Monday, January 16, 2006

The Martin Luther King Day celebration at Reverend Al Sharpton's National Action Network is a rite of passage in an election year. And with so many big races this year, candidates and controversy were the order of the day....

"I need you to tell us what distinguishes Democrats from Republicans right now," [Senator Hillary Clinton] was asked.

Clinton's answer was provocative.

Said Clinton, "When you look at the way the House of Representatives has been run, it has been run like a plantation and you know what I'm talking about..."

Some House Republicans took immediate offense at Senator Clinton's choice of words.

Said Republican Congressman Peter King, of Long Island, "It's always wrong to play the race card for political gain by using a loaded word like plantation. But it is particularly wrong to do so on Martin Luther King Day."


--WCBS-TV, New York

****

1992 Republican Party platform:

For low-income families, the Republican Party stands for a revolution in housing by converting public housing into homes owned by low-income Americans. President Bush is eager to work closely with the States to fight and win a new conservative war on poverty. The truest measure of our success will not be how many families we add to housing assistance rolls but, rather, how many families move into the ranks of homeownership. But every part of that opportunity agenda has been thwarted by landlord Democrats in Congress. We ask the electorate: End the strangulation of divided government. Give Republicans the chance to move housing policy off the Democrat Party plantation into the main-stream of American life.

National Republican Senatorial Committee press release, December 2005:

Charles Krauthammer Called [Senator Harry] Reid's Objection To [Judge Clarence] Thomas A Symbol Of The "Liberal Plantation Mentality," Where It Is Unacceptable To Be A Conservative African-American Man. Charles Krauthammer: "He said some nice things about Scalia and lousy stuff about Thomas. If you look at their records on the Court, Scalia and Thomas are two closest in terms of concurrences and agreements. . . . In the end, you've got to ask yourself, why Scalia, good, Thomas, bad in the eyes of a man like Reid. I say it's the liberal plantation mentality, in which if you're a man on the right and white, it's OK. If you are the man on the right and you're African-American, it's not." (Fox News' "Special Report With Brit Hume," December 6, 2004) (emphasis in original)

(See also: Joseph Farah, "Racism on Dem Plantation," World Net Daily, 11/19/03; Michael Gonzalez, "Hispanics for Jorge: Another Immigrant Group Wanders Off the Democratic Plantation," Wall Street Journal, 11/8/04; Edward Whelan, "The Liberal Plantation," National Review Online, 6/7/05; etc., etc.)
I listened to an hour of All Things Considered on NPR this afternoon and was told three times that Bush went to look at the Emancipation Proclamation.

IT'S A FREAKIN' PHOTO OP, PEOPLE! IT'S NOT NEWS!

The beginning of wisdom would be not even sending a reporter to cover nonsense like this.
WWGOPD?

Everybody knows that the Democrats failed to make their case against Alito in the Judiciary Committee hearings, right? It's somewhat similar to November 1998, when everybody knew that Republican losses in the midterm elections meant that the GOP hadn't made its case for impeachment.

We know the GOP didn't give a damn and impeached Clinton anyway, but I just want to remind you what the immediate reaction was:

November 6, 1998

Judiciary Chairman Asks Clinton to Admit or Deny 81 Findings


Forging ahead with an impeachment inquiry that most Americans say Congress should drop, Rep. Henry Hyde, R-Ill., asked President Clinton Thursday to say flatly whether he lied under oath, tampered with witnesses or obstructed justice.

In an 11-page letter, Hyde, chairman of the House Judiciary Committee, asked Clinton to admit or deny 81 selected findings gleaned from the independent counsel's 445-page report on the president's affair with Monica Lewinsky....

Hyde said the president could speed the process by not disputing the findings. But many questions are pointed and ask Clinton to admit to accusations that he and his advisers have strenuously denied since the independent counsel Kenneth Starr sent his scathing report to Congress. For example, question No. 20:

"Do you admit or deny that you gave false and misleading testimony under oath when you stated during your deposition in the case of Jones v. Clinton on Jan. 17, 1998, that you did not know if Monica Lewinsky had been subpoenaed to testify in that case?" ...

Hyde denied the questions constituted a witch hunt. "It would be a witch hunt if we served him with a subpoena to come in, get under oath and testify to a cross-examination from all members," Hyde said. "That would be pushing the envelope. We're doing it in the most genteel way."...


Yup -- electorally they'd screwed up, as the entire political establishment noted, and yet they came right back that week with a new, obnoxious, full-bore attack on Clinton. Just to prove they still could. Please note that the attack was surprising, and therefore headline-grabbing; it was in an unexpected form, which helped make it newsworthy.

The linked article is from The New York Times. Note what the conventional wisdom was in the days after the election:

But the shock waves from Democratic gains in the midterm election on Tuesday have injected new doubts and uncertainty into the impeachment process, lawmakers said Thursday....

With the possibility of impeachment growing dimmer, attention is shifting to a group of 10 committee moderates who have been exploring alternative punishment, including censure....


It was actually believed at that moment that the election results meant the SOBs probably couldn't impeach.

But Republicans just pressed on. And they got their victory -- not against Clinton, but against Democrats ever since, by branding Dems as the party of immorality.

A lesson for Senate Democrats now?

Sunday, January 15, 2006

When I read in this New York Times Magazine story that so far there have been 134 victories in municipal and statewide campaigns to raise the minimum wage to a "living wage," that "a hypothetical state ballot measure [on the issue] typically generates support of around 70 percent," that a living wage measure got 71% of the vote in Jeb Bush's Florida in 2004 (even as Jeb's brother got 52%), and that "over the years there has been anywhere from a 2 to 5 percent increase in voter turnout specifically correlated with wage measures," particularly among "the kind of voters who are difficult to engage in other ways: younger voters, infrequent voters, low-income urban voters," I have to ask: Why the hell don't more Democrats run on economic populism?

Did you read the Slate article this past week in which John Dickerson argues that Bush actually wants hearings on warrantless spying because he thinks the public will come down on the GOP's side? Well, running against Bush's GOP with a message of economic populism would be a way to do the same thing back to the Republicans, because Bush, in particular, looks at the GDP numbers and the Dow Jones industrial average and thinks the economy is just hunky-dory -- and just doesn't get that the average American, faced with stagnant wages, rising medical costs, rising energy costs, and permanent job insecurity, strenuously disagrees.

I think John Edwards gets all this, but does any other Democrat of national stature? And why not?
THE DOG ATE OUR HOMEWORK

This is just pathetic:

Democratic aides said there had been even less strategy than usual in trying to coordinate the questioning [of Samuel Alito] by the eight Democratic senators [on the Judiciary Committee]. The situation was complicated because senators and staff were out of Washington before the hearing.

But what about that newfangled gadget everyone's using these days -- what's it called? The "telephone"? And that "e-mail" whoozywhatsis all the kids seem to like? Couldn't the senators have tried that?

Saturday, January 14, 2006

Think they'll literally "Swift Boat" him? How much do you want to bet someone's out there right now trying to prove that John Murtha didn't deserve his medals?

--me, 11/17/05

Guess I really should have taken some bets -- here's the smear.

Sources claiming Murtha is a liar: Three guys who've run against him and lost. Yeah, that's really persuasive, isn't it?

Every time I think I've seen the worst the Right can do, the level of scum rises higher.
I've been reading recently about efforts to increase the number of non-American troops in Afghanistan. Australia has agreed to augment its force there; so has NATO -- among NATO members, the Dutch, in particular, are under great pressure to send more fighters, and have just now agreed to do so. This is meant, it seems, to "free up US troops to mount a more aggressive offensive against the Taliban in the border regions."

Or, perhaps, to mount a more aggressive offensive against al-Qaeda in the border regions -- which might explain the bombing that was meant to kill Zawahiri.

In my last post I noted that the U.S. had fallen for bad intel again and had failed to kill a top terrorist leader -- but I don't want to be completely cynical about this. Maybe, just maybe, we're redoubling our efforts to capture or kill the masterminds of 9/11. That would be a good thing.

And if that's the case, maybe it took relentless criticism, approval ratings in the 30s, and the threat of losing GOP control over one or both houses of Congress to get President Bush to grope for ways he could regain the upper hand and to decide that one way might be to focus -- finally -- on al-Qaeda. If that's what's going on, then Bush's biggest supporters owe those of us who criticize him a word of thanks, for getting him to take seriously a bit of business that's been unfinished for more than four years.

After all, a year ago Bush thought he had the country in his pocket, and he'd gotten to that point without harming a hair on the heads of bin Laden and Zawahiri. But we critics didn't kowtow to Bush and his supposed mandate; we criticized him on any number of issues, and some of it stuck. He's been hurting recently, and so has his party. And maybe that put the fear of God into him.

I really don't think George W. Bush will ever get us out of Iraq, will ever reverse runaway deficits, will ever preside over a country in which the poor no longer get poorer as the rich get richer. But maybe, just maybe, he now wants the U.S. military to get bin Laden and Zawahiri, and maybe, despite his blundering mismanagement of the job of commander in chief, the military will get the job done. If that happens, perhaps it will turn out to have been a genuine response to pressure applied by free people in a democracy -- which would be a good thing.

Then again, why the hell do we have to put pressure on the president of the United States in order to get him to focus on this?

****

On the other hand, The U.S. is reducing the number of troops it has in Afghanistan, even as violence there increases. So maybe you should forget everything I just said.
AL-QAEDA'S LEADERSHIP = ROADRUNNER. BUSH = COYOTE.

So they sent us to bed all excited, hinting that they might have killed Zarqawi, but once again they were acting on bad intel:

al-Qaida Leader Not at Site of Airstrike

Al-Qaida's second-in-command was the target of a U.S. airstrike near the Afghan border but he was not at the site of the attack, two senior Pakistani officials said Saturday. At least 17 people were killed.

...The two Pakistani officials told The Associated Press on Saturday that the CIA had acted on incorrect information, and Ayman al-Zawahri was not in the village of Damadola when it came under attack....

"Their information was wrong, and our investigations conclude that they acted on a false information," said a senior intelligence official. His account was confirmed by a senior government official, who said al-Zawahri "was not there." ...

An AP reporter who visited the scene in Damadola village about 12 hours later saw three destroyed houses hundreds of yards apart. Villagers recounted hearing aircraft overhead moments before the attack. By their count at least 30 people died, including women and children....


Aw, hell, the Bushies have lowered my expectations so much that I'm impressed they're even still trying to get the people who were actually responsible for 9/11. Too bad they can devote only a fraction of the resources they've committed to the Iraq quagmire, an effort that's done nothing to al-Qaeda except allow it to metastasize.

What did Bush say days after 9/11? Oh, yeah, that's right:

"When I take action," he said, "I'm not going to fire a $2 million missile at a $10 empty tent and hit a camel in the butt. It's going to be decisive."

Still waiting.

Friday, January 13, 2006

If you've already read Kate O'Beirne's Women Who Make the World Worse: And How Their Radical Feminist Assault Is Ruining Our Schools, Families, Military, and Sports and you're hungry for more writing by women who use feminism as a pinata, be patient: I see from Publishers Lunch (in its subscription-only edition for today) that Random House has just signed a book by syndicated columnist and "maverick conservative" Kathleen Parker that will be titled Save the Males.

For those who've never heard of Parker, go here for a thumbnail bio, and for a sample column that could well be in the book; it bears the charming title "Feminism's Devolution from Hoaxers to Whores." I probably won't surprise you when I tell you that the column bashes feminists for making straight men want to be "metrosexuals" -- a word right-wing pundits grab at greedily every time they're writing about the sexes, even though no one else in America has talked about metrosexuals for at least a year, much less met one.
People with problems, as reported by The New York Times:

...Many megayachts have grown so big -- sometimes as long as a football field -- that their very size rules out docking at most marinas, which don't have large enough slips to accommodate them....

It is a problem that has vexed Ira and Audrey Kaufman ever since they built their dream boat, Gray Mist III, a 150-foot yacht fashioned after their home in Highland Park, Ill. -- complete with antique furniture, a working fireplace and a dining table that seats 12 -- about five years ago.

"Many places that we go to, you can't get in the marina because our draft is too deep," said Mr. Kaufman, 77, a senior managing director at Mesirow Financial....

"There's so few marinas now that you can get a boat in," Mr. Kaufman said. "There's not room." ...


People with problems, as reported by USA Today:

The problems began showing up earlier this month at small pharmacies such as the one Ed Derderian runs in Dinuba, Calif.: poor, elderly and disabled residents unable to get their prescriptions refilled.

... trouble persists for people such as Geoffery Foughnor of Galveston, Texas, and his mother, Helen Walker. Foughnor has been without his prostate-cancer medicine for a week. Walker used her last blood pressure pill -- a loan from the neighborhood CVS drugstore -- on Thursday....

Since Medicare began covering prescription drugs this month for the first time, some low-income Americans have lost ground. They are among 6.2 million Medicare beneficiaries also on Medicaid....

Until Dec. 31, they were getting prescription drugs from Medicaid, usually with co-payments of just a few dollars. On Jan. 1, they were automatically enrolled in one of Medicare's private insurance plans. But many beneficiaries have disappeared from the government's database, been overcharged or found that important prescriptions are no longer covered, pharmacists and government officials say....


Do I even need to tell you which group is getting a break from the taxman?

THE BUDGET blueprint for fiscal 2006 could come to the House and Senate floors this week....

The resolution would take from the poor and give to the rich. It would provide for easy passage -- no Senate filibuster allowed -- of what's likely to be $70 billion in tax cuts over the next five years, the benefits of which would tilt heavily toward wealthier Americans.... The new cuts would, among other things, extend the lower tax rates for dividend and capital gains income. According to an analysis by the Urban Institute-Brookings Institution Tax Policy Center, almost three-fourths of the benefits from those cuts would go to the richest 3 percent of Americans, households making more than $200,000 a year....


Good thing, too, because marinas for those huge yachts are finally being built in large numbers, according to the Times, and the fees will undoubtedly make a lot of megayacht owners really feel the pinch.

As for those seniors who are running out of drugs: Your call is important to us. Please continue to hold....

(Third link via Sisyphus Shrugged.)
WANKER OF THE DAY

I'll say it before Atrios does: It's Jake Tapper of ABC News, for telling us on his blog that Samuel Alito was unfairly smeared as a racist because Dinesh D'Souza says so:

...D'Souza worked for CAP [Concerned Alumni of Princeton] from 1983 to 1985, editing CAP's controversial Prospect magazine. He said a number of the Democratic attacks on Samuel Alito were based on falsehoods.

First off, D'Souza says, one of the two stories from
Prospect that Sen. Ted Kennedy, D-MA, read this week at the confirmation hearings was intended as a satire.

The 1983 essay "In Defense of Elitism" by Harry Crocker III included this line, read dramatically by Kennedy: "People nowadays just don't seem to know their place. Everywhere one turns blacks and hispanics are demanding jobs simply because they're black and hispanic..."

The essay may not have been funny, D'Souza acknowledges, but Kennedy read from it as if it had been serious instead of an attempt at humor.

"I think left-wing groups have been feeding Senator Kennedy snippets and he has been mindlessly reciting them," D'Souza said. "It was a satire."...


Yeah, because satire can't possibly be racist, can it, Dinesh?

Under D'Souza's editorship, the [right-wing campus newspaper] Dartmouth Review ... published a parody titled "Dis Sho Ain't No Jive Bro," which mocked the way African-American students supposedly speak. ("Dese boys be sayin' that we be comin' here to Dartmut an' not takin' the classics. You know, Homa, Shakesphere; but I hea' dey all be co'd in da ground, six feet unda, and whatchu be askin' us to learn from dem?") Also during his tenure as editor, according to a September 22, 1995, article in The Washington Post, the Review "published an interview with a former leader of the Ku Klux Klan, using a mock photograph of a black man hanging from a campus tree."

(Via Memeorandum.)
Atrios, citing this enumeration of some of Samuel Alito's more troubling opinions, asks:

Why is it that white guys who comb their hair, dress well, and mostly speak in full sentences are presumed to be "decent" no matter what the evidence to the contrary?

Good question -- but it isn't "white guys," it's Republican guys, and gals. John Yoo, Alberto Gonzales, and Condoleezza Rice operate under a blanket presumption of decency that's challenged only out here on the wild fringes of lefty advocacy; the members of the Senate Judiciary Committee, by contrast -- all but one of them white and male -- operate under no such presumption.

Some of this is a matter of style: Most Republicans have mastered the technique of using politesse to disguise relentlessness and sometimes viciousness. Then again, Charles Schumer is generally polite and soft-spoken even at his most dogged, whereas President Bush often can barely conceal his mile-wide mean streak -- yet it's Schumer whose character is frequently questioned and Bush who is seen as possessing an unmistakable decency at his core.

Why is this?

Because Republicans have mastered the art of persuading the public that Democrats, individually and collectively, are evil freaks, neurotics with malign intent. The New York Times may catalog failures in the Iraq War on its front page, but Rush Limbaugh and Fox News and the Drudge Report and the New York Post make it personal, snickering and recoiling in mock-revulsion at the unhinged perfidy of twisted yet powerful Democrats (and presumed Democrats) -- compulsive liar Al Gore, power-mad Hillary Clinton, sexual predator Bill Clinton, drunk Ted Kennedy, prissy traitor John Kerry, raving old coot ex-Klansman Robert Byrd, wacko GOP-basher Dan Rather.

This is a cancer on our politics, and it would be best if it disappeared from the scene, but it won't. So Democrats won't have a fighting chance until there's a comparable effort on our side.

Sure, we on the left do a good job of spreading negative impressions of Republicans amongst ourselves. But Republicans reach the middle -- mostly, I think, because they use tools other than snark and ridicule. The right-wing specialty is a fake tone of concern -- Bill O'Reilly is the master of this, Sean Hannity is quite adept at it, and even Rush, between infantile song parodies, regularly goes solemn while sounding the alarum bells about the crimes of Democratic and liberals. This is mixed in with relentless attacks on soft targets (e.g., Ward Churchill) and campaigns based on half-truths (e.g., stories about "the war on Christmas") to paint a picture of a vast, interlinked liberal/left/Democratic conspiracy of dangerous weirdos preventing the triumph of decency and of common sense.

It all plays in Peoria.

We might have won this thing if we had built a multi-tiered, self-referential advocacy/attack media that could persuade Middle America that Samuel Alito is an evil freak and so, for that matter, is the oleaginous Lindsay Graham; until we build it, we're going to get beaten over and over again. I'm not saying I necessarily want to live in a country in which we send as much poison into the political atmosphere as the Right. I'm just saying that may be the only way to prevent Republican rule without end.
So, when is the media going to start cordoning this off as "the Senate Democrats' bad week" and arguing that they're "poised for a comeback"?

Thursday, January 12, 2006

The New York Times tells us today that Iraq-born Sunni insurgents are beginning to get tired of the tactics of foreign-born Islamists. Exultant voices from the right say this is a very, very good thing. Well, maybe. I'm skeptical:

...American and Iraqi officials believe that the conflicts present them with one of the biggest opportunities since the insurgency burst upon Iraq nearly three years ago. They have begun talking with local insurgents, hoping to enlist them to cooperate against Al Qaeda, said Western diplomats, Iraqi officials and an insurgent leader.

One problem is that there's no evidence whatsoever that this means Iraqi insurgents will actually work with Americans:

...the Americans face significant challenges in trying to exploit the split. "It is against my beliefs to put my hand with the Americans," said an Iraqi member of the Islamic Army who uses the nom de guerre Abu Omar.

Still, he said in an interview in a house in Baghdad, he allowed himself a small celebration whenever a member of Al Qaeda fell to an American bullet. "I feel happy when the Americans kill them," he said.


And if that attitude changes, do we really want these insurgents as our allies?

Whatever the answer, what we seem to have right now is something like a gang war:

Samarra, north of Baghdad, had been infiltrated by Al Qaeda's fighters. In desperation, a local sheik, Hekmat Mumtaz al-Baz, traveled to Baghdad in September to meet with Iraq's defense minister and ask for help, said one of the sheik's aides, Waleed al-Samarrai. A few weeks after the visit, the sheik was shot dead by Qaeda gunmen in his yard....

The tribe was furious, and its members tracked down the three men who carried out the killing. Elders from the tribe held a trial in a local farmhouse and interrogated the men for days....

Members of the tribe swept the town and arrested 17 people they suspected were associated with the sheik's killing. In one house raid, the tribe found men from Sudan, Morocco, Afghanistan and Saudi Arabia, a member of the tribe said.

Al Qaeda's fighters struck back during the tribe's offensive. A foreign Arab believed to be a Saudi wearing in a suicide belt blew himself up at the sheik's funeral, killing one guest and wounding two....

As a lesson to all those associated with the sheik's death, the tribe staged a public killing. While the sheik's father watched, men with machine guns shot the three men who carried out the assassination....

****

Two and a half years into the American occupation, the towns and villages south of Baghdad are divided among the insurgent groups like gang territory in big American cities. The arrangement is largely invisible to American troops who patrol the towns, the insurgents said in interviews. But guerrillas themselves say they must seek permission to travel through towns their groups do not control....


This is progress?

If this were, say, Los Angeles circa 1990, would we consider it a hopeful sign that tensions between the Crips and Bloods had escalated to all-out combat? Would we say a gang war should make the residents of South Central or Compton feel safer? Would we argue that our best hope for peace would be the possibility that one gang might brutally eliminate the other in a series of drive-by shootings? Would we look forward hopefully to the day when the Crips or the Bloods will show up at police headquarers and offer to work with the cops?

Maybe these tensions really will lead to the insurgency's demise. Or maybe we're getting this story now because otherwise we're fresh out of potential sources of light at the end of the tunnel.
THE BLOWHARD WITH A THOUSAND FACES

It's Rush Limbaugh's birthday today.

In honor of the solemn occasion, this thread at Free Republic links to a two-year-old essay of sorts entitled "Rush Limbaugh Is 'The Passion.'" Here are some excerpts:

Make no mistake. Rush Limbaugh is "The Passion." He is the passion of conservatism, the very pulse, bounding through the veins of the nation. He produces life with every heartbeat of his show as he scoffs at liberals and gives us his interpretation of conservative truth. His brand of ideology shakes the very foundations of liberalism.

He follows in the footsteps of giants, such as George Washington, Thomas Paine, and Ronald Reagan, promoting the ideals of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. He broadcasts affectionately trying to steer growing government towards the ideals of the Constitution....

Mildly he sits and passes on his message, his passion, his views, his legacy. A legacy of truth, justice, and the conservative American way.... There are few men in history that has received the same award as President Ronald Reagan. There are fewer men that could go on day after day under the scrutiny he faces. And there are only a handful of men that could keep themselves reserved while suffering the onslaught of the visceral hatred of "compassionate liberals."

Quite frankly, I don't know how he does it. How does he stand so strong against so much? How does he execute his duties so faithfully with the onslaught of these lies? How does he continue to go on the air? Especially when the people that presume to blackmail him walk free! "The Passion." That’s how....

Liberalism was planted deep within me, as if it were a parasite feeding on me. Rush cut it out like a surgeon excising a cancerous tumor, giving me the opportunity to experience life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. He gave me the chance of a lifetime....


The author of this essay, Chris Davis, also posts it here, along with two follow-ups. The first is a mock-eulogy for Limbaugh that presents a sort of origin myth:

In an excerpt of a speech given many times, Rush's father, Rush Limbaugh, Jr. talked about the Founding Fathers. "Of those 56 who signed the Declaration of Independence, nine died of wounds or hardships during the war," he said. "Five were captured and imprisoned, in each case with brutal treatment. Several lost wives, sons or entire families. One lost his 13 children. Two wives were brutally treated. All were at one time or another, the victims of manhunts and driven from their homes. Twelve signers had their homes completely burned. Seventeen lost everything they owned. Yet not one defected or went back on his pledged word. Their honor, and the nation they sacrificed so much to create, is still intact."

The speech, The Americans who Risked Everything, was included as an article supplement to the September 1997 issue of The Limbaugh Letter....

Those fundamentals were passed from the patriarch, Rush H. Limbaugh, Sr. to Rush H. Limbaugh, Jr. -- in turn -- passing them to Rush Limbaugh III.


The second is a note on the passing of the author's father:

... there are only two men that could've changed my life for the better. One was my father, the other Rush Limbaugh.

This is nuts. Isn't it?

Well, yes and no. On one level, obviously, it's nutty in a love-letters-to-Hitler way. But it also reminds us that right-wingers believe in themselves as figures in a great saga of good and evil. I think this really helps them gird their loins and fight in a way we can never seem to manage.

So many of the elements of legend are here: the noble descent (from sage ancestors and the Founding Fathers), the vicious enemy (us) whose "onslaught" only a rare hero can withstand, the serene demeanor of the hero ("Mildly he sits..."). "The Passion" might as well be "the Force," although it seems, in this legend, to have no Dark Side.

Liberalism, here, is an enemy worthy of legend -- a "parasite," a "cancerous tumor," spread by shape-shifting tricksters who appear "compassionate." Its foul nature even helps explain away Limbaugh's painkiller addiction, according to Davis (perhaps this is the Dark Side of the Force):

I can’t help but applaud a man with this many medical conditions going on day after day after day after day, executing liberal lies with impunity. I have too much respect and admiration for the man that put his own show ahead of pain, pushing himself into addiction and blackmail. Too much admiration for the man that removed the disease, the man that removed liberalism.

Right-wingers tell stories like this -- about Rush and about other conservatives, most notably Bush, Chosen of God.

Ultimately, these are stories about themselves. They don't grumble about their side very much because they believe in their side; they believe in their side because they think God believes in their side, and the Founders would believe in it. They believe God and the Founders would want them to smite the enemy -- us -- without mercy. So when the battle is joined, they don't hold back, and they throw everything at us they think they can get away with. After all, they're fighting for something bigger than themselves, something bigger than the day-to-day -- something mythical.

I'd like to laugh at Chris Davis -- and I would, if I didn't fear what he represents.

Wednesday, January 11, 2006

After telling us for months and months that al-Qaeda captives regularly claim torture when it hasn't taken place, right-wingers have apparently decided to try this technique themselves:

ALITO WIFE LEAVES HEARING IN TEARS AFTER DEM ATTACK

Judge Samuel A. Alito’s wife Martha left the confirmation hearing room in tears this evening, the DRUDGE REPORT has learned.

Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC) apologized to the Judge's family for the behavior of his fellow committee members during the course of the last three days.

Sen. Graham said: "Judge Alito, I am sorry that you've had to go through this. I am sorry that your family has had to sit here and listen to this."

...One senior Republican in the hearing room said of the situation: "After three full days of attacks against her husband's character, Mrs. Alito had enough. Democrat behavior during this hearing has not only been wrong, it's been embarrassing. Ted Kennedy is nothing but a bully."


(Actually, as I explained last June, the manual for al-Qaeda operatives tells them to expect real torture if they're captured -- it doesn't tell them to fake it. Apparently this is not true of the manual for Republican Party operatives.)

****

UPDATE, THURSDAY MORNING: John Cole at Balloon Juice, no fan of the Democrats on the Judiciary Committee, says Drudge is completely distorting the incident. Yes, John -- Drudge and the operatives who spoon-fed the "meanie Democrats" narrative to him.

****

UPDATE: Karl Rove must have wet himself with glee when he saw the front page of this morning's USA Today. Ditto Newsday.
A lot of people (at least here in New York) have been talking this week about the Smoking Gun's story on James Frey, author of the mega-selling Oprah-endorsed substance-abuse-recovery memoir A Million Little Pieces. The Smoking Gun conducted interviews, consulted documents, and now presents large amounts of evidence leading to the conclusion that Frey

wholly fabricated or wildly embellished details of his purported criminal career, jail terms, and status as an outlaw "wanted in three states."

Now, you'd think this might hurt his literary career. You'd think that this, combined with earlier skepticism about some of Frey's tales (such as his claim that he had a root canal without painkillers after he got clean), might lead readers to shun his work.

But I just received the weekly e-mail containing the new New York Times bestseller lists (the new lists will appear here next Sunday) -- and I see that

* Frey's newest hardcover, My Friend Leonard, has shot from #9 on the list to #1
* the hardcover edition of A Million Little Pieces has returned to the list
* the softcover edition of A Million Little Pieces has remained at #1 on the paperback nonfiction list

The moral of this story?

In this country, we apparently like self-dramatizing macho braggart ex-drunks, even when -- perhaps especially when -- we think they're lying.

Draw your own conclusions as to how this relates to the usual subject area of this blog.
HAKIM TO BUSH: WHO CARES WHAT YOU THINK?

When the new Iraqi government assumes office, ... Iraqi leaders will also have to review and possibly amend the constitution to ensure that this historic document earns the broad support of all Iraqi communities....

--Bush speech, 1/10/06

The leader of Iraq's most powerful party indicated today that his group would block substantive changes to the country's new constitution, despite a promise to Sunnis to consider amendments.

... Abdul Azziz al-Hakim, the leader of the Supreme Council for Islamic Revolution, the most influential group in the ruling Shiite coalition, today said that "the first principle is not to change the essence of the constitution," according to The Associated Press.

...Mr. Hakim appeared to rule out in particular any change in the constitution's provisions allowing the creation of strong regional provinces, a point that had angered many Sunnis....


--New York Times today

The Interior Ministry's Special Police are the most capable of the Iraqi police forces.... Many of these Special Police forces are professional, they represent all aspects of society. But recently some have been accused of committing abuses against Iraqi civilians. That's unacceptable. That's unacceptable to the United States government; it's unacceptable to the Iraqi government, as well. And Iraqi leaders are committed to stopping these abuses.

--same Bush speech

Mr. Hakim's speech today followed tough statements he made last week in the wake of suicide bombs that killed more than 200 people over two days.

Mr. Hakim criticized the United States and Sunni parties that encouraged the insurgency....

Mr. Hakim's criticism of the United States referred to recent pressure from the American forces to rein in the Iraqi security forces, which are under Shiite control.


--same New York Times article
TIPS

And as Iraqis see their own countrymen defending them against the terrorists and Saddamists, they're beginning to step forward with needed intelligence. General Casey reports that the number of tips from Iraqis has grown from 400 in the month of March of 2005 to over 4,700 last month....

--Bush speech, 1/10/06

In the week since national elections, police officers and Iraqi National Guardsmen said they have received more tips from the public, resulting in more arrests and greater effectiveness in their efforts to weaken the violent insurgency rocking the country.

--Washington Post, 2/7/05

U.S. and Iraqi officials insist they are getting more tips from Iraqis about insurgent activity since the Americans transferred sovereignty to an interim government last June.

--AP, 1/21/05

The U.S. military is reaping more high-quality intelligence tips from Iraqi prisoners than ever since it stopped using several coercive interrogation techniques after the Iraqi prisoner-abuse scandal in May, the American general in charge of Iraqi prisons said Monday.

--USA Today, 9/6/04

Saddam arrest leads to more tips, U.S. says

BAGHDAD -- The capture of Saddam Hussein has prompted many more Iraqis to come forward with intelligence about the armed insurgency...


--The Olympian, Olympia, Washington, 1/5/04

Our greatest advantage has been the one the media ignore: Few Iraqis wanted the Ba'athists back. As they began to feel more confident of American resolve, they offered ever more tips about hide-outs and arms caches....

--Ralph Peters in the New York Post, 12/15/03

Intelligence has begun flowing in at a faster rate, according to Maj. Gen. Raymond Odierno, commander of the 4th Infantry Division in Iraq.

More and more tips are coming in every day, said General Odierno in a videoconference with Washington-based reporters.

"It is probably 10- or 20-fold more than when we first started here ... the number of people we have coming in to provide us human information," he said.


--Christian Science Monitor, 10/29/03

****

(Yes, this is an update of an earlier post.)

Tuesday, January 10, 2006

John Tierney, raving about the privatized Chilean social security system in The New York Times, April 26, 2005:

... if you contribute for at least 20 years, Chile guarantees you a minimum pension that, relative to the median salary, is actually more generous than the median Social Security check.

..."I'm very happy with my account," [my Chilean friend Pablo] said to me after comparing our pensions. He was kind enough not to gloat....


John Tierney, still raving about the privatized Chilean social security system in The New York Times, May 7, 2005:

I can't protect my pension against political risk, but Pablo can help protect his against the risks of the stock market. As he approaches retirement, he can gradually shift his money out of stocks and into bonds, like the ones that financed the private road between Santiago and the port city of Valparaiso, which will be paid off by tolls.

... My pension depends on 535 politicians who will be asked to vote for steep tax increases or budget cuts that they fear could cost them their jobs. Pablo's pension depends on people driving between Chile's two largest cities.


John Tierney, still raving about the privatized Chilean social security system in The New York Times, June 14, 2005:

[Chile's] pension system has a stronger safety net for the older poor than America's (relative to each country's wages) and more incentives for people to work, because Chileans' contributions go directly into their own private accounts instead of a common pool like Social Security....

****

The New York Times today:

... "Many of those who started work when the system was first adopted are realizing that they have not been able to contribute enough to get a significant pension," [Chilean political science professor Patricio] Navia said, adding that they resent "overhead costs that are so high" and that have led to record profits for the pension funds that manage contributions automatically deducted from workers' paychecks.

...According to a recent study here, Chile's pension funds, whose number has shrunk to 6 from more than 20 as competition has diminished, recorded an average annual profitability of more than 50 percent during a recent five-year period. Other studies, including one conducted by the World Bank, indicate that pension funds retain between a quarter and a third of workers' contributions in the form of commissions, insurance and other administrative fees.

... many young people, who should be enrolling in the system early to accrue maximum benefit, are staying out or paying in very little. Some cannot afford to contribute beyond the obligatory minimum payment, which is 10 percent of wages, while others are either self-employed or have been hired by companies as low-paid independent contract workers and therefore do not have to contribute at all....

As a result of such doubts, attacking the pension system and especially the perceived excesses of the funds has become a surefire source of votes. One of the big winners in the first round of the election last month, for example, was Guido Girardi, a senator-elect ... who has taken upon himself the role of scourge of the private management funds.

"I am going to do away with these thieves in jackets and ties," Mr. Girardi vowed. "We are going to defend the citizenry from these funds that rob people of their pensions."...