine -- I think the ad is cute overload, but that's me. If you're the cops, and you're doing community outreach, do you want to communicate with diverse groups of people, or do you want to have a self-righteousnessgasm? My vote is for the former -- and if it were in my neighborhood or my nation, I'd say, Sure, accommodate the sensibilities of Hasidic Jewish shopkeepers or fundamentalist Christian shopkeepers or whatever group if you want them to pit your number in their shop windows.
So nix the dog in the ad, then wait for time to do its work and for the grandchildren of these shopkeepers to perhaps question the old folks' proscriptions and grow up to be champion dog breeders.
Sunday, July 06, 2008
Thanks, Aimai, Kevin, Tom, Bulworth, and Kathy for holding the fort. I thought I'd have some brilliant insights to share with you tonight, but it's been an odd vacation (a now-resolved mini-health scare, a few too many visits from a few too many relatives), and now I think I need a vacation from my vacation. Or just a good night's sleep. So I'll see you tomorrow.
Saturday, July 05, 2008
Of course this flies in the face of the wingnut worldview, in which every Muslim is a potential violent jihadist. They could never entertain the idea that even among formerly violent groups there is a strong movement in favor of peace and co-existence.
But then, reading Zawahiri's arguments (on behalf of al Qaeda) against Fadl's revisions, I couldn't help thinking of typical wingnut illogic, of their chest-thumping belligerence and contempt for 'appeasement'. If the wingnuts had been born into the Islamic world, which side of the argument would they be on?
Friday, July 04, 2008
Whitewash
Unrepentant racist Jesse Helms is dead.
I hadn't planned to write anything about this...until I saw John Miller's complaint about the New York Times obit:
He "opposed civil rights"? Uh, no. He opposed a particular vision of them.Yes, Helms opposed the 'particular vision' of civil rights that rejected white supremacy. White supremacist civil rights he was okay with.
Digging around some more, I found a whole lot of extravagant praise for the guy. At The Corner, there wasn't a single disparaging word about him. The Heritage Foundation called him "a truly great American and champion of freedom". Ben Domenech hailed him as "a warrior and a patriot". To Robert Bluey, he was a "great man and true conservative champion".
Helms had one or two things to say himself, of course. Back in the '60s, for example, he said this:
No intelligent Negro citizen should be insulted by a reference to this very plain fact of life. It is time to face honestly and sincerely the purely scientific statistical evidence of natural racial distinction in group intellect. ... There is no bigotry either implicit or intended in such a realistic confrontation with the facts of life. ... Those who would undertake to solve the problem by merely spending more money, and by massive forced integration, may be doing the greatest injustice of all to the Negro.And then of course there's our own Flightsuit Boy, pre-eulogizing Helms back in 2005:
Throughout his long public career, Senator Helms has been a tireless advocate for the people of North Carolina; a stalwart defender of conservative values of limited government and individual liberty; an unwavering champion of those struggling for freedom; and a fearless defender of a culture of life.Or, in the corrected version:
Throughout his long public career, Senator Helms has been a tireless advocate for the white people of North Carolina; a stalwart defender of conservative values of limitedWhat else can they say? Helms helped to make the Republican party what it is today. To anathematize him would be to reject everything they stand for.governmentregulation of business and individual liberty for white people; an unwaveringchampionopponent of those struggling for freedom; and a fearless defender of a culture oflifefemale subjugation.
The Republicans are now running against a popular and charismatic candidate who stands a better than even chance of becoming the first African-American president. You think they wish they had someone just like Jesse Helms on their side today?
You bet your ass they do.
Thursday, July 03, 2008
Metaphors Gone Wild
Time has an interesting (if not terribly substantial) piece about the gambling styles of the two candidates (McCain plays craps; Obama plays poker). It's entertaining enough (check out McCain's handlers trying to keep him away from the craps table while he's campaigning) right up until the concluding paragraph, which veers off into silliness:
What do the candidates' gambling proclivities tell us about who they are? Politicians talk of their campaigns as grand contests of ideas. But in practice, the political battle is both a crapshoot and a poker game, a study in managing risk and in manipulating people. And there is no bigger gamble than a presidential run, which both candidates have conducted very differently this cycle. McCain's campaign, like his life, has been marked by its embrace of living dangerously and by clear runs of fortune and disappointment. Obama, meanwhile, has succeeded, no less remarkably, by diligently executing a premeditated strategy. But the general-election game is new to both men. And as the stakes rise, both know they'll need a little luck.There's nothing wrong with writing fluff about the candidates' recreational activities (although the New Yorker did it much better, at least where Obama is concerned). The problem is in trying to pretend that the fluff has Significance. The problem is that fluff like this is what passes for analysis these days.
BILL MOYERS: Do you think that people like David Addington and John Yoo and Jim Haynes, and the other lawyers you've mentioned who advised and were on the torture team, should ultimately be held responsible in court for what they did in government at this period of time?
PHILIPPE SANDS: If they were complicit in the commission of a crime, then they should be investigated. And if the facts show that there is a sufficient basis for proceeding to a prosecution, then they should be prosecuted. Lawyers are gatekeepers to legality and constitutionality. If the lawyers become complicit in a common plan to get around the law, to allow abuse, then yes, they should be liable.... Soldiers on the front lines who are doing their best in difficult circumstances, to protect the United States, should not be blamed for what was decided at the top.... If people like Doug Feith and Jim Haynes had said to me, "Look, Philippe. September the 11th came. The anniversary was coming. We were getting information that there were going to be more attacks. We had people that we were told had information that we need to do something about. And we therefore felt, in those circumstances, it was right to use all means appropriate and necessarily to get the information. But, with the benefit of hindsight, we realize we fell into error, we made a mistake. We accept responsibility for that. We will learn from those mistakes. We'll make damn sure it doesn't happen again." I didn't get that at all. There was not a hint of recognition that anything had gone wrong, nor a hint of recognition of individual responsibility. When you read these chapters, when you read my account with Doug Feith and with others, you will see the sort of weaseling out of individual responsibility, the total and abject failure to accept involvement. Read Mr. Feith's book. on how to fight the so-called war on terror. And it's as though the man had no involvement in the decisions relating to interrogation of detainees. And yet, as I describe in the book, the man was deeply involved in the decision making from step one. So it's about individual responsibility. And there's been an abject failure on that account.
Happy Fourth Of July to the Torturers of America!
Wednesday, July 02, 2008
I read this article in today's NYT and a couple of statements jumped out at me as being suspect:
Greg Craig, a Washington lawyer who advises the Obama campaign, said Tuesday in an interview that Mr. Obama had decided to support the compromise FISA legislation only after concluding it was the best deal possible.
“This was a deliberative process, and not something that was shooting from the hip,” Mr. Craig said. “Obviously, there was an element of what’s possible here. But he concluded that with FISA expiring, that it was better to get a compromise than letting the law expire.”
I've been wondering about the urgency here. Why, after all, is a "deal" needed? Why does what is "possible" have any meaning in relation to not doing anything? According to Craig, it's because without a "deal", FISA would "expire".
I was pretty sure this was incorrect, but I emailed Glenn Greenwald asking about it (Greenwald is also quoted in the NYT article).
Turns out Greenwald was working on a response to Craig's comments and has a post up about it. Wanna read it? Here it go:
Craig's statement is flat-out false. FISA -- enacted in 1978 and amended many times to accommodate modern communications technology -- has no expiration date. The Protect America Act, which Congress enacted last August to legalize warrantless eavesdropping on Americas, had a 6-month sunset provision and thus already expired back in February, restoring FISA as the governing law. Thus, if Congress does nothing now, FISA will continue indefinitely to govern the Government's power to spy on the communications of Americans. It doesn't expire. What Craig said in defense of Obama is just wrong.
(snip)
The issue is not -- as one extremely confused Obama-cheering blogger put it -- that Obama has done "something contrary to what conventional wisdom as dictated by a small coterie of prominent bloggers agrees with," nor is it -- as an equally confused, Obama-cheering Ed Kilgore put it -- that Obama is "stray[ing] from Democratic Party orthodoxy or from strict down-the-line partisanship" by "expressing heretical thoughts on FISA" (incidentally, it's amazing how the rule of law, the Fourth Amendment and accountability for Bush lawbreaking have now -- in service of defending Obama -- all been instantaneously reduced to nothing more than quirky, self-absorbed, petty blogger "dictates," and Obama's disregarding of those core political values is a bold demonstration that he won't be held hostage to anyone's narrow partisan demands).
This last paragraph of Greenwald's is what really gets my goat. The Ed Kilgore's of the world are all about doing what is apparently not "down the line partisanship", unmindful of the substance of the matter.
cross posted at If I Ran the Zoo
McCain became visibly angry when I asked him to explain how his Vietnam experience prepared him for the Presidency.
"Please," he said, recoiling back in his seat in distaste at the very question...
McCain then collected himself and apologized for his initial reaction.
"I kind of reacted the way I did because I have a reluctance to talk about my experiences," he said, noting that he has huge admiration for the "heroes" who served with him in the POW camp and said the experience taught him to love the U.S. because he missed it so much.
"I am always reluctant to talk about these things," McCain said.
Asked about one of his former jailors from the notorious Hanoi Hilton who has now endorsed his candidacy for President, McCain chuckled.
"Yeah, I saw that," he said. "He also said that he and I used to have these nice, long philosophical chats. The ones that I recall is, confess or else."
Glenn Greenwald's post this morning reminds me of another troubling thing Obama has recently said:
Smearing people as anti-Semites for cheap political gain is repellent in its own right and merits a response. But this tactic is particularly dangerous now, as the pressure is obviously being ratcheted up in numerous circles to pursue a far more bellicose policy towards Iran. Responding to the types of disgusting smears that are in Rubin's column and many other places, Obama not only appeared before AIPAC last month and vowed that "the danger from Iran is grave, it is real, and my goal will be to eliminate this threat"; that Iran's "Quds force has rightly been labeled a terrorist organization"; and "I will do everything in my power to prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon," but also, when asked last week by a Fox News host to play a "word association game" whereby he should say the first word that comes into his mind, Obama -- when the word was "Iran" -- responded as follows: "threat."
Why is the "danger" from Iran "grave" and "real"? Because they are reported to be seeking the technology that serves as the basis for the actual nuclear weapons possessed by our Israeli friends, and by others in the region and around the world?
It's hard to believe that with all we now know about the political hustle that was played on us beginning about six years ago, that the language of our political elites, and our most liberal and informed of them, regarding another oil-enriched, Middle Eastern, and largely feeble country continues to be as loose and credulous as this.
While I hope that before the next war there is some kind of appropriate skepticism in the media and in Congress, I suspect that the next war will not include such niceities as a UN Resolution or an "authorization" vote in Congress.
WASHINGTON — The military trainers who came to Guantánamo Bay in December 2002 based an entire interrogation class on a chart showing the effects of “coercive management techniques” for possible use on prisoners, including “sleep deprivation,” “prolonged constraint,” and “exposure.”
What the trainers did not say, and may not have known, was that their chart had been copied verbatim from a 1957 Air Force study of Chinese Communist techniques used during the Korean War to obtain confessions, many of them false, from American prisoners.
The recycled chart is the latest and most vivid evidence of the way Communist interrogation methods that the United States long described as torture became the basis for interrogations both by the military at the base at Guantánamo Bay, Cuba, and by the Central Intelligence Agency.
Tuesday, July 01, 2008
Breaking...
After accusing Senator Webb of working ("collaborating") with the presumptive nominee of Senator Webb's own Party, the presumptive GOP nominee was seen yelling at some neighborhood children to get off his lawn.
Maha takes Arthur Silber to task for his cockeyed post about Obama supporters (Instapproved!) and, as usual, nails it. Here's an excerpt:
My primary reason for supporting Obama is that his considerable organizational skills and his resonance with younger voters could bring about a political realignment and a shift in political culture that progressivism can build on in the years to come. I keep saying I don’t think he’s liberal Jesus and that I expect him to make mistakes and take wrong turns. I am less interested in what I think he will do than in what I think he might help to enable, which is an America in which progressive ideas at least can get a fair hearing.Read it all.
Some of his recent turns are disappointing, particularly his stand on the FISA bill. I’m not making excuses for that. I realize he’s probably doing it for political expediency to help him win the election in November, but I still don’t like it.
But does that make McCain the better alternative? Hardly.
One of the frustrations I had during the Endless Primary was that so many Clinton supporters clearly were operating on some level of fanaticism even as they screamed about Obamabots. You couldn’t talk to them. They’d literally get wild-eyed and dredge up dark suspicions about Obama’s motivations and possible ties to right-wing extremism, suspicions based on nothing but their own overheated imaginations. And I do think the Clinton campaign cultivated this fanaticism to some extent, particularly as time went on and it was about the only thing the campaign had going for it.
But, ultimately, fanaticism is about projecting. Fanatical Clinton supporters were not fixated on the real Senator Clinton, but on a Hillary Clinton who lived only in their own heads. This is part of the nature of fanaticism.
(crossposted at Rumproast)
...but why in the hell is Jowly Joe's approval rating still so high in Connecticut? What's going on in the Nutmeg State? Might as well rename it Neoconnecticut. The place has really gone to hell since I moved out over two decades ago. At least Blackie's hasn't closed yet. One dog piled high with their stellar relish can wash away just about any pain, even the knowledge that McSame's mush-mouthed lapdog is still viewed favorably by nearly half of the residents of my former home state.