Monday, February 11, 2019

THE 2020 PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION WILL BE A REFERENDUM ON ONE CANDIDATE -- AND IT MIGHT NOT BE TRUMP

The real and (mostly) imagined scandals of Hillary Clinton received more coverage during the 2016 campaign than the very real, very serious should-have-been-scandals of Donald Trump. The standard explanation is that most political insiders assumed that Clinton would win, so the press was getting a head start on holding the next president accountable.

In an ideal world, a presidential election with no incumbent wouldn't be a referendum on one candidate rather than the other. Sometimes, as in 2008, it's a referendum on the previous president. That was a year when Democrats were fortunate: George W. Bush was so reviled, and John McCain had done so little to distance himself from Bush, that much of the public was voting against the status quo. The outcome that year is also a tribute to the Obama team's campaign skills; the 2012 election was also a referendum on the incumbent Obama's opponent, who was successfully (and accurately) portrayed as a rich elitist with no ability to feel the pain of ordinary citizens.

But far more presidential elections in recent years have been referendums on Democrats -- even when the Democrat on the ballot isn't in office. The 1988 election was a referendum on Mike Dukakis rather than the Reagan/Bush record. The 2004 election was a referendum on John Kerry, alleged Swift Boat liar. The 2000 election was a referendum on Al Gore and the sins ascribed to him (earth tones! lying about inventing the Internet!); oddly, after Bill Clinton's polarizing presidency, that election wasn't a referendum on the Big Dog.

It wasn't a referendum on Clinton because Clinton was very popular as he left office, just as Barack Obama was popular in 2016. In both cases, the right-wing noise machine knew it had to make the election a referendum on the Democratic candidate rather than the sitting president (or the Republican candidate). In both cases, the mainstream media eagerly fell in line.

But surely this election will be referendum on the incumbent, won't it? The 2018 midterms were about Trump. How can 2020 not be?

Well, we're seeing signs that it will be a referendum on the Democrat. Here's the lede of a Washington Post news analysis:
Sen. Elizabeth Warren’s presidential rollout has been upended by questions about why she called herself Native American decades ago. The governor and attorney general of Virginia are under fire for darkening their faces in a racist cultural appropriation that has rocked the state and placed their careers in limbo.

The past week has seen a combustible collision of politics focused on racial and ethnic identity, highlighting how much the national discourse is being fragmented not only by partisan loyalties, but also by factors innately personal.

As both the Warren and Virginia cases show, Democrats are engaged in a vigorous debate over how to talk about identity politics at a time when the country’s growing diversity is scrambling the electoral map, and as a diverse field is gathering to run for president.
Warren's presidential rollout hasn't been upended, as far as Democratic voters are concerned; she's meeting enthuasiastic crowds and she's being asked questions about issues, not about ancestry. But the media perception of her rollout is that it's been upended, just as the media perception of Amy Klobuchar's rollout is that she's gravely wounded by reports of tyrannical behavior as a boss. Kamala Harris is in trouble because her record as a prosecutor wasn't ideally progressive, and because her stated desire to get rid of private health insurance is assumed to be too frightening for the heartland.

Oh, and the whole party is doomed because ideas Democrats are discussing are believed to be too progressive. Politico headline: "Republicans Can't Wait to Debate ‘Medicare for All.’" Axios headline: "Trump's Lifeline: Democrats' Socialism Surge." Headline for an opinion piece by National Journal's Josh Kraushaar:



The Democrats and their ideas should be vetted. But some of this isn't vetting -- it's the media telling us that Democrats are outside the Overton window (while Trump is presumably within the window, because as president he has a large part in defining where the window is).

The right will work hard to assassinate the Democratic nominee's character and marginalize his or her ideas. That's to be expected. But the mainstream press doesn't have to cooperate. Yet apparently it will.

Does the MSM assume, again, that the Democrat will inevitably be the winner? I don't think so -- the press was burned by 2016 and now realizes that Trump can win an election. I'd say that the press is no better at resisting the ref-working of the right than it was in 2016 or 2000 or 1988. Also, the plutocrats are coming off the sidelines and attacking economic progressivism, with the Beltway press parroting every corpocrat's complaint.

So the 2020 election really might be a referendum on the Democrat, and on Democrats in general, while Trump skates.

Sunday, February 10, 2019

GALLUP PRODUCES IRRESPONSIBLE CLICKBAIT FOR XENOPHOBES, PRESIDENT RISES TO BAIT


Nice work, Gallup. I hope you're proud.



And here are some headlines from the online right:



All this is based on an alarmist, clickbait-y blog post from Gallup's chairman, Jim Clifton:
What If There Were 42 Million at the Border?

Here's a good question about caravans: How many more are coming?

Gallup asked the whole population of Latin America. There are 33 countries in Latin America and the Caribbean. Roughly 450 million adults live in the region. Gallup asked them, "Would you like to move to another country permanently if you could?"

A whopping 27% said "yes."

So this means roughly 120 million would like to migrate somewhere.

The next question Gallup asked was, "Where would you like to move?"

Of those who want to leave their Latin American country permanently, 35% said they want to go to the United States.

The Gallup analytics estimate is that 42 million want to come to the U.S.

Forty-two million seekers of citizenship or asylum are watching to determine exactly when and how is the best time to make the move. This suggests that open borders could potentially attract 42 million Latin Americans. A full 5 million who are planning to move in the next 12 months say they are moving to the U.S.
Gallup was pushing this story back in November. As I noted at the time; Breitbart responded then with a scare story titled "Gallup: Five Million Central Americans Want to Move to U.S."

But the Gallup story at the time included a caveat:
... unlike the caravan of Central American migrants who are currently on the move, most people who desire to migrate will never try to make their way to the U.S. Desire remains only that. Gallup typically finds that the percentage of those who have plans to move is substantially lower than the percentage who would like to move, and even fewer are actively making preparations to do so.

Central America is no different in this regard. For example, in Honduras, whose residents make up a large percentage of the migrant caravan, about half of adults (47%) say they would like to move to another country permanently if they could, but about 9% are planning to move in the next year -- and 2% are actively preparing to do so.
In the post cited by Trump, which appeared on Friday, the chairman decided to leave all that out, presumably in order to induce maximum right-wing outrage. (Also omitted: the fact that not everyone who claims to be "actively preparing" a move will actually follow through. Also, the survey doesn't distinguish those who plan to migrate in a strictly legal fashion from those who don't.)

And as a point of comparison, let's go to Gallup's Migration Research Center and see how many Americans want to leave the country.
... the 16% of Americans overall who said in 2017 and again in 2018 that they would like to permanently move to another country -- if they could -- is higher than the average levels during either the George W. Bush (11%) or Barack Obama administration (10%).
And what's their preferred destination?
In 2018, more than one in four Americans (26%) who would like to move named Canada as the place they would like to go, up from 12% in 2016.
So let's run the numbers. The population of the U.S. is approximately 328 million. If 16% want to move somewhere else permanently and 26% of the would-be movers want to go to Canada, that means more than 13 million Americans would like to move to Canada. The total population of Canada is approximately 37 million. (Maybe Canadians should build a wall.)

The estimated number of Americans who want to move to any country is more than 52 million. It was also in the tens of millions during the Bush and Obama presidencies.

But the State Department says that, as of 2016, there were only 9 million (non-military) U.S. citizens living abroad. Which means that the vast majority of the tens of millions of Americans who wanted to leave in the Bush and Obama years didn't leave. The same is likely to be true of the 52 million who want to leave now. And the same is likely to be true of the Latin Americans who say they want to leave. Even the ones who claim to be making plans aren't all going to emigrate.

But Gallup effectively recycled the numbers and got mentioned in a lot of ooga-booga stories in the xenophobic press, so it's all good, right?

Saturday, February 09, 2019

AN AUDIENCE OF 63 MILLION

The acting attorney general was rude and uncooperative in House testimony yesterday. Writing about this, The Atlantic's Natasha Bertrand offers the standard explanation:
It took about five minutes of questioning for the acting attorney general to provoke gasps and jeers in the congressional hearing room. “Your five minutes are up,” Matthew Whitaker ... told the House Judiciary Committee’s Democratic chairman Jerry Nadler. Nadler cracked a smile, but from that point on the rules of engagement seemed clear: Whitaker ... appeared to be playing to an audience of one.
Beltway journalists love to use the phrase "an audience of one" in the Trump era. It's often argued that Fox & Friends and various Fox evening shows customize their programming for the same "audience of one."

Bertrand suggests that Whitaker was trying to please Trump. She thinks he might be angling for another job in the administration, possibly chief of staff. But Whitaker didn't focus on gratifying Trump's ego. He focused on carrying out Trump's strategy. Axios's Mike Allen explains:
President Trump watched live cable coverage of yesterday's chippy Hill testimony by acting Attorney General Matt Whitaker, and liked what he saw.

... "He liked the combative approach," said an outside West Wing adviser familiar with Trump's thinking. "He thought the Democrats were grandstanding." Inside the White House, according to the adviser, here were the lessons learned: Do not give an inch, push back, resist, delay, deflect.

... The White House recognizes that it can do little to resist the House Dems' demands for testimony. Republicans just hope that over time, they can argue to their base that Dems have been guilty of overreach and "show trials."

A Republican political operative and Capitol Hill veteran told me: "It doesn’t take long for ordinary voters — who are very different from people in Washington — to start seeing participating committee members as pompous, rude and belittling, and begin to side with whoever is sitting in the hot seat."
Whitaker's insolence wasn't just aimed at "an audience of one." It was aimed at audience of 63 million -- the people who voted for Trump in 2016. Like Brett Kavanaugh, Whitaker was trying to fire them up. (GOP congressman Doug Collins, who did some anti-Democratic ranting of his own, was Lindsey Graham to Whitaker's Kavanaugh. Collins's histrionics will probably make him a Fox News star now.)

I don't like the "audience of one" argument. It implies that the only result of these actions is a dopamine rush in Trump's brain from all the flattery. In fact, when Fox reaches out to the president, it's to push the national agenda rightward, because that's what the Fox TV audience wants (and, on most issues, what the Murdoch family wants). This has real-world consequences. Whitaker was previewing a strategy that Trump's people will use in every hearing held by House Democrats: portray the investigations as "overrreach and show trials" and discredit all efforts to hold Trump and his circle accountable. I don't know how many Americans might be receptive to this, but I think it's nearly half the population.

I say that because the president's approval numbers are bouncing back, after a stretch of time during the shutdown when even friendly polls like Rasmussen had the president deeply under water. A few weeks ago, consecutive polls from Rasmussen had Trump's approval rating below his approval rating by double digits -- 43%/55% and 44%/56%. Now he's back where he usually is in Rasmussen surveys -- 50%/49%. The Hill HarrisX poll also had Trump down by 12 during the shutdown, at 44%/56%. Now he's at 47%/53%. Expect similar bouncebacks in other polls.

Trump still has a large base of support. No matter what various investigators find, most of these people will remain loyal to Trump. They'll dismiss all investigations as overreach, no matter how shocking the revelations seem to us. And they vote, so we have to outvote them. It's not at all certain we'll manage to do that.

Friday, February 08, 2019

NO ONE EVEN BOTHERS TO ASSUME THAT TRUMP WILL LIVE UP TO HIS OWN PRINCIPLES

The Washington Post provides more evidence -- as if any more were needed -- that Donald Trump is an immigration hypocrite:
The Washington Post spoke with 16 men and women from Costa Rica and other Latin American countries, including six in Santa Teresa de Cajon, who said they were employed at the Trump National Golf Club Bedminster. All of them said they worked for Trump without legal status — and that their managers knew....

The brightly painted homes that line the road in Santa Teresa de Cajon, many paid for by wages earned 4,000 miles away, are the fruits of a long-running pipeline of illegal workers to the president’s course, one that carried far more than a few unauthorized employees who slipped through the cracks.

Soon after Trump broke ground at Bedminster in 2002 with a golden shovel, this village emerged as a wellspring of low-paid labor for the private club, which charges tens of thousands of dollars to join. Over the years, dozens of workers from Costa Rica went north to fill jobs as groundskeepers, housekeepers and dishwashers at Bedminster, former employees said. The club hired others from El Salvador, Mexico and Guatemala....
This is just the latest of several stories about the Trump Organization's hiring practices at Bedminster. There's no ambiguity here: If you're outraged at employers who hire the undocumented at low wages, you should be furious at Donald Trump.

But I'm not seeing any suggestion, either in the mainstream press or in the right-wing media, that Trump might have trouble selling his hard-line message on immigration to the public now that we know this. I'm not seeing what we saw -- also in the Post -- when a form submitted to the Texas Bar in which Elizabeth Warren described herself as a Native American was unearthed:
The matter now threatens to overshadow the image Warren has sought to foster of a truth-telling consumer advocate who would campaign for the White House as a champion for the working class. Instead, she is now seeking to combat the portrait of someone who for years was insufficiently sensitive to a long-oppressed minority. The matter also is arising at a time when issues of racial and cultural identity are increasingly sensitive in the Democratic Party.
(As Charlie Pierce wrote, "if you can tell me how this little tidbit somehow devalues and/or calls into question everything that Senator Professor Warren has done in the field of consumer advocacy and middle-class economic equality, you're smarter than I am and can cover the campaign for The Washington Post.")

I'm also not seeing anything like this, which appeared in the Post after we learned about a racist photo on Virginia governor Ralph Northam's medical school yearbook page (via Charlie Pierce again):
But a Democratic member of Congress, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss the sensitive topic, said the Northam revelation may potentially undercut the contrast Democrats are seeking in their messaging if he remains in office. “It could complicate the message,” this Democrat said.
After every bad story involving a Democrat, the media stokes the expectation of a second-order effect: Not only is Elizabeth Warren expected to be embarrassed about a decades-old form on which she called herself a Native American, she now should expect to lose credibility when talking about the disproportionate power of the wealthy, which is a completely unrelated subject. Not only is a racist photo of Ralph Northam a mark of shame for the governor, it's expected to be toxic for everyone in the Democratic Party for the next 21 months, until Election Day 2020.

But Trump? As far as I can determine, not even Ann Coulter has called him on the hiring at Bedminster. Hey, he's a hypocrite -- ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. It's okay if you're a Republican.

REPUBLICANS ARE THE PROVINCIALS WHO DON'T UNDERSTAND MILLIONS OF THEIR FELLOW CITIZENS

Headline of an opinion piece by Kimberley Strassel of The Wall Street Journal:



AOC is a "secret Republican weapon for 2020"? Go on.
The Republican Party has a secret weapon for 2020. It’s especially effective because it’s stealthy: The Democrats seem oblivious to its power. And the GOP needn’t lift a finger for it to work. All Republicans have to do is sit back and watch 29-year-old Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez ... exist.

AOC, as she’s better known, today exists largely in front of the cameras. In a few months she’s gone from an unknown New York bartender to the democratic socialist darling of the left and its media hordes. Her megaphone is so loud that she rivals Speaker Nancy Pelosi as the face of the Democratic Party. Republicans don’t know whether to applaud or laugh. Most do both.
We're told that she's "set off a fratricidal war on the left." (Did you hear shots fired? Me either.) We're expected to react in horror because she's "called the American system of wealth creation 'immoral.'" (That opinion seems to be shared by much of America, including a surprising number of Republicans.) And much scorn is heaped on her Green New Deal proposal. ("It’s a GOP dream.... The Green New Deal encapsulates everything Americans fear from government, all in one bonkers resolution.")

Conclusion:
Ms. Ocasio-Cortez is a freight train gaining speed by the day—and helping Republicans with every passing minute.
This is a common perception on the right:



Ocasio-Cortez is just doing what many Republicans in Congress have done for decades, but in mirror image: She's staking out positions that more moderate members of her party won't, something she can do because her voters are fine with it. When they were in office, Jesse Helms was to the right of his fellow Republicans on race, as was James Inhofe on climate. They were proudly contemptuous of both liberalism and moderation -- but Americans voted for Republican presidents, and for somewhat more reasonable Republican members of Congress in other states, because they were on the local ballots, not Helms or Inhofe. Ocasio-Cortez hopes to ultimately pull her party to the left the way Helms and Inhofe wanted to pull theirs further right. (Helms and Inhofe got their wish.)

Meanwhile, Strassel and Shapiro treat Ocasio-Cortez as if she's polarizing and widely hated. Morning Consult found recently that that's not true at all: Her approval/disapproval numbers are 24%/28%. She's underwater, but far less than, say, the president of the United States.

What Strassel and Shapiro can't imagine is that a lot of people like Ocasio-Cortez, and a lot of people are receptive to her ideas. I'm reminded of the standard critique of the mainstream press in the wake of the 2016 election: Coastal elitist reporters missed the Trump phenomenon because they know nothing about millions of their fellow citizens, for whom Trump was a welcome messenger. I think that may have been true before November 2016, but it's certainly not true now -- now we all know what every blue-collar retiree sitting in a Pennsylvania diner thinks. But people like Strassel and Shapiro don't know what non-conservatives think. They're oblivious to the existence of people who might respond to Ocasio-Cortez, or at least to Kamala Harris or Elizabeth Warren.

Conservatives are the blinkered provincials now. They're certain that AOC alienates everyone within earshot. Maybe they need to make some pilgrimages to Democratic and progressive strongholds and do a little anthropology.

Thursday, February 07, 2019

IS THIS THE WORD THAT MAKES POPULAR PROGRESSIVE IDEAS UNPOPULAR?

Farhad Manjoo, a former tech writer for The New York Times who's now writing op-eds for the paper, signs on to a growing movement:
Abolish Billionaires

Last fall, Tom Scocca, editor of the essential blog Hmm Daily, wrote a tiny, searing post that has been rattling around my head ever since.

“Some ideas about how to make the world better require careful, nuanced thinking about how best to balance competing interests,” he began. “Others don’t: Billionaires are bad. We should presumptively get rid of billionaires. All of them.”

Mr. Scocca ... offered a straightforward argument for kneecapping the wealthiest among us. A billion dollars is wildly more than anyone needs, even accounting for life’s most excessive lavishes. It’s far more than anyone might reasonably claim to deserve, however much he believes he has contributed to society.

... Dan Riffle, [Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez's] policy adviser, recently changed his Twitter name to “Every Billionaire Is A Policy Failure.” Last week, HuffPost asked, “Should Billionaires Even Exist?”

I suspect the question is getting so much attention because the answer is obvious: Nope. Billionaires should not exist — at least not in their present numbers, with their current globe-swallowing power, garnering this level of adulation, while the rest of the economy scrapes by.
I'm for imposing some serious taxes on the wealthy. I would not be displeased if the result was that the superwealthy were now substantially less wealthy. (They'd still be stinking rich by any normal person's standard.) If this were accompanied by a better standard of living for non-rich people, I'd say that was an excellent tradeoff. And if it meant no one was a billionaire anymore, I'd be perfectly content with that.

But if economic progressives intend to memeify the phrase "abolish billionaires," as seems to be the case, that's going to have an unintended impact on how we talk about inequality. Americans are very much on board with the idea of significantly higher taxes on the rich ...
A plan from first-term Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) to slap a 70 percent marginal rate on income earned over $10 million clocked in at 59 percent support in a recent Hill/HarrisX poll.

The new POLITICO/Morning Consult poll, conducted Feb. 1-2, found that 61 percent favor a proposal like the “wealth tax” recently laid out by Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) that would levy a 2 percent tax on those with a net worth over $50 million and 3 percent on those worth over $1 billion. Just 20 percent opposed the idea.
... But I predict that the idea of abolishing billionaires will poll badly. Americans today are resentful of the disproportionate wealth and power of the rich, but Americans have never wanted to close the door to the possibility of being rich. They're not going to like "abolish."

It's not exactly analogous, but Americans don't like the idea of abolishing ICE:
A new POLITICO/Morning Consult poll shows that most voters oppose eliminating Immigration and Customs Enforcement — the homeland security agency some liberal Democrats have called for abolishing.

Only 1 in 4 voters in the poll, 25 percent, believe the federal government should get rid of ICE. The majority, 54 percent, think the government should keep ICE. Twenty-one percent of voters are undecided.
Polling shows that Americans oppose a border wall and support a path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants in the country now. They've expressed outrage at family separation. But abolishing ICE is a step too far.

Conservatives like to portray liberal/progressive ideas as totalitarian. (Hell, conservatives like to portray the existence of government itself as totalitarian. They think taxes at any level are theft.)

Most Americans don't think that way -- but slogans with the word "abolish" do sound a bit totalitarian. It may not matter -- the "Abolish ICE" slogan didn't prevent Democrats from making big gains in the 2018 midterms (and probably won the Democrats a fair number of votes in more left-leaning districts). But "abolish" slogans carry risks. There'll be polling on "abolish billionaires" eventually. We'll see how popular the idea is.


TRUMP'S CATCHPHRASE DUNNING-KRUGERISM


The president thinks he has a catchy new catchphrase....




Trump is our Dunning-Kruger president -- he believes he knows more than the experts about foreign policy, trade, foreign intelligence, economics, tariffs, science.... Among his other areas of expertise, he seems to believe that he's the great phrasemaker of our era. To give him his due, a lot of his grade-school insults during the 2016 campaign caught on -- Crooked Hillary, Low Energy Jeb. But he had a distinct advantage then: He was going after careerist politicians who were, for the most part, not widely loved.

But it's harder now that he's president. Thirty times on Twitter, Trump has tried to brand Robert Mueller's team the "Angry Democrats" (either "13 Angry Democrats" or "17 Angry Democrats"; I won't bore you with the reason for the different numbers). Has this caught on? It really hasn't caught on even with conservatives. It's like one of those shibboleths you see on right-wing discussion boards -- a reference to an obscure fact or half-truth that was talked about for a few days on Fox and Rush Limbaugh's show, then dropped for fresher content, all while non-conservatives had no idea that the discussion was even taking place. "Angry Democrats" has not been one of Trump's successful branding efforts, although he clearly doesn't know that.

I don't think "presidential harassment" will catch on either. Trump's campaign nicknames were acts of aggression, while his catchphrases in response to the investigations he's facing all paint him as a whiny victim. I know that Republican voters have liked self-pity in their heroes at least since Nixon, but self-pity is the opposite of the chest-thumping bluster that helped Trump to victory in 2016. It's off brand. Besides, a significant portion of Trump's base consists of QAnon believers, who think Trump is just biding his time until he's ready to bring all his enemies to justice for their many crimes. The Trump of QAnon legend is powerful, although he's concealing that fact until the moment is right. He's not a victim, which is the impression "presidential harassment" conveys. So no, it won't catch on.

Wednesday, February 06, 2019

TRUMP'S APPROVAL NUMBERS WERE GOOD LAST NIGHT -- ALMOST AS GOOD AS OBAMA'S COMPARABLE NUMBERS

Some on the right will tell you that the instant-poll numbers for President Trump's State of the Union address were extraordinary.



What were the numbers? Here's what CBS told us:



But let's compare those numbers with the numbers for the State of the Union address that began Barack Obama's third year in office. Like Trump, he'd just suffered significant congressional losses for his party in the midterms. So how'd Obama do in 2011?



An overwhelming majority of Americans approved of the overall message in President Obama's State of the Union speech on Tuesday night, according to a CBS News poll of speech watchers.

According to the poll, which was conducted online by Knowledge Networks immediately after the president's address, 91 percent of those who watched the speech approved of the proposals Mr. Obama put forth during his remarks. Only nine percent disapproved.

Last year, 83 percent of viewers approved of Mr. Obama's State of the Union remarks.
And what about CNN?
A CNN poll conducted by ssrs following President Trump's State of the Union address Tuesday night found that 59% of viewers had a very positive reaction to the speech, 17% had a somewhat positive reaction and 23% had a negative reaction.
That's a total of 76% approval. How did Obama do at CNN in 2011?
CNN ... ran an instant poll with its Opinion Research partner. They found that 52 percent of those who had watched the speech had a "very positive" reaction and an additional 32 percent had an "somewhat positive" response. An overall positive mark of 84 percent ain't bad.
The overall positive number was 84% to Trump's 76%. And while Trump's "very positive" number was higher, there may be an explanation for that:
President Donald Trump's State of the Union address drew a deeply Republican audience, which largely gave the President strong reviews for his address from the House chamber, according to a CNN poll conducted by SSRS immediately following the speech.

... the audience had the largest partisan tilt measured in any CNN instant poll following a presidential address to Congress dating back to 2001 -- viewers were roughly 17 points more likely than the general public to identify as Republicans, and were largely fans of the President.
And CBS said the same thing:
As is often the case in State of the Union addresses, the people who watched tonight's speech leaned more towards the president's own party, at least compared to Americans overall. In the latest CBS national poll released last month, 25 percent of Americans identified themselves as Republicans. Among those who watched Tuesday night's address, that figure was 43 percent, and Republicans helped bolster the overall approval of the address.
So don't take those numbers too seriously.

TRUMP WOULD RATHER FIGHT THAN WIN

Here are a couple of tweets from Ezra Klein in response to last night's State of the Union address:




Klein wrote this at Vox after the speech:
I’ll be honest. There were parts of President Donald Trump’s 2019 State of the Union that I liked. But then I remembered the reality of his presidency.

I liked when he called on the country to “reject the politics of revenge, resistance, and retribution, and embrace the boundless potential of cooperation, compromise, and the common good.” But then I remembered America is only 10 days past the longest government shutdown in history, which Trump triggered when he refused to compromise or cooperate with Democrats. And I remembered that Trump’s acting chief of staff just said the president is willing to do it again....

I liked when Trump said that the nation’s priority should be to “lower the cost of health care and prescription drugs, and to protect patients with preexisting conditions.” But then I remembered that his policies had led to 7 million more people becoming uninsured, and that he had fought (and failed) to pass legislation ending protections for preexisting conditions.

I liked when Trump told Congress that an infrastructure bill was “not an option,” but “a necessity.” Then I remembered that Trump has been president for years now, that he had control of Congress for most of that time, and that he has never prioritized either proposing or passing an infrastructure package.
There were more examples. Klein went on to write:
Trump’s speech tonight could have been a victory lap. He could have bragged about the roads being repaired and the bridges being built by his infrastructure bill. He could have talked about the lives being saved by his massive mobilization to staunch the opioid crisis. He could have pointed to tax cuts focused on the middle-class, a border wall built in exchange for protecting DREAMers, a health care effort that did what he promised and expanded coverage while cutting deductibles. And all of it would have come in context of the strongest economy since the 1990s.
But the president many observers told us to expect -- a guy who has few political convictions and just wants a win -- is not the real Trump. The Trump of Klein's second tweet -- "The president you get when you just let Trump talk" -- is not the real Trump. The real Trump is the Trump who's very easily talked into fighting, even if the fights he's talked into are fights he can't win.

Trump's nature means that he can't even compromise strategically. Remember the George W. Bush presidency? It started with the bipartisan No Child Left Behind education bill, proposed by Bush three days after his inaugural. In retrospect it's clear what Bush was doing -- he was reaching across the aisle once, in a high-profile way, before reverting to a high level of partisanship. It worked. After proposing No Child Left Behind, Bush got his tax cuts, his deregulation, and his wars.

An infrastructure bill in the first days of 2017 could easily have been Trump's No Child Left Behind. Chuck Schumer was eager for it. If it had been a real infrastructure bill with real money for real projects and not a phony attempt to make the rich richer by allowing them to leverage the bill's incentives in order to fund for-profit projects, it would have passed easily. But Trump, for all his ideological inconsistency earlier in his life, discovered Fox News a decade or so ago, and now he's in a partisan gang, and he likes it that way. It suits his nature. He's had some wins -- tax cuts, judges -- but they've been partisan wins masterminded by veteran GOP partisans.

There's are pleasure centers in Trump's brain that light up when he's approaching a moment of agreement with an opponent. But he doesn't like compromise -- it makes him feel "weak," one of his most-used words -- so he'd rather have the much greater rush of pleasure he gets from telling the opponent to fuck off.

Pay no attention to the "nice" Trump we saw in parts of last night's speech. We know that the Kumbaya words in Trump's speech were his staff's idea, an effort to start selling Trump and the GOP to swing voters ahead of the 2020 elections, and we know from Peter Baker of The New York Times that Trump wasn't pleased.
As [Trump] and his team have drafted his address in recent days, he has groused about the text, complaining that it is too gentle on Democrats, according to people briefed on the matter.

The president has sought to sharpen various lines, and while aides have urged him to congratulate Speaker Nancy Pelosi on her ascension after the November midterm elections, which handed control of the House to Democrats, they were not entirely clear that he would.
Oh, and at whose behest was this leaked?
For public consumption, President Trump planned to use his State of the Union address on Tuesday night to appeal for bipartisan unity. But at a private lunch for television anchors earlier in the day, he offered searing assessments of a host of Democrats.

Mr. Trump dismissed former Vice President Joseph R. Biden Jr. as “dumb,” called Senator Chuck Schumer of New York a “nasty son of a bitch” and mocked Gov. Ralph Northam of Virginia, who he said “choked like a dog” at a news conference where he tried to explain a racist yearbook photo, according to multiple people in the room.
Many White House leaks are embarrassing to the president, but I'm sure he wanted this out, because the speech he was handed to read last night wasn't the real Trump. The real Trump is a nasty SOB.

Tuesday, February 05, 2019

RIGHT-WING SITE'S SOURCES FOR SEXUAL ASSAULT STORY ARE THE KINDS OF PEOPLE RIGHT-WINGERS USUALLY DEMONIZE

The website Big League Politics -- described by The Wall Street Journal as a "pro-Trump outlet" that's "backed by GOP operatives" -- was the first to report on claims that Virginia's lieutenant governor, Justin Fairfax, sexually assaulted a woman at the 2004 Democratic convention. NPR now reports that the woman -- identified by Big League Politics and other news outlets as Vanessa Tyson, now a research fellow at Stanford University -- has retained high-profile legal counsel.
A California woman who has accused Virginia Lt. Gov. Justin Fairfax of sexually assaulting her 15 years ago has hired the same law firm that represented Christine Blasey Ford in her allegations against then-Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh....

The woman making the accusation against Fairfax has retained Katz, Marshall and Banks, a Washington, D.C.-based firm, and is consulting with her attorneys about next steps, according to a source close to the legal team.
It's curious to me that right-wingers are uncritically reporting these allegations, and that they're not immediately attacking Tyson for hiring this firm, given the nasty attacks they launched when it was first revealed that the firm represented Blasey Ford.

Back in September, when Debra Katz of Katz, Marshall and Banks was identified as Blasey Ford's lawyer, there were headlines in the right-wing press such as this one at Townhall:
The Legal Advisor for Kavanaugh’s Accuser Is a Big Time Democratic Donor, Thinks People Who Work for Trump Are 'Miscreants'
The narrative on the right was that the lawyers were hardcore Democratic operatives. It was deemed suspicious when Blasey Ford said that Dianne Feinstein recommended Katz to her. Also when it was learned that Katz and her partner Lisa Banks were scheduled to hold a fund-raiser for Democratic senator Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin, until they backed out after the media reported on the event. Also when it was discovered that Julie Swetnick, a Kavanaugh accuser brought forth by Michael Avenatti, had once hired Katz to represent her after she'd made a sexual harassment claim.

TMZ would go on to publish a photograph of a woman who seemed to resemble Katz walking with Hillary Clinton, which led to wild speculation on the right:



(Snopes reported that the woman in the photo was actually Barbara Kinney, Clinton's official campaign photographer.)

But now an accuser who might take down a Democrat has hired Katz's firm, and the right's response is: "Debra Katz? Whatever."

If Tyson herself weren't useful to the right, she's just the kind of person who'd be the subject of conservative attacks. As Heavy.com notes, Tyson has "described herself as 'affiliated with the California Democratic Party'" and has said that she's "worked on Democratic campaigns in Southern California 'since I was 12 years old.'" She's using her Stanford fellowship "to research the politics and policies surrounding sexual violence against women and children in the United States" and "explore political discourse surrounding sexual assault, corresponding policies, and the unique identities of sexual assault survivors." Tyson is a professor of political science at Scripps College and is described by the Women's Media Center as an “expert on US Congress, policy formulation, race, gender, and social justice.” Also:
Her book, Twists of Fate: Multiracial Coalitions and Minority Representation in the US House of Representatives, published by the Oxford University Press, explores “structural inequality in the United States, and how members of Congress have formed multiracial coalitions as a strategy to provide for their diverse constituencies.”

Author Tyson is described as “a scholar of policy formulation, race, gender, and social justice ...”
If Tyson were accusing a Republican politician, she'd be vilified by the right as a Democratic plant, and as that worst of all modern archetypes -- a "social justice warrior."

Tyson mentioned the assault in a private social media post that was reportedly shared with her permission by a friend in Virginia named Adria Scharf:



If Scharf were helping an accuser of a Republican, she'd also be dismissed as an SJW. She's the executive director of the Richmond Peace Education Center, a group that tries to reduce urban violence through "workshops, public events, youth programs, and conflict resolution training." The workshop include this one next month:



Scharf has also visited the West Bank and expressed her dismay at the plight of the Palestinians:
My own family faced persecution, ethnic hate and forced displacement as Jews in Europe. I understand personally the historical roots of Jewish trauma. But that history does not excuse what I saw taking place in the Palestinian territory. Real hope for peace requires a basic respect for human rights. It requires a fair distribution of land, resources and opportunity. Land theft and occupation only worsens the cycle of violence.
If she were helping to bring down a Republican rather than a Democrat, she'd be hated on the right.

****

I don't know whether Justin Fairfax is innocent or guilty of these charges. Knowing little about him, I was initially pleased at the prospect that he might become Virginia's next governor. But after Al Franken and (especially) Eric Schneiderman, I assume it's possible that any man in politics, even one I admire greatly, could be as a sexual predator.

I take these charges seriously in part because the women involved aren't right-wing operatives -- far from it. I also know that false sexual assault claims are very rare. Vanessa Tyson has much more to lose than to gain by going public.

But the people pushing this story are people who'd be trying to destroy the reputations of Tyson, her friend, and her lawyer if the accused man was a Republican. The right's distaste for Democrats and liberals is clearly situational.


REPUBLICAN RATFUCKING IS GETTING IN THE WAY OF REPUBLICAN RATFUCKING

Republicans are upset because they apparently screwed up and created too many Ralph Northam scandals, diverting attention from the one they think is most important.

Let's go to The Federalist and feel their pain:
Don’t Let Ralph Northam’s Racism Controversy Obscure Democrats’ Sickening Abortion Policies

Last week’s outrage over Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam’s statement that babies born alive following a botched abortion could be allowed to die quickly evaporated when a racist photograph from Northam’s medical school yearbook began circulating. Northam quickly apologized for the picture, only to later backtrack, claiming that he was not the man in blackface or hidden beneath a Ku Klux Klan hood, but had darkened his face for a Michael Jackson costume that same year and thus his confusion.

... the uproar over Northam’s past succeeded in diverting attention from media’s focus on the party’s extreme abortion position.
Oh, boo-hoo! Your distortion of Northam's remarks about abortion was supposed to be the big scandal, but nobody except your side cared, especially when it was made clear that he was talking about possibly failing to resuscitate late-term fetuses that were non-viable or had severe deformities -- he wasn't talking about killing random newborns for sport.

But then your side dug up the blackface-and-Klan-robe photo in Northam's medical school yearbook, and Northam is now keeping that story in the headlines by refusing to resign, and your side complicated matters further by digging up another story involving a possible sexual assault by the lieutenant governor who'd take over if Northam does resign. Too confusing! What about the babies!

At Fox Nation, David Limbaugh laments:
"As abhorrent as racism is, we have to focus on what [else] he did, how he advocated for that Virginia infanticide law, celebrating it like [Andrew] Cuomo did in New York by lighting up the World Trade Center in pink," Limbaugh, the younger brother of radio host Rush said.
Feel the frustration at the American Thinker: "Yearbook Outrage, Infanticide Yawn." Also at FrontPage Magazine: "Media More Outraged Over Blackface Photo in Gov Northam Yearbook Than Infanticide."

Conservatism has nothing to offer ordinary Americans except more tax cuts for the rich accompanied by more reductions in wages, benefits, and government social services for the non-rich. Conservatism survives because the machinery of the right is excellent and ginning up Two Minutes' Hates against the enemies of Republican base voters.

But conservatives appear to be too good at this now. In Northam's case, the right has generated an excess number of scandals. The one that jibes with right-wing values didn't really land, then the one that contradicts right-wing values (because it calls on people to be anti-racist) did land. (There's a lesson for conservatives right there -- maybe America just doesn't like the right's values.)

Maybe the right needs to dial down the scandal-mongering a bit. Conservatives seem to be getting in their own way.

Monday, February 04, 2019

HAVE YOU TRIED TREATING THEM AS PEOPLE?

I'm gobsmacked and overwhelmed by the news coming out of Virginia, so instead I'd like to address Jill Abramson's Washington Post op-ed "Will the Media Ever Figure Out How to Cover Trump?," because her critique suggests to me that she hasn't figured out how Trump -- or, more specifically, Trump's base -- should be covered.

Abramson writes:
The news media’s collective shock that Donald Trump won in 2016 was evidence of how out of touch most reporters were with the less affluent, less educated, rural parts of the country, where white voter rage galvanized into votes that made him the 45th president. In the days after the election, there was anguished self-examination in many newsrooms and vows to cover the parts of the United States that had been mistakenly overlooked.

But more than two years later, the same question bedevils journalism: Can our tribe cover their tribe?

The president does have his amen corner on right-wing talk radio, Fox News and Breitbart, megaphones that help keep his base rock solid and reticulate his warped version of the facts and truth. But in the rest of the news media, there is little evidence that reporters have fulfilled their pledge to report on and reflect the interests and values of the people who voted for him. There have been some good dispatches from the heartland, but too often what is published amounts to the proverbial “toe touch in Appalachia.”
She contrasts the standard journalistic practice with what a reportorial legend once did:
I was powerfully moved by a recent article in the New Yorker about journalism by LBJ biographer Robert Caro. He described how he couldn’t really understand President Lyndon B. Johnson’s native Texas Hill Country until he and his wife actually moved there from New York City for three years. The locals had a derisive name for the reporters who parachuted in and out: “portable journalists.” There are great reporters who defy this description.
But are those really the only alternatives -- ignore the heartlanders, parachute into their world and write inadequately about them, or live in their world for years until you've gone native?

I'm reminded of a probably apocryphal story about Dustin Hoffman, who's a devotee of the Method, and Laurence Olivier, who wasn't:
When Dustin Hoffman was on set for Marathon Man, one scene in particular called for his character to appear as if he suffered from extreme exhaustion. To simulate this, Hoffman stayed up for three days straight ... to which costar Laurence Olivier responded, “My dear boy, have you tried acting?”
Abramson suggests that it's impossible for an upscale, coast-based journalist to write about people from Middle America without a deep, prolonged immersion in their world. You can understand why shr might believe this. Abramson's old paper, The New York Times, arguably ignored the people of Trump country before the 2016 election. Since then, it has romanticized them, portraying them in story after story as raw, elemental Real Americans whose perspective on Trump is more valid than whatever cosseted elitists like us (and the reporters themselves) think.

Reporters shouldn't automatically feel contempt for people who aren't like them -- but they also shouldn't portray them as noble savages. Olivier, it's said, couldn't understand why Dustin Hoffman couldn't portray fatigue without immersing himself in it. I don't understand why it's necessary to embed in a Pennsylvania mining town for years in order to treat the residents with the respect they deserve -- no more and no less.

Respect means not rejecting them out of hand and not treating them as American oracles. They're just people. They're culturally different from the reporters covering them, but reporters ought to be capable of seeing them as people without establishing residence in their communities. Seeing them as people would mean honoring their struggles and frankly acknowledging their shortcomings.

Maybe it's not easy, but it shouldn't be impossible.

REPUBLICANS VS. AMERICANS

I say this all the time: Despite the mainstream media narrative that the typical American is a MAGA-hat-wearing white blue-collar retiree in a rural Pennsylvania diner, poll after poll shows that Republicans are the ones who are out of step with the rest of America.

We see this again in a new CBS poll:
Sixty-six percent of Americans overall say President Trump should not declare a national emergency if Congress does not fund a border wall, although most Republicans (73 percent) think he should.

If government funding runs out on Feb. 15 and there's still an impasse over wall funding, Americans don't want either side to force another shutdown.

Seventy-three percent of Americans want Mr. Trump to continue negotiating while keeping the government open, rather than demand wall funding if that forces a shutdown....

But ... Republicans are split on what Mr. Trump should do on Feb. 15 if there is no deal. Fifty percent of Republicans say he should demand funding for a wall, even if it means another shutdown....

Fifty-eight percent of Americans don't think there should be another summit [with North Korea] right now, while 42 percent think there should be. Partisan splits drive this as well: most Democrats (77 percent) and independents (57 percent) don't want a second meeting, while seven in 10 Republicans do....

Most Americans say the Russia investigation is either a critical matter of national security (43 percent) or at least a serious one (22 percent). A third, including 73 percent of Republicans, call it a political witch hunt and a distraction.

Fifty-four percent of Americans think special counsel Robert Mueller is conducting the investigation fairly, while 46 percent believe he's conducting it unfairly, including most Republicans who say so....

Among Americans overall, fewer than half think Mr. Trump brought back manufacturing jobs, specifically (45 percent) made the borders more secure (38 percent) or reduced the influence of lobbyists and big donors (29 percent)....

Republicans ... feel he has brought back jobs (89 percent) and made the borders more secure (78 percent), [and] reduced the influence of lobbyists (60 percent)....
On most issues, Democrats and independents are roughly in agreement. Republicans are the outliers. They're not the norm. It's time for our political culture to start acknowledging this.

SECOND POLL SHOWS THAT HOWARD SCHULTZ HELPS TRUMP (updated)

On Friday you may have seen this post from a firm called Change Research:
There’s been much speculation about the impact of Howard Schultz running for president as an independent....

Change Research tested hypothetical matchups with and without Schultz of Trump running against different Democrats: Joe Biden, Kamala Harris, Elizabeth Warren, Beto O’Rourke, and Bernie Sanders, with the order shown randomized.

* Schultz takes an average of four points away from what the Democratic candidate receives in a two-way race, while taking just 1% away from Donald Trump. That means Schultz’s presence in the race makes Trump’s margins between 2 and 4 points better than they would be without him in the race.

* In every three-way matchup except against Biden (who leads both candidates), President Trump has plurality support.

* In every two-way matchup except against Biden (who once again has a significant lead), the Democrat narrowly leads President Trump. A Schultz candidacy could pull more from the Democratic nominee than the Republican nominee if held today.
Change Research's survey clearly shows that Schultz hurts Democrats nationwide. And now a second poll, published over the weekend -- this one with only one three-way match up, and in Iowa only -- finds a similar result:
A new Emerson College poll finds President Trump’s approval rating underwater at 46% approval with 48% disapproval. However, the President remains competitive against his potential 2020 Democratic rivals, leading against 7 of 8 candidates....

Biden is ... the only potential candidate to be leading Trump in a head to head matchup, by a margin of 51% to 49%. Trump leads Sanders by 1% (51-50), Warren by 4% (52-48), and Harris and O’Rourke by 6% (53-47)....

The Emerson Poll suggests a third party candidate would help the President’s chances in 2020. In a head-to-head matchup against Elizabeth Warren, Trump leads 52% to 48%, but when Howard Schultz is added as a third party candidate, Trump’s lead extends to 9 percentage points, 49% to 40%, with 11% voting for Schultz.
In the Change Research poll, Schultz helps Trump by 2 to 4 points nationwide, depending on the candidate. In Iowa, according to Emerson, Schultz helps Trump against Warren by 5 points. (The Schultz bump for Trump in a race against Warren is 3 points in the Change Research poll.)

The best-known Democrats -- Joe Biden and Bernie Sanders -- do the best against Trump in both polls. Those numbers will change for at least some of the other Democrats as they become better known.

But it's becoming clear that there's a Trump vote and an anti-Trump vote -- there isn't a Democratic vote, a Republican vote, and a large unaffiliated pool of voters who are desperate for corporatist centrism. Schultz will split the anti-Trump vote if he runs. He's a reasonably bright guy, so if he chooses to run, he's doing so fully aware that that will be the outcome.

****

UPDATE: And now there's this in a Morning Consult poll:
While only 26 percent of voters who approve of Trump's job performance as president are very or somewhat likely to consider a third-party candidate, a larger percentage of Trump disapprovers, 41 percent, would consider voting for an independent. By party, nearly a third of Democrats, 31 percent, say they would consider a third-party candidate — greater than the 25 percent of Republicans who would consider voting for someone other than the two major-party nominees.
Schultz is a menace.

Sunday, February 03, 2019

MAYBE THEY WON'T KEEP ALL THE MONEY AND POWER FOR THEMSELVES IF WE ASK THEM NICELY

In a New York Times op-ed, Michael Tomasky argues that our current troubles started in the 1970s, with inflation, flat wages, and the loss of manufacturing jobs:
... inflation ... hit 5.7 percent in 1970, then 11 percent in 1974. Such sustained inflation was something that had never happened in stable postwar America. And it was punishing. For a family of modest means, a trip to the supermarket was now a walk over hot coals.

... the Great Inflation, as the author Joe Nocera has noted, made most people feel they had to look out for themselves. Americans had spent decades just getting more and more ahead. Now, suddenly, they were falling behind.

Throw in wage stagnation, which began in the early ’70s, and deindustrialization of the great cities of the North....

Inflation also produced the manic search for “yield” — it was no longer enough to save money; your money had to make money, turning every wage earner into a player in market rapaciousness....

Even as Americans scrambled for return, they also sought to spend. Credit cards, which had barely existed in 1970, began to proliferate.
Then in the 1980s we had the Ronald Reagan presidency, which, Tomasky says, "freed people of the responsibility of introspection" and made Americans "a more acquisitive — bluntly, a more selfish — people," all as taxes on the rich were lowered and a commitment to activist government waned. "And this, more or less, is where we’ve been ever since," Tomasky writes.

Tomasky is right. But while he hopes that changing attitudes among ordinary Americans will help us find a way out, he also writes this:
... our captains of commerce ... will always be rich. But they have to decide what kind of country they want to be rich in. A place of more and more tax cuts for them, where states keep slashing their higher-education spending and tuitions keep skyrocketing; where the best job opportunity in vast stretches of America is selling opioids; where many young people no longer believe in capitalism and record numbers of them would leave this country if they could? Or a country more like the one they and their parents grew up in, where we invested in ourselves and where work produced a fair and livable wage?
The short answer to this is: Forget it. The rich don't care what happens to the rest of us.

Now, here's the long answer: Life also changed for the rich starting in the 1970s. For a few decades they'd been in something approaching an equilibrium with the rest of us. Out of fear of communism and fascism, and in response to a labor movement that had sometimes needed to resort to violence (often in response to violence on capital's part), the rich had agreed to better wages, better working conditions, and higher taxes on their own wealth meant to finance government programs for ordinary Americans.

But now the rich can have all the pie -- and they won't give it up without a fight.

They don't concern themselves with what's happening to ordinary Americans. They don't worry that impoverishment and crushing debt burdens will leave fewer of us able to buy their products and services. They'll just switch to luxury items, or sell more overseas.

They seem not to worry that our frustrations will lead us to elect very left-wing leaders who'll take significant amounts of their money. They assume they'll find a way to put the squeeze on Elizabeth Warren or Bernie Sanders if one of them is elected president. And they're probably right to believe that they can bottle up any radical change -- after all, they have complete control over one of our major political parties and significant control over the other.

They also appear not to be worried about the possibility that the populace will turn to full-blown fascism. I assume they they they can continue to make nice money under those circumstances, assuming war doesn't ensue. (And who would fight an American fascist leader? A weakened EU? The Chinese, who don't concern themselves with the morals and human rights records of other governments?)

I think the rich assume they're bulletproof now. They think they'll maintain their ability to hoard all the nice stuff even if the rest of America (or the world) burns. And I wish I believed they were wrong about that. I support progressive politicians, but I suspect it may be impossible now to make significant improvements to ordinary Americans' lives through conventional politcal means. I fear the rich won't allow us to do that unless we threaten to destroy their world.

Saturday, February 02, 2019

REPUBLICANS ARE STILL BETTER AT SETTING THE NEWS AGENDA

Virginia governor Ralph Northam is, so far, refusing to step down, and it's the most talked-about story in America:
Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam (D) faced the public Saturday and defiantly said he will not resign because he does not believe that it is him in a racist photograph from his 1984 medical school yearbook.

“I am not either of those people in that photo,” Northam told media gathered at the Executive Mansion, referring to the image of a person dressed in blackface and another in a Ku Klux Klan robe on his yearbook page....

But he alluded to other actions in his past, and disclosed that in 1984 he won a dance contest in San Antonio where he wore dark shoe polish on his cheeks as part of a Michael Jackson costume.
This is a story that pushes a lot of cultural hot buttons. I understand why it's big news. But there's no reason for it to be the biggest story in the country right now. And it doesn't make sense that a distorted interpretation of remarks Northam made about abortion on a radio show earlier this week became national news at all.

Posing in blackface or in a Klan robe is bad, but do you know what else is bad? What we were told about the conduct of then-Missouri governor Eric Greitens last year:
As he was preparing to declare his candidacy in early 2015, Greitens, who is married with children, began a sexual relationship with a woman he met at a hair salon. Though the relationship began consensually, the woman’s testimony to the legislature showed that things quickly took a darker turn. She said that when she was naked, he bound her and then took a picture and told her, “You’re not going to mention my name. Don’t even mention my name to anybody at all, because if you do, I’m going to take these pictures, and I’m going to put them everywhere I can. They are going to be everywhere, and then everyone will know what a little whore you are.”

Her account also described a sexual assault, as she said that Greitens became violent, and she felt coerced to perform oral sex in order to be allowed to leave his house....
Greitens was also facing felony charges after reportedly misusing funds collected for his veterans' charity. And yet this never became a banner-headline, wall-to-wall-cable-coverage national story. It was never as big as the Northam story is now.

And if we're just talking about racism, what about this now-departed governor?
The governor of Maine has said that people of colour were enemies of his state, and appeared to suggest they should be shot.

Speaking about Maine's effort to combat drug crime, Paul LePage said that "the enemy right now... are people of colour or people of Hispanic origin".

"When you go to war... and the enemy dresses in red and you dress in blue, then you shoot at red," he said....

The press conference capped a controversial 72 hours for the Republican governor.

Mr LePage was asked about a statement he made in January, in which he blamed the state's heroin problem on "guys by the name D-Money, Smoothie, Shifty" who "come from Connecticut and New York".

"They come up here, they sell their heroin, then they go back home. Incidentally, half the time they impregnate a young, white girl before they leave," he said.

Speaking on Wednesday, he denied it was racist, but said that since January he had been putting together a binder cataloguing drug arrests in the state, and that "90-plus per cent of those pictures in my book, and it's a three-ringed binder, are black and Hispanic people".

Asked by reporters to provide the binder, Mr LePage replied: "Let me tell you something: Black people come up the highway and they kill Mainers. You ought to look into that."
LePage was national news, but he was never huge national news.

Republicans are simply better than Democrats at forcing negative stories about the other party onto the national news agenda, and at working them until they rise to the top. And Republicans are motivated right now: They know they're going into 2020 with an unpopular incumbent president, and they're determined to make the election that year a referendum on anything but Trump.

So they're starting now. They're throwing everything they've got out there, to distract voters from Trump's words and deeds. If they're successful, we'll be voting in 2020 on whether we think Democrats are evil, not on whether we want four more years of Trump. Don't assume they can't pull that off.

BLACKFACE IN THE 1980S: IT WASN'T JUST RALPH NORTHAM

I agree with the many Democrats (and opportunistic hypocrite Republicans) who've called for Ralph Northam's resignation.
A photo from Gov. Ralph Northam’s medical school yearbook shows him and another person in racist costumes — one wearing blackface and one a Ku Klux Klan robe and hood, though it was not clear which person was the future governor.

Hours after the 35-year-old photo came to light Friday, Northam apologized for his decision to appear in it. Elected officials and activist groups from across the political spectrum called for him to resign.

But in a video posted to Twitter Friday evening, Northam said he had spent the past year “fighting for a Virginia that works better for all people” and he would continue to do so throughout the rest of his term, which ends in January 2022.
I'm ready for his solidly progressive lieutenant governor, Justin Fairfax, to take over and become Virginia's second black governor. I understand why Northam thinks he can survive -- in early December, his approval/disapproval numbers in a statewide poll were 59%/24%. He thinks he has political capital. But if Democrats want to say to Americans that racism is intolerable, he can't stay.

The yearbook photo was published in 1984, a generation after the Civil Rights Era -- but the 1980s was a time of backlash and retrenchment. Ronald Reagan was president -- and in 1981 there was blackface at one of his pre-inaugural events, although it was blackface worn by a black performer who was trying (unsuccessfully) to send the president and the country a message:
On January 19, 1981, a number of prominent entertainers gathered at the Capital Centre, just outside of Washington, D.C., for the All Star Inaugural Gala, saluting the country’s new President, Ronald Reagan. Among them was the Tony Award-winning actor Ben Vereen, who, a few years before, had been nominated for an Emmy for his performance in the enormously popular miniseries “Roots.” For his contribution to the gala, Vereen staged an homage to the legendary black vaudevillian Bert Williams, one of the most popular entertainers of the early twentieth century. The tribute, which he performed with Ronald and Nancy Reagan seated regally near the stage, consisted of two parts. First, Vereen sang the popular show tune “Waiting for the Robert E. Lee.” He did so dressed as Williams, wearing coat and tails, and, as Williams would have—as was required of African-American theatrical performers of Williams’s era—wearing blackface, too.

The tribute begins buoyantly. After the first song, looking delighted by the rapturous applause of his audience, Vereen, still performing as Williams, mimics an interaction with an imaginary bartender and offers to buy the largely Republican crowd a celebratory drink. Then he gently makes it clear that this gesture has been denied owing to the color of his skin. Appearing deflated, Vereen then sings Williams’s signature song, the mordant and dirgelike “Nobody” (“I ain’t never got nothin’ from nobody, no time”), while staring into a makeup mirror and wiping the black paint from his face.

This final five minutes of Vereen’s performance is anguished yet defiant, evoking the pain and exploitative power of blackface minstrelsy and the distortions of stereotype. It was intended to implicate the predominantly white audience. And almost nobody saw it. The gala was televised on ABC, on tape delay, but the broadcast omitted this latter half of Vereen’s act. Vereen had been promised that the whole performance would be shown, and he felt betrayed by the network’s decision to edit out the latter part.
This is what America saw. Notice the delight on Reagan's face:



Reagan's reaction is at 2:43 of the clip. He isn't enjoying the critique of racism in Vereen's act. He's enjoying the minstrel show.

We should have been beyond blackface by the 1980s, but in 1986 America made this a hit movie:



Mark Watson (Howell), is the pampered son of a rich family who is about to attend Harvard Law School along with his best friend Gordon (Gross). Unfortunately, his father's neurotic psychiatrist talks his patient into having more fun for himself instead of spending money on his son. Faced with the prospect of having to pay for law school by himself, Mark decides to apply for a scholarship, but the only suitable one is for African-Americans only. He decides to cheat by using tanning pills in a larger dose than prescribed to appear as an African-American.
Northam blacked up, but he wasn't alone in Reagan's America. Progress comes slowly.

Friday, February 01, 2019

ALINSKY FOR IDIOTS

These people never say or do anything in good faith:
Counselor to the president Kellyanne Conway suggested Friday that 2020 presidential candidate Cory Booker is being held to a different standard on sexism than Republicans are, wondering aloud why he hasn't been criticized for jumping into a Democratic field already densely populated with female candidates.

“I would ask him a couple questions today as he runs from my native New Jersey,” Conway said in an interview on Fox News’ “Fox & Friends.”

“One is, what is wrong with the candidates that are already in there? What is your objection to [California Sen.] Kamala Harris running, [Massachusetts Sen.] Elizabeth Warren, [New York Sen.] Kirsten Gillibrand, these others who have already announced, [Hawaii Rep.] Tulsi Gabbard maybe? If he were a Republican running against them, they immediately would call him a sexist for running against these women in the Democratic field.”
Obviously, this is meant as a troll -- but it's a very specific kind of troll.

Saul Alinsky was a lefty, but lefties don't read him much these days. Conservatives, on the other hand, are obsessed with Alinsky. They have been since the early days of the Tea Party. As a leader of the Koch-funded group FreedomWorks, Dick Armey used to hand out copies of Alinsky's Rules for Radicals.

Rule #4 in Rules for Radicals is "Make the enemy live up to its own book of rules." That's what Conway is trying to do here. The problem is, Republicans have no idea what our "rules" are. Obviously we're having a debate in the Democratic Party about whether it would be a bad thing to put forward another male nominee, particularly a white male. On the other hand, I don't know anyone who thinks males or even white males shouldn't run, and there seem to be strong constituencies for several Caucasian guys -- Beto O'Rourke, Joe Biden, Bernie Sanders, Sherrod Brown. Many of us will vote hoping to expand the possibilities of who can be president in America, but we don't want to exclude men from the contest -- and, of course, Booker isn't white. (I don't know anyone Democrat who thinks it was sexist for Andrew Gillum to run successfully against Gwen Graham, the favorite in the 2018 Florida Democratic gubernatorial primary.)

When it comes to recruiting and electing female candidates, Democrats have had a much better track record than Republicans, especially in 2018. But "no boys allowed" is not in our "book of rules." Nevertheless, Conway's fellow Republicans probably do believe we're going against our own code of behavior. So I guess the joke lands with its intended audience. People who know nothing about Democrats think this terrible joke about Democrats is funny because it's true.

THIS IS HOW YOU GOT LATE-TERM ABORTION

Republicans are outraged because blue states are attempting to expand abortion rights.
When New York expanded abortion rights last week for the first time in 49 years, Democrats across the state were exultant. Now, that jubilation has been met with an equal and opposite reaction.

Anti-abortion advocates, from grass-roots activists all the way to the White House, are taking aim at New York, Virginia and other states in a bid to halt similar legislative efforts by emboldened Democratic lawmakers and to mobilize supporters ahead of the 2020 presidential race.

By Thursday, both President Trump and Vice President Mike Pence had leaned into the debate....

New York’s new law, passed last week, permits abortion after the 24th week of a pregnancy when there is “an absence of fetal viability, or the abortion is necessary to protect the patient’s life or health.” A bill introduced in Virginia by a Democratic state lawmaker would also have reduced restrictions on late-term abortions to protect the mother’s health, and would have decreased the number of physicians whose opinions were required to approve an abortion, to one from three. The Virginia bill was set aside in committee....

Similar bills to expand abortion rights in New Mexico and Rhode Island seem unlikely to be derailed, given the dominance of Democrats in both states’ legislatures and governor’s mansions.
Republicans blame Democrats. They blame the culture.

The only people they don't blame are themselves.

We know that Republicans are curbing abortion rights in the states they control:
... a ban on abortions after 15 weeks ... was signed by Mississippi Gov. Phil Bryant, a Republican, in March. More states have moved to restrict abortion since: On May 4, Republican Iowa Gov. Kim Reynolds signed a bill banning abortions after a doctor can detect a fetal heartbeat, or as early as six weeks. The Ohio House of Representatives passed a similar bill in November....

In May, Gov. John Bel Edwards of Louisiana, a Democrat, signed a bill banning abortion after 15 weeks; it will only take effect if the Mississippi law is upheld....

On March 27, the Kentucky House of Representatives passed a bill banning dilation and evacuation, a procedure often used in second-trimester abortions, if a patient is more than about 11 weeks pregnant. The bill, signed into law by Republican Gov. Matt Bevin in April, is facing a court challenge.
And we know that an anti-abortion majority on the Supreme Court might well overturn Roe v. Wade.

Whenever Democrats do something the GOP considers extreme, Republican commentators inevitably say, "This is how you got Trump." On just the first page of Google search results for that phrase, I see that "attacking Mike Pence's Christian faith" is how we got Trump, as is harassing Sarah Huckabee Sanders at a restaurant. Also: liberals' unwillingness to date conservatives, The Atlantic's decison to fire Kevin Williamson, and -- I'm not making this up -- Google's removal of an egg from a salad emoji to make it more vegan-friendly.

Pretty much everything we do is the reason we're to blame for Trump. Why isn't this ever reversed? Maybe if red states weren't trying to restrict abortion after six weeks, blue state officials wouldn't be passing laws the right regards as opening the door to infanticide. We can extend this to other hot-button issues -- for instance, maybe we wouldn't be trying to raise taxes on the rich as high as we are if you guys weren't trying to lower them at every opportunity.

In fact, we're passing laws we believe in. We're not doing these things just to induce conservative tears. But maybe we wouldn't be prioritizing some of these issues if it weren't for you. So look in the mirror: This is how got late-term abortion.