Monday, January 10, 2022

TREATING COVID WITH URINE ISN'T CHRISTOPHER KEY'S FIRST SCAM

I'm sure you've seen this story:
Anti-COVID-19 “Vaccine Police” leader Christopher Key has a new quarter-baked conspiracy theory for his anti-vax followers to use to cure themselves of COVID-19: Drink their own urine. “The antidote that we have seen now, and we have tons and tons of research, is urine therapy. OK, and I know to a lot of you this sounds crazy, but guys, God’s given us everything we need,” Key said in a video posted over the weekend on his Telegram account after being released from jail over a trespassing charge. “This has been around for centuries,” he added. “When I tell you this, please take it with a grain of salt,” the anti-vaccine advocate warned while saying people might now think he is “cray cray.” “Now drink urine!” he continued. “This vaccine is the worst bioweapon I have ever seen,” he concluded. “I drink my own urine!”
Key is from Alabama. The Birmingham-based Bhamwiki has information on Key's long history of scamming.
Key graduated from Fultondale High School and studied kinesiology and exercise physiology at the University of Alabama. He was impressed as a young man by the career of Lynn Kenny who claimed to be able to cure cancer and AIDS with ray beams.

Key ... partnered with Mitch Ross in S.W.A.T.S. Fitness and Performance (an acronym for 'Sports with Alternatives to Steroids").... The company marketed unproven products for performance enhancement and rapid healing to college and professional athletes. Its flagship was a "deer antler spray" which Key claimed contained a natural form of insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1), the synthetic form of which was banned by the NCAA.

A January 2013 feature story in Sports Illustrated detailed S.W.A.T.S' history of misleading claims and its extensive relationships with athletes desperate for performance enhancers that wouldn't get them in trouble with their leagues. Notably, the story detailed a gathering with several members of 2011 Alabama Crimson Tide football team at the New Orleans Marriott just before the 2012 BCS National Championship game.
That Sports Illustrated story is here. Key told University of Alabama players that they needed his company's products because otherwise they were going to be physically depleted during the game by -- wait for it -- the energy generated by all the spectators' cellphones. (And this was before 5G!)
On the two nights before the Jan. 9, 2012, BCS national championship game, a handful of Alabama players in crimson and gray sweats made their way to room 612 in the New Orleans Marriott....

The room belonged to Christopher Key, who was in town to demonstrate the wares of S.W.A.T.S. -- Sports with Alternatives to Steroids.... Key began by telling the players that there would be thousands of cellphones in the Superdome the following night and that frequencies from those phones would be swirling through their bodies. "They're going to affect you guys very negatively," Key said rapidly and with a twang. "We figured out a way to manipulate that so that you aren't affected ... [to] give you strength, give you balance, give you flexibility and help with pain."

... Key passed out his remedy for the frequencies: stickers, which he calls chips, bearing holograms of a pyramid. Key told the players that on game day they should place the chips on three acupuncture points -- one on the inside of each wrist before they tape their arms ... and one over the heart.

... Key also showed the players gallon jugs of "negatively charged" water, which he claimed would afford them better hydration because it adheres like a magnet to the body's cells. Then he held up a canister containing a powder additive, to be mixed in water or juice, that he said had put muscle mass on a woman who was in a coma, and an oscillating "beam ray" lightbulb that could "knock out" the swine flu virus in 90 minutes. Finally, he pulled out a bottle of deer-antler spray (which also comes in pill form).
As Bhamwiki explains, this was not a viable long-term business model:
In September 2013 Alabama Attorney General Luther Strange filed a civil complaint against S.W.A.T.S., alleging at least 264 violations of the Deceptive Trade Practices Act. After a preliminary hearing on September 5, Judge Caryll Privett issued a restraining order against the business, which was raided by the Jefferson County Attorney General and Jefferson County Sheriff's Office and its assets turned over to a court-appointed receiver.
If you're running a business so shady that a Republican AG in a deep-red state sics the law on you, you must be something really bad.

But this is America, so, of course, Key is able to get on with his life's work, which now includes intimidation. Bhamwiki picks up the story:
Since losing his business, Key has worked as a mover while continuing to promote unproven medical treatments and devices under the names "Health Management Systems" and "Keys 2 Life". He has also shared numerous anti-government claims and references to alleged conspiracies, including false claims about vaccines, on social media. In 2019 he began appearing with a badge around his neck and an embroidered polo shirt reading "Vaccine Police". During the COVID-19 pandemic he has appeared at public meetings to protest against mask orders and vaccine mandates. While unemployed he has raised tens of thousands of dollars through crowdfunding platforms, part of which he has used to pay for billboards with false claims about vaccines and other political messages alongside links [to] his website.

Key was removed from a meeting of the Jefferson County Board of Education, afterward claiming his appearance as a "victory". He later berated Whole Foods employees regarding mask requirements at the store's Cahaba Village Plaza location, resulting in a trespassing charge. When he appeared at Mountain Brook Municipal Court to enter a plea, he instead mocked the judge and was forcibly removed.

Key was invited to appear at an organized anti-vaccination rally on August 14 outside of Mercy Hospital in Springfield, Missouri. He used the platform to make false accusations against vaccine developers and public health officials. He addressed a board meeting of Springfield Public Schools and picketed pharmacies. On August 16 he and a group entered a Wal-Mart store in Springfield and shouted threats at pharmacy staff who had been administering vaccinations, including a false statement that they could be put to death under the "Nuremburg Code".... After leaving, he proceeded to other pharmacies in the area to berate workers. The next morning he confronted CoxHealth CEO Steven D. Edwards in a parking lot, accusing him of "crimes against humanity".

On December 22, Key told Tulsa, Oklahoma-based business coach Clay Clark that he would confront Louisiana Governor John Bel Edwards and place him under citizens' arrest on February 7 if he continued to promote COVID vaccinations.
Key's plan was to harass multiple pro-vaccine government officials around the country, a plan he announced in a video in which he showed off multiple weapons, including a flamethrower.

Bhamwiki says:
Key was scheduled to appear in Jefferson County Circuit Court on January 4, 2022 to enter a plea on charges of 3rd degree criminal trespass from the April confrontation at Whole Foods. He was not allowed to enter the courtroom or address the judge because he refused to wear a face covering. Instead he was ordered held for contempt and booked into the Jefferson County Jail.
And when he was released, he made the urine video. He's nothing if not persistent. And he'll never lack for suckers in this country, at least as long as he stays out of jail.

ANYONE WHO THINKS THE PANDEMIC POLITICALLY HELPS LIBERALS IS AN IDIOT

In a recent New York Times focus group of Republican voters, one partcipant said this:
Gayle: I’ll be quite frank: I think that the reason that [Democrats] push Covid so much is because they’re going to try to keep the mail-in ballots. I think that they are putting the fear in people so that they can push Covid as long as possible for 2024. It’s all about control, and they’re keeping Covid as one of their biggest weapons.
Gayle believes that the pandemic is good for Democrats electorally. Your right-wing relatives probably believe this, too.

Here's the reality:
EATONVILLE, Wash. — On the morning she met her opponent for coffee, Sarah Cole walked in with a front-runner’s confidence.

To Cole, the school board seat in this rural red district about an hour outside Seattle was all but hers. Educators and community leaders had endorsed her. She had name recognition from years in the Parent Teacher Association. And, besides, she was running against Ashley Sova, a home-schooling, anti-masking member of the far-right Three Percent movement.

“I kind of thought I had it in the bag,” Cole recalled.

... In December, however, it was Sova who was sworn in, the second Three Percenter on the five-person Eatonville School Board.

... Once-fringe views about government “tyranny” now match the mainstream conservative discourse on vaccine and mask mandates, softening the public image of movements linked to political violence.

... one liberal Eatonville couple — supporters of school board candidate Cole — requested anonymity to freely describe changes in their community that make them uneasy.

... the wife ... learned how extremists organized by latching onto Stop the Steal and anti-mask events.

... Drawing from her research, the wife put together a 24-page dossier, compiled from public information, that documents Sova’s ties to the Washington Three Percent and how she was supported by influential right-wing figures and a sympathetic political action committee. It’s a forensic, time-stamped look at how one local race was influenced by a simultaneous right-wing showdown with state leaders over vaccine mandates.

Before sharing it with The Washington Post, the couple hadn’t released the information....

“We think it would’ve helped her,” the wife said with a sigh. “That’s what the concern was.”

... Sova saw running mainly as a way to register conservative discontent on the issues of the moment: mask mandates, diversity and inclusion efforts, sex education lessons.
There's more going on here than just resistance to mask or vaccine mandates, but it's obvious that the right is benefiting politcally from the persistence of COVID, not the left. The pandemic is now perceived as a Democratic/liberal failure and efforts to reduce the spread of the virus are perceived as Democratic/liberal tyranny, the perfect outrage generator for off-year elections.

I'm sick of the pandemic. I want a combination of vaccines and treatments that reduces the risk of death, hospitalization, and long COVID to trivial levels. I'd be thrilled if the drugs were so good and so accessible that it didn't matter anymore whether you were vaccinated.

The pandemic is not an evil scheme to impose social controls on an unwilling populace. The pandemic is not a scheme to monkey with elections. The pandemic is not in any way politically advantageous for those who take it seriously. It is advantageous for those who don't. That's reason enough to wish it were over.

Sunday, January 09, 2022

POLITICO'S JOHN HARRIS THINKS THIS IS A CIVIL WAR ABOUT NOTHING BECAUSE IT'S ABOUT NOTHING THAT MATTERS TO HIM

At Politico on January 6, John Harris asked: Why are the peasants all worked up?
We Are In a New Civil War … About What Exactly?

... On the anniversary of the Jan. 6 insurrection at the Capitol, we mark the evolution of journalistic cliche: Serious people now invoke “Civil War” not as metaphor but as literal precedent.

... If this is a 21st century version of 19th century disunion, shouldn’t it be more obvious what the war, at bottom, is all about?

The country many times over has witnessed dissent and disruption far more violent than anything seen in recent years. But earlier episodes featured profound ideological and moral questions ... that lay at the heart of the matter.

The real Civil War was about slavery.... Capitalists opposed to the New Deal knew why they loathed FDR — he was fundamentally shifting the balance of power between public and private sectors — and FDR knew, too.... The unrest of the 1960s was about ending segregation and stopping the Vietnam War.

Only in recent years have we seen foundation-shaking political conflict — both sides believing the other would turn the United States into something unrecognizable — with no obvious and easily summarized root cause. What is the fundamental question that hangs in the balance between the people who hate Trump and what he stands for and the people who love Trump and hate those who hate him?
Harris's inability to understand what's going on stems, in part, from his mistaken belief that all this started with the rise of Trump:
... the violent conflict spurred by the 2020 election flowed from years of conflict over every aspect of Trump’s rise to the presidency and his performance in it....

Efforts to explain Trump often rely on complex sociological or economic theories. He was a backlash to globalization and selfish elites. He exploited resentment of trade and the decline in real wages. He was the representative of people who disliked the cultural ascension of women and African-Americans and the diminution of working class white males. And so on.

All semi-plausible. All inadequate in the face of Trump’s zigs on one day and zags the next, and the obvious truth that most of his partisans are attracted to him less for any programmatic reason than for the sheer bombast of his performance — and especially that he offends his opposition.
But angry right-wingers do have fixed opinions on issues, and not just ones based in "economic anxiety." They worship guns and the Second Amendment. They unswervingly oppose abortion. They believe this is a Christian (or possibly "Judeo-Christian") nation and have no tolerance for other belief systems. They think undocumented immigrants are history's greatest monsters. They fear "Black Crime" (which used to be a tag at Breitbart). They don't loathe gay people as much as they used to, but they've shifted their loathing to trans people. Their hatred of liberals is different from the animosity that led to the Rwandan genocide only in degree. I stand by what I wrote on Twitter just after Harris's piece was published, but it's insufficient to describe how much they hate us.


And we despise them because they proudly vote for politicians who will never allow an increase in the federal minimum wage, never curtail the power of billionaires and big business, and never acknowledge that climate change is a real problem that needs to be addressed. We despise them because the rights of non-whites and non-Chritians and immigrants and LGBT people are important to us, as are abortion rights, as is the right not to live in fear of gun violence. We despise them because they've embraced the corporatist who-cares-if-they-die approach to the pandemic.

The fact that John Harris can't boil all this down to something that fits on a cocktail napkin doesn't mean the issues aren't real or profound. More likely, he just doesn't see any of it as meaningful to him. No one he knows is trying to subsist on $7.25 an hour. He's not a person of color. If anyone he cares about needs an abortion, it's probably readily available. Climate change won't get really bad until after he's dead. His immediate neighbors don't parade around with AR-15s.

Harris concludes:
The more the vitriol has risen the less consensus there is about the origins of anger. To the contrary, there is something closer to an establishment consensus that the search for root cause is folly — the Trump phenomenon defies explanation, and the threat posed by his demagoguery makes speculation about its origins an irrelevant distraction.
Oh, well, if the establishment consensus says that it's not even worth troubling one's beautiful mind over the possible reasons for what could be a nation-destroying schism, then I guess I'm wasting my time.

Saturday, January 08, 2022

THE NEW YORK TIMES CITES A PUSH POLL TO BASH COVID-AVERSE TEACHERS' UNIONS

Your right-wing relatives think of The New York Times an extremely liberal -- socialist! communist! -- news outlet, but in one way the Times is on exactly the same page as Fox News: Both despise teachers' unions in urban public schools. Here's a "straight news" Times story, written by Dana Goldstein and Noam Scheiber, that exudes contempt for unions, presenting their concerns about the current COVID surge as objectively unjustified and contrary to the public good:
Few American cities have labor politics as fraught as Chicago’s, where the nation’s third-largest school system shut down this week after the teachers’ union members refused to work in person, arguing that classrooms were unsafe amid the Omicron surge.

But in a number of other places, the tenuous labor peace that has allowed most schools to operate normally this year is in danger of collapsing.

While not yet threatening to walk off the job, unions are back at negotiating tables, pushing in some cases for a return to remote learning. They frequently cite understaffing because of illness, and shortages of rapid tests and medical-grade masks. Some teachers, in a rear-guard action, have staged sick outs.
Unions are "arguing" that Omicron makes classrooms unsafe. They "cite" understaffing and lack of tests and good masks. There's no acknowledgment, that, well, they might have a point.


Just the opposite, in fact. Here's an astonishing paragraph from the Goldstein/Scheiber story:
The unions’ demands echo the ones they have made for nearly two years, despite all that has changed. There are now vaccines and the reassuring knowledge that in-school transmission of the virus has been limited. The Omicron variant, while highly contagious, appears to cause less severe illness than previous iterations of Covid-19.
Two months ago, a paragraph like this could have been justified, even though America was in the midst of a Delta wave. Now it's abhorrent. "All that has changed" since late November is that we have a massively contagious variant that, while it causes somewhat milder disease, is still filling up hospitals because the vaccines don't stop it altogether and "milder" is a relative term.

The point of the story is: Unreasonable union demands are coming to your community soon -- and not only are the union nutjobs dangerous to the cause of in-person learning at all costs, they might cost Democrats several elections in November.
... for Democrats, the revival of tensions over remote schooling is a distinctly unwelcome development.

Because they have close ties to the unions, Democrats are concerned that additional closures like those in Chicago could lead to a possible replay of the party’s recent loss in Virginia’s governor race. Polling showed that school disruptions were an important issue for swing voters who broke Republican — particularly suburban white women.
Let's take a closer look at the link on the word "Polling."

The link goes to a press release from a group called Democrats for Education Reform. It reads in part:
A new poll, jointly released today by Democrats for Education Reform (DFER) and Murmuration found that education was one of the primary issues voters considered when casting their ballots in the 2021 Virginia gubernatorial election. Republicans–with Democrats’ help—turned a natural Democratic advantage into a Republican strength by playing into parents’ frustrations.

Of voters who ranked education as a top issue (21% overall), a whopping 70% voted for Governor-elect Glenn Youngkin....

Voters across demographics found Youngkin’s stated support to “invest more in schools, raise teacher pay, and demand better performance from our schools” (66%) convincing, including 28% of Biden voters.

Among Republicans, in particular, protecting parental involvement was an especially resonant message (96%), while Biden voters noted concerns over prolonged school closures based on unions, not science, as the most resonant argument against Terry McAuliffe (28%).
"Among Republicans, in particular, protecting parental involvement was an especially resonant message" -- that would seem more of a reference to the curriculum wars that took place during the Virginia gubernatorial campaign, and to Terry McAuliffe's poorly worded assertion “I don’t think parents should be telling schools what they should teach.”

And what should we take away from this?
Biden voters noted concerns over prolonged school closures based on unions, not science, as the most resonant argument against Terry McAuliffe (28%).
"Based on unions, not science" doesn't seem like the bland, objective wording you expect in a responsibly worded poll. And, in fact, if you look at one series of questions posed in this survey, you see that this is effectively a push poll.
Q14. Here are some statements that you may have heard during the election. Regardless of who you voted for in the election for Governor, for each one please indicate whether you find that statement very convincing, somewhat convincing, not too convincing, or not at all convincing as a reason to have voted for Glenn Youngkin or oppose Terry McAuliffe.

Q14A. [SCHOOL CHOICE] Glenn Youngkin says he will launch 20 new innovative charter schools to give parents more choices in their kids’ education. He says McAuliffe would block any school option other than any public school because he believes government officials know better than parents how to educate their children.

Q14B. [STANDARDS/REWARD TEACHERS] Youngkin says we have to go to work for our kids. He'll invest more in schools, raise teacher pay, and demand better performance from our schools.

Q14C. [PARENTS - MCAULIFFE] As Governor, McAuliffe pushed left liberal activists into Virginia schools while shutting parents out of the conversation on school curricula, saying "I don't think parents should be telling schools what to teach."

Q14D. [CRT] Glenn Youngkin says our school curricula have gone haywire. He’ll ban dangerous education programs that teach kids the only thing that matters is their skin color and that all white people are racists, while Terry McAuliffe would support the activists and bureaucrats pushing them.

Q14E. [CLOSURES W/ UNIONS] Despite CDC guidelines about safe school re-openings, Terry McAuliffe and other Democrats sided with teacher’s unions instead of scientists and kept schools closed for in-person learning for too long. Glenn Youngkin will follow the science and oppose unnecessary shutdowns.

Q14F. [CLOSURES W/ LIBERALS] Despite CDC guidelines about safe school re-openings, Terry McAuliffe and other Democrats sided with liberal activists instead of scientists and kept schools closed for in-person learning for too long. Glenn Youngkin will follow the science and oppose unnecessary shutdowns.

Q14G. [PARENTS - CHOICE] Youngkin says parents have a right to make decisions about their children's education, and he will always stand up for Virginia parents.
Every one of these statements is pure propaganda. As a rule, push polls are conducted before an election, in order to push a candidate's talking points on the public in the guise of polling, but this one appears to have been conducted after the fact, presumably in order to generate public support for right-leaning education "reform."

But why would a group called Democrats for Education Reform order up a poll like this? Well, you should take the word "Democrats" with a grain of salt. Ballotpedia explains:
DFER was founded in 2007 by a number of New York hedge fund managers, including Whitney Tilson, R. Boykin Curry IV, and John Petry. The group was founded as an alternative to the more mainstream Democratic Party positions on changes in the education system. According to Philanthropy Roundtable, the group started as a "lobbying, funding and advocacy group that plans to challenge the entrenched party power of teachers’ unions and other education sector interests, who largely define the official Democratic position on education issues."

... The financial backing for DFER has been a source of opposition from other education advocates. DFER's funding largely comes from private interests. Diane Ravitch, a progressive education expert, has called DFER a "Wall Street hedge fund managers’ group." In 2013, the Democratic Party of California denounced the group, saying DFER "is funded by corporations, Republican operatives and wealthy individuals dedicated to privatization and anti-educator initiatives, and not grassroots democrats or classroom educators."
There's other polling cited in the piece that's a smidge more plausible, though in one case it's GOP polling and in another case it's a focus group conducted for another group of right-centrist Democrats, Third Way. But the DFER polling should never have been cited.

Meanwhile, what's actually happening in schools seems a lot closer to the unions' characterization than to the Goldstein and Scheiber's:


But don't you dare close the schools, even briefly, because hedge fund managers whose ultimate goal is to abolish unionized public education in big cities wouldn't like that.

Friday, January 07, 2022

THE NEW YORK TIMES BURIES THE LEDE, WHICH IS THAT REPUBLICAN VOTERS ARE CRACKPOTS

The New York Times has just published the transcript of a focus group with eight GOP voters conducted by Kristen Soltis Anderson, a Republican pollster. The focus group was primarily about the events of last January 6. Here's how Patrick Healy and Adrian Rivera of the Times describe what it reveals:
Why Republican Voters Think Americans Have to Get Over Jan. 6

Former President Donald Trump may be popular in the Republican Party, but his conduct during the attack on the Capitol last Jan. 6 earned poor marks and stood out as a troubling memory during a discussion among eight G.O.P. voters in a Times Opinion focus group this week.

This transcript of the discussion ... offers a more nuanced portrait of Republican voters and their concerns about American democracy than the typical image of the pro-Trump party base in lock step with the former president....

Some of the Republicans said Mr. Trump could have stopped the attack on Jan. 6 sooner and others blamed him for egging on his supporters.
To Healy and Rivera, these are the most important revelations from the focus group. Oh, and also:
At the same time, several of the Republicans repeated Mr. Trump’s falsehoods about election fraud and traded in other unfounded claims, including about the Jan. 6 riot, news coverage and a Democratic push for Covid-related restrictions to supposedly ensure more mail-in balloting in future elections.
In other words, they believe crazy shit -- which really ought to be Healy and Rivera's lede. But even after acknowledging this, they suggest that what we really need to do is try to grasp where these people are coming from:
Listening to some of the Republicans rationalize their support for the president, and in some cases justify the mob violence at the Capitol, may offer insights into what makes them vote the way they do, and believe what they believe. It’s only by understanding that can we move toward a better, clearer understanding of our fellow citizens.
Here's some of what we need to understand:
Kristen Soltis Anderson: What are some of the biggest things that you remember happening in 2021?

... Sandy (from California): The vaccinations — you have to show your card. It’s almost like we’re having our civil rights taken away.
As Healy and Rivera write, some in the focus group say that "Mr. Trump could have stopped the attack on Jan. 6 sooner and others blamed him for egging on his supporters." But they don't seem particularly upset, with maybe one exception:
Kristen Soltis Anderson: Were there any things that anybody was saying or doing that made what happened on Jan. 6 more likely to occur the way it did?

Judi: People were saying that the states wanted to recount the votes because they saw fraud.

Jill: I would say Trump. Trump saying he lost the election, it was stolen from him, over and over and over again. And I think a lot of people were just getting very angry about it, feeling like the election was stolen.

Joshua: Trump’s speeches and his Twitter.

Kristen Soltis Anderson: I want to know if you think there’s anything that President Trump could have done or should have done to prevent the escalation and what happened on Jan. 6?

Judi: I don’t think you should have had that rally with all the people, with all the protesters. I think he just got everybody more ticked off.

Gayle: I think he could have stopped it earlier somehow. I remember watching it on TV and going, ‘What the hell is going on right now?’ And I was like, ‘Where is Trump during this?’ And that was the only thing that kind of came to mind in that moment, was Trump’s got to come in and do something about this. But he wasn’t, and that was a concern of mine.
But they're sure he didn't want a riot, and they're equally certain that the riot was disasteful to, um, the rioters:
Kristen Soltis Anderson: Based on what you’ve heard and your impressions of President Trump, what do you think was going through his mind when he was seeing all of this on television?

Barney: He wasn’t very happy. For sure. Because Trump’s people don’t act like that. A lot of these people were professional antagonists. I’ve lived in D.C. my whole life. They like to do it.

Sandy: People coming in there and storming and causing a ruckus didn’t achieve his goal.

Judi: His followers were not like that.
(His followers were, in fact, like that.)

Later on, we get a clarification of that reference to "professional antagonists."
Kristen Soltis Anderson: I think, Barney, you may have mentioned people coming in from other places. Who is antifa? Where are they coming in from, in your view?

Barney: I think there’s groups around the country that just — they’re professional hell-raisers, and they like to poke the bear. And they’re funded by, maybe, other countries. I’m not sure. I don’t know. Or maybe by Soros. But they’re always there, and they’re always in front.
Soros! Drink!

No true conservative would have so much as scuffed the floor of the Capitol, even though, y'know, they all had good reason to be ticked off...
Patrick Healy: A show-of-hands question: How many of you believe Joe Biden won the election fair and square?

[Jill raises her hand.]

Patrick Healy: And how many of you believe Trump really won the election?

[All but Jill and Matt raise their hands.]

Patrick Healy: Judi, you made a point at the beginning about your concern about the great political divide in the country. Do you think that Jan. 6 contributed to that political divide, or do you think other factors contribute to that divide?

Judi: I think it has a lot to do with the divide. Because there’s people like us. We feel that Trump should have won. Trump won the election. And there are others that will say no, Biden won fair and square. And that’s what’s dividing this country between the Republicans and the Democrats. I mean, even more so. I mean, really, really dividing us.
We know Trump won, but Democrats and state election authorities and the courts and the media and the majority of Congress insist that he didn't. And that's divisive!

These people also know that the evil libs have pre-stolen the next election:
Lorna: They’re already talking about the mail-in ballots with Covid. You know where that’s going to go.

Sandy: Yeah. It’s like they’re coming up with these — the right to vote thing. I’ve never been turned down to vote. Just show up and go vote. But this whole mail-in ballot thing? I think that should end right away.

Gayle: I’ll be quite frank: I think that the reason that they push Covid so much is because they’re going to try to keep the mail-in ballots. I think that they are putting the fear in people so that they can push Covid as long as possible for 2024. It’s all about control, and they’re keeping Covid as one of their biggest weapons.
Either that or the libs have a plan that's even more nefarious:
Gayle: ... I don’t think [Trump] should run again. It’s a mistake for him to run. If he runs, every Democrat is going to just vote Democrat just to not keep Trump in.
Sneaky Democrats with their sneaky plan to win the next election by casting more votes!

Okay, that's not quite fair. Gayle isn't saying it should be illegal to vote against someone just because you hate him. But those libs are just so mean!
Barney: ... I used to think it was really bad when George Bush II was president. I mean, no matter what he did, he got criticized. If you got a flat tire, it was Bush’s fault. Trump, no matter what, he couldn’t do anything. The Washington Post food critic, because [Trump] likes his steak well done, criticized him for that. What he likes.
Whereas Republicans were so nice to Bill Clinton and Barack Obama, and didn't call them murderers or rapists or drug dealers or drug addicts or communists or secret Muslims bent on the destruction of American civilization or anything!

And so we come to the final question:
Kristen Soltis Anderson: ... What would you want ... historians, 100 years from now, to know about how you think about Jan. 6?

... Joshua: About how the news was just trying to get out the story as fast as they could have and not worrying about the facts, just changing everything as they went on.

Barney: I hope they include both sides of the story and all the players involved.

Lorna: How the Democrats invaded the White House.
I speak fluent wingnut and I'm not even sure what Lorna means by "How the Democrats invaded the White House." You mean, by getting elected? Which I guess, to Republicans, is an invasion. Oh, dear -- I'm not being very understanding, am I?

THE TORCH HAS BEEN PASSED

After the Democrats' overwhelming victory in the 2008 election, there was a moment when a few Republicans said less-than-flattering things about Rush Limbaugh, who was then the king of right-wing talk radio.

They were immediately forced to recant.

There was Michael Steele:
Republican National Committee Chairman Michael Steele says he has reached out to Rush Limbaugh to tell him he meant no offense when he referred to the popular conservative radio host as an “entertainer” whose show can be “incendiary.”

“My intent was not to go after Rush – I have enormous respect for Rush Limbaugh,” Steele said in a telephone interview. “I was maybe a little bit inarticulate. … There was no attempt on my part to diminish his voice or his leadership.”
And Congressman Phil Gingrey:
Following statements made to Politico yesterday telling Rush Limbaugh to "back off," Republican congressman Phil Gingrey now has his tail between his legs. In a groveling call to Limbaugh's conservative radio program this afternoon, Gingrey offered a humble apology and described Limbaugh as a "conservative giant" ...
And Congressman Todd Tiahrt:
... in an interview with the Kansas City Star editorial board, Rep. Todd Tiahrt (R-KS) risked alienating thousands of ditto-heads by giving his honest opinion of whether Rush Limbaugh was the “de facto leader of the GOP.” “No, no, he’s just an entertainer,” Tiahrt said.

According to the Wichita Eagle ... Tiahrt’s office is now also rushing to apologize:
... “The congressman believes Rush is a great leader of the conservative movement in America — not a party leader responsible for election losses,” Sackett told The Eagle editorial board. “Nothing the congressman said diminished the role Rush has played and continues to play in the conservative movement.”
A few years later, Republicans were groveling again, but this time it was before Donald Trump. Lindsey Graham went from calling Trump "a kook ... crazy ... unfit for office" to gushing that Trump had “allowed me in his world.” Mitt Romney attacked Trump, then was humiliated when the then-president-elect invited him to dinner to discuss the job of secretary of state, after which he gave it to Rex Tillerson. Ted Cruz and Trump traded insults during the 2016 primaries, then Cruz began kissing Trump's ring on a regular basis.

But now it appears that there's a new Grand Inquisitor on the right, or perhaps Grand Humiliator, a feared enforcer of conservatively correct doctrine:
Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) found his name trending Thursday on social media for all the wrong reasons after what critics called a “groveling” and “humiliating” appearance on Fox News.

And it all started after he finally said something honest about the Jan. 6, 2021, assault on the U.S. Capitol....

Cruz this week called it a “violent terrorist attack,” in line with a Jan. 7, 2021, statement he made calling it “a despicable act of terrorism.”

Those comments enraged far-right conspiracy theorist Tucker Carlson ... who called him out over it on Fox News this week.

On Thursday, Cruz went on Carlson’s show to bend the knee, calling his own comments “sloppy” and “dumb.”

But in one of the most uncomfortable moments on Fox News, Carlson wasn’t buying it:

It's almost as if Trump has ceded sole ownership of January 6, and with it the Republican Party. Carlson is at least a co-owner now, and he enforces doctrinal purity rather than Trump.

I wonder what would happen if a Republican dared to say that Carlson isn't an important figure in the conservative movement, and is "just an entertainer." Would he be threatened with banishment until he prostrated himself and conceded that Carlson is a giant among men? Maybe Ted Cruz should test the waters. He seems to like groveling.

Thursday, January 06, 2022

THE DEPLATFORMING OPERATION WAS SUCCESSFUL, BUT DEMOCRACY DIED

This NPR story seems to exist in a world that only bears a slight resemblance to the real one:
It's been called the Great Deplatforming. In the hours and days after the U.S. Capitol insurrection on Jan. 6, 2021, Facebook, Twitter and YouTube kicked off then-President Donald Trump as well as many involved in planning the attack.

Since then, far-right groups that had used the big tech platforms to spread lies about the 2020 U.S. presidential election, stoke conspiracy theories and call for violence have been scrambling to find new homes on the internet....

They turned to the encrypted messaging app Telegram, video streaming services DLive and Rumble, and social media sites like Parler, Gab and Gettr that claim to allow users to post things that would get them in trouble on Facebook or Twitter....

"The best research that we have suggests that deplatforming is very powerful," said Rebekah Tromble, director of the Institute for Data, Democracy and Politics at George Washington University. "It means that really prominent actors who helped stoke the Stop the Steal campaign that led to the insurrection have much less reach, get much less audience and attention. And that is very, very, very important."
Terrific! So the people who spread these lies are less visible, and now nobody believes what they were saying in the days leading up to the January 6 riot. Right?

Well, no. Just as many people now believe that Democrats stole the election as believed this a year ago.

It actually doesn't matter that "far-right groups" have been kicked off social media -- the lies they were spreading are being spread now by Fox News and high-profile Republican politicians.

The NPR story goes on to tell us:
In the meantime, far-right groups are adapting: joining protests at city council and school board meetings against vaccine and mask mandates and over how public schools teach kids about race.

This new local focus doesn't require a big network to have an impact, the Atlantic Council's [Jared] Holt said.

"If the purpose of organizing is just to get a dozen people to turn out at a local government body, then you know, they don't need a channel or an account with 100,000 followers on it. They might just need a hundred," he said.
No, they don't need an account with 100,000 followers to get people to protest the teaching of racial issues in schools because right-wingers are being stirred up on that issue by high-profile demagogues who appear regularly on Fox News and are bankrolled by right-wing billionaires.

If all you knew about these subjects was what you learned from this NPR story, you'd think these were fringe ideas spread exclusively by fringe people. But these ideas are mainstream conservatism. What difference does it make whether the Proud Boys are deplatformed when Tucker Carlson isn't?

KARL ROVE, MEET KARL ROVE

Karl Rove tells readers of the Wall Street Journal editorial page that the events of January 6, 2021, were deeply disturbing to him.
... on the anniversary of Jan. 6, I’m addressing squarely those Republicans who for a year have excused the actions of the rioters who stormed the Capitol, disrupted Congress as it received the Electoral College’s results, and violently attempted to overturn the election.

...the thousands who went to the Capitol a year ago were wrong to insist the election was stolen....

... there were several thousand protesters willing to use force to disrupt Congress in its constitutional duty to receive and certify the electoral vote. Some went to Washington with that purpose in mind. Others were swept up in the moment’s savagery, led astray by stronger wills with dangerous motives.

The leaders of this group were intent on committing violence, some having planned to do so for weeks. Many wore tactical gear. Some came armed with chemical agents, flagpoles, batons and sticks. They broke through barricades and assaulted approximately 140 police officers, in some cases with an officer’s own shield or gear. They smashed doors and windows, illegally entered the Capitol, ransacked offices and searched for leaders of Congress, and made dire threats about what would happen if they found them.

... There can be no soft-pedaling what happened and no absolution for those who planned, encouraged and aided the attempt to overthrow our democracy. Love of country demands nothing less. That’s true patriotism.
The use of violence to overturn the result of an election seems to upset Rove quite a bit. But while Rove stipulates that the election was legitimate, he doesn't dwell on that fact -- which isn't surprising, given that he seemed comfortable with manipulating elections nonviolently when he was working for President George W. Bush.

Here's a Washington Post story from 2007:
Nearly half the U.S. attorneys slated for removal by the administration last year [2006] were targets of Republican complaints that they were lax on voter fraud, including efforts by presidential adviser Karl Rove to encourage more prosecutions of election-law violations, according to new documents and interviews.

Of the 12 U.S. attorneys known to have been dismissed or considered for removal last year, five were identified by Rove or other administration officials as working in districts that were trouble spots for voter fraud -- Kansas City, Mo.; Milwaukee; New Mexico; Nevada; and Washington state. Four of the five prosecutors in those districts were dismissed....

Rove, in particular, was preoccupied with pressing [Attorney General Alberto] Gonzales and his aides about alleged voting problems in a handful of battleground states, according to testimony and documents.

Last October, just weeks before the midterm elections, Rove's office sent a 26-page packet to Gonzales's office containing precinct-level voting data about Milwaukee. A Justice aide told congressional investigators that he quickly put the package aside, concerned that taking action would violate strict rules against investigations shortly before elections, according to statements disclosed this week....

Rick Hasen, a professor at Loyola Law School who runs an election law blog, said that "there's no question that Karl Rove and other political operatives" urged Justice officials to apply pressure on U.S. attorneys to pursue voter-fraud allegations in parts of the country that were critical to the GOP.

Hasen said it remains unclear, however, "whether they believed there was a lot of fraud and U.S. attorneys would ferret it out, or whether they believed there wasn't a lot of fraud but the allegations would serve political purposes."
This happened in the run-up to midterms that Rove and other Republicans worried (correctly) that they were going to lose. Rove wanted the Justice Department to put its thumb on the scale before ballots were cast. As far as I know, he's still comfortable with that.

But that's been the mainstream Republican approach to elections for years: cheat, but don't make it obvious to casual observers. I agree with Amanda Marcotte that that's likely to be the party's approach in the future:
Institutional Republicans have fully come on board with Trump's plan to steal the 2024 election. But they remain conflicted with Trump over whether or not violence is the best way to make that happen.... Republican leaders ... feel that stuff backfires.... they think it will be easier to end democracy with paperwork, rather than guns. They are busy rewriting state election laws so they can throw out any results they find displeasing, all while pretending to be a normal political party to the media, so that they don't get called out on it. The idea is to gut democracy in such a way so that the majority of Americans don't even know it happened. Violence interferes with that plan.

... The appeal of the paperwork coup is that one can end democracy without the mainstream media ever coming out and telling the public that it's happened. Instead, you get stories with quotes from Democrats warning that democracy is ending vs. Republicans claiming they're trying to "save" it. Cowardly reporters will throw up their hands and pretend there's no way to know who is telling the truth, rather than bluntly tell readers that Republicans are simply lying.
Marcotte focuses on Republicans' ability to "throw out any results they find displeasing" -- but they also like to manipulate elections so those displeasing results never happen in the first place. That's what Rove was trying to do in 2006. That's been the point of GOP gerrymandering and voter-roll purging and precinct consolidation and ID-law tightening throughout this century. No Republican considers any of that unpatriotic.

Wednesday, January 05, 2022

TRUMPIST WRITER DOESN'T WANT AN AMICABLE "NATIONAL DIVORCE," BECAUSE THEN WE WON'T BE CRUSHED

At American Greatness, Benjamin Braddock says right-wingers should stop imaging that there might someday be a "national divorce."
Every now and then an absurd idea enters the discourse and picks up a sort of memetic traction in spite of itself. The latest such idea is that of a “national divorce” in which Blue America and Red America decide they’ve had enough of each other and call it quits. It popped up most recently when U.S. Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene (R-Ga.) broached the idea on Twitter, but the idea has been entertained by liberal figures as well, most recently the comedienne Sarah Silverman.
Why is it "an absurd idea"? Because, Braddock says, those evil libs will never allow it, at least not in a mutually acceptable form.
The kind of national divorce conservatives have in mind is the amicable separation that Gwyneth Paltrow and Chris Martin sought when they introduced the term “conscious uncoupling” to the cultural lexicon. A world in which two parties could break up without losing everything. It’s an appealing idea. But when liberals say they’re considering a national divorce, they mean they want to take your kids, half your money (plus monthly payments), have you living in a dismal studio apartment furnished solely with an air mattress and a microwave, all while continuing to nag you relentlessly and blame you for their problems.
(I guess that kid with the super-small Manhattan apartment haunts Braddock's dreams. Believe me, even those of us who live here think that space is snug. None of us would wish that on anyone.)
Liberalism is fundamentally an ideology of regime change. Those on the Left are never satisfied with dominating the areas they already have, in fact they grow quickly bored with governing them, as can be seen in cities like San Francisco and Seattle. They are always looking beyond the limits of the city to the wide and wild frontier. This is their doctrine of Manifest Predestination—that the arc of history is long but it bends towards a pride flag and BLM sign in front of every house in West Virginia.

The moment that a conservative breakaway nation achieved independence and success there would be plans already underway for color revolutions and occupation by gender diverse commissars. They will never leave us alone. And they will never let us go. Why would they?
Why would we let you go? Um ... because we hate you? Because we know you hate us? Because we know you want to ban all abortions in America, force us to accept concealed AR-15s in Times Square, and never, ever allow a transition from fossil fuels? Because we understand that you don't think we deserve to vote, and that you don't think any election we win is legitimate? I have more reasons. Do you have all night?
Just as Pharaoh resisted the emigration of the Israelites, so would liberals and progressives resist their best milk cows leaving for greener pastures. Conservatives are too valuable to let go. It is our labor that keeps this whole system going.
As Roy Edroso said in response to this, "the fella seems to have a confused idea as to who's paying the bills around here. (Google 'red state blue state taxes')." The counties Joe Biden won in 2020 account for 70% of the nation's economy.
... This is the land of my parents and our grandparents and great-grandparents. If anyone is going to leave, it’s going to be the carpetbaggers. I was born here and, by God’s grace, I’m going to die here.
I'm married to a Mayflower descendant. But go on, Benjamin.

Braddock does go on, at great length, but after telling us that liberals are vicious hegemonists who want to control True Patriots' lives, he reveals that this is pure projection: His solution is for the right to control our lives, forever:
Purge the grifters and incompetents. Bring back the old sharks and have them train a new generation in the art of election warfare. And once in power, actually use that power to purge or destroy the institutions responsible for brainwashing so many of our countrymen. The Right has to articulate and act on a positive vision for America and break out of this learned helplessness that we find ourselves in as we point and object while the other side steadily achieves their goals. We have to learn from the Left in order to defeat it.

That doesn’t mean copying their framing, narrative, or tactics, but understanding their basic will to power and strategy and adapting our approach to effectively combat it. America lost Vietnam in large part due to our failure to appreciate the Maoist doctrine of political warfare. We were not fighting the same war the Viet Cong and the North Vietnamese were fighting. We see echoes of that playbook again, but this time in our own country.

We could survive losing Vietnam, we cannot survive losing America. No surrender, no retreat, no compromise. This ends in complete victory for them or us. The sooner that the entire right wing of American politics realizes that, the better the odds are that the victory will be ours.
Wait -- did he say we have a Maoist "will to power"? You'll have to excuse me a minute -- I'm laughing too hard to continue writing. Will to power? We can't even get Kyrsten Sinema to show up to a Senate caucus meeting if she has a vacation planned.

Braddock insists that "This ends in complete victory for them or us" because nothing will satisfy him -- or much of the rest of the right -- short of our complete subjugation or elimination. As for me, I'm with Greene -- let's start negotiation the right's departure from America right now. Let's call it "Foxit." Let 'em run their little tyranny outside our borders, rather than inside.

TOM FRIEDMAN IS SO CLOSE TO GETTING IT

Tom Friedman worries that there could be a repeat of January 6 after the 2024 election.
If the majority of G.O.P. lawmakers continue to bow to the most politically pernicious “alternative fact” — that the 2020 election was a fraud that justifies empowering Republican legislatures to override the will of voters and remove Republican and Democratic election supervisors who helped save our democracy last time by calling the election fairly — then America isn’t just in trouble. It is headed for what scientists call “an extinction-level event.”
He calls on one particular group to do what it can to prevent this outcome:
I think our last best hope is the leadership of the U.S. business community, specifically the Business Roundtable, led by General Motors C.E.O. Mary Barra, and the Business Council, led by Microsoft C.E.O. Satya Nadella. Together those two groups represent the roughly 200 most powerful companies in America, with 20 million employees. Although formally nonpartisan, they lean center-right — but the old center-right, the one that believed in the rule of law, free markets, majority rule, science and the sanctity of our elections and constitutional processes.

Collectively, they are the only responsible force left with real leverage on Trump and the Republican lawmakers doing his bidding. They need to persuade their members — now — not to donate a penny more to any local, state or national candidate who has voted to ... dismantle the Constitution.
Friedman is a ridiculous person -- but he's stumbled on the truth. These are the people who really run the country. If they wanted to, they could persuade the Republican Party to back away from the rejection of democracy.

But as Friedman notes, they're doing no such thing.
So what will big business do? I wish I were more optimistic.

CNBC reported Monday that data compiled by the watchdog group Accountable.US “shows that political action committees of top corporations and trade groups — including the American Bankers Association, Boeing, Raytheon Technologies, Lockheed Martin and General Motors — continued to give to the Republican election objectors.”

Kyle Herrig, president of Accountable.US, said in a statement: “Major corporations were quick to condemn the insurrection and tout their support for democracy — and almost as quickly, many ditched those purported values by cutting big checks to the very politicians that helped instigate the failed coup attempt. The increasing volume of corporate donations to lawmakers who tried to overthrow the will of the people makes clear that these companies were never committed to standing up for democracy in the first place.”

The leaders of these companies are totally underestimating the chances that our democratic institutions will unravel. And if American democracy unravels, the whole world becomes unstable. That will not exactly be good for business, either....

So, my New Year’s wish is that item one on the agenda for the next meetings of both the Business Roundtable and the Business Council will be: Which side are we on?
Friedman nearly grasps the truth, though people who are smarter than he is don't seem to have come any closer than he has to grasping it: The business community continues to bankroll Republicans who support the curtailing of democracy because big business thinks a post-democratic, illiberal, one-party America will be just fine, even if the president is Donald Trump again.

We all know America is a plutocracy, but even commentators who think that's a bad thing, and who are upset at corporations for continuing to make contributions to antidemocracy Republicans, don't seem to have grasped that it's the crucial thing: When a problem like this can't be solved through the normal governing process -- as is clearly the case now -- the only people left who could conceivably keep democracy on track are the people who, in our cash-driven system, supply the cash. Friedman, who likes the plutocrats, stumbled on this idea first.

But the plutocrats don't care. They assume that there won't be violence (I think they're right), or that any violence won't affect them. They assume that when illiberalism comes, life will go on much as before, with the same amount of buying and selling, much as it does in Hungary, the only difference being that half the country will never see its preferred candidates in power again for the foreseeable future. And they're fine with that.

Tuesday, January 04, 2022

THAT'S WHAT THEY WANT YOU TO BELIEVE (updated)

Sorry, Politico, I'm not buying this:
GOP shudders at Trump Jan. 6 speech

Senate Republicans are cringing at former President Donald Trump's plans to speak on Jan. 6, openly fretting he's trying to pull their party back into debating his false election claims.

“I don't think that's a good idea,” said Sen. Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.). “I guess it depends on what he's going to say. But early assumptions are that it's going to be an aggressive statement. I just don't think it's a good idea.”
Those "early assumptions" are undoubtedly correct. Axios reports:
A source familiar with Trump's plans said the former president would call Pelosi's investigation a "witch hunt" and embrace the protests of Jan. 6 as a legitimate reaction to a "stolen" election on Nov. 3, 2020....

Asked whether Trump would claim the riot was not violent and blame it on antifa and the FBI, the source replied, "I'm sure that will be a component."
(I'm sure you know that the right blames Antifa for the January 6 violence, but if you want to fall down the blame-the-FBI rabbit hole, Google "Ray Epps FBI" and learn all about the man every wingnut now believes was the real instigator of the riot -- on behalf of the now-deemed-evil FBI.)

More from Politico:
Then there's Sen. Joni Ernst (R-Iowa), who wants to “stay focused on congressional activities." And Sen. Pat Toomey (R-Pa.), who voted to convict Trump over his role in the Jan. 6 attack, said the event isn’t a “terribly good idea,” but added, "What am I going to do about it?”

And those were the members who decided to even talk about it. While Trump plans to defend the rioters who attacked the U.S. Capitol nearly a year ago at a press conference Thursday, Senate Republicans largely prefer to ignore him, still seeing scant purpose in provoking a prickly Trump, even a year after he's left office. In interviews Tuesday, several declined to comment and instead said their attention is on moving forward....

“There's no benefit on commenting,” said Sen. Tim Scott (R-S.C.). “So I'm not going to comment.”
Is this really how they feel? They certainly want Politico readers to believe that's how they feel -- that they're not against Trump, but they'd really prefer to put their heads down and focus on the people's business.

But they know that Trump drives base turnout, which is what they want for their party. They worry that he'll also turn out the Democratic base, but they know that if they pretend to distance themselves from him, Demorats are probably too inept at messaging to hang him around their necks.

So the plan is to pretend he's not the party's leader in any forum where swing voters might be paying attention, while benefiting from his ability to generate base turnout. I hope this fails -- I hope he's increasingly visible and the 2022 midterms are a referendum on him, with Democrats roused and ready to vote -- but I think Senate Republicans sense that if they ignore him, swing voters will ignore him, too, while GOP voters won't. That would work out quite nicely for them.

*****

UPDATE: Well, somebody got Trump to change his plans.
Former President Trump is scrapping a planned news conference on the one-year anniversary of the Jan. 6 riot at the U.S. Capitol.

The former president had planned to use the Thursday news conference at Mar-a-Lago in Palm Beach, Fla., as counterprogramming for a scheduled prayer service at the Capitol to commemorate the events of Jan. 6.

In a statement, Trump blamed the House select committee charged with investigating the Jan. 6 riot for the cancellation. He said he would instead touch on many of the themes he had planned to discuss at the news conference during a rally in Arizona set for Jan. 15.


*****

UPDATE: A blogger at RedState assures us that Trump' wimp-out totally owned the libs:
While the snowy weather may have other plans, Democrats are still tentatively gearing up for a day of “commemoration” on January 6th. Part of that will be CNN hosting a live event from the Capitol — in what is sure to be a grotesque, gaudy spectacle — in which they trump up the world’s first “insurrection” that didn’t involve the use of deadly weapons or anyone actually attempting to take over the government....

Yet, Democrats were also banking on another happening to bolster their January 6th spectacle. Donald Trump had a press conference scheduled at Mar-a-Lago on the same day, and there’s little doubt what the content of the discussion would have included. Yet, he’s now abruptly canceled it in a move that is going to leave no one upset except Democrats, who hoped to make political hay out of it.

... it’s a smart move on his part to deny them the viral clips and talking points they were banking on. I’m sure he and his advisers sat down and figured out what the game was here and chose not to play along.
I'm not the big loser! You're the big losers, libs!

A CIVIL WAR WITH NO GUNFIRE

Stephen Marche has just published a book called The Next Civil War: Dispatches from the American Future. He's also published a Guardian opinion piece titled "The Next US Civil War Is Already Here – We Just Refuse to See It." In the piece he makes some good points, particularly about the faith many liberals have that we can avoid the loss of democracy in America just by letting the system do its work. But I disagree with one of Marche's main assertions about American conservatives:
Most of the American right have abandoned faith in government as such. Their politics is, increasingly, the politics of the gun.
Is that what's really happening in America? I don't think so.

Like Marche, I'm disturbed by the coziness of the Republican Party, the police, and right-wing militias. I think we should be very concerned about this alliance.

But that isn't the main way Republicans plan to establish one-party rule in America. They'll continue to do it the way they've been doing it for years: through laws. Look at what they've done with voting and election administration in the states they control. Look at what Republicans in Washington have done to the federal courts, particularly the Supreme Court.

Unlike Donald Trump, most Republicans want their seizure of power to have a patina of legitimacy. So they purge voter rolls and pass voter ID laws and gerrymander electoral maps -- and then hold elections in which they can't lose, and it all looks legitimate. They haven't seized control of the legislatures in Michigan and Pennsylvania and Texas and Wisconsin and North Carolina and Florida through thuggery -- they've done it through legislation and favorable court rulings. They don't reject the use of force to get what they want, but they recognize that they don't really need force.

The notion that we're on the brink of an actual shooting war is a good premise for a book -- and hey, it might be true. But I think it's far more likely that we're on the verge of a bloodless coup, just like the ones that have turned many of our states into illiberal pseudo-democracies.

Monday, January 03, 2022

THE LEAST LIKELY END-OF-DEMOCRACY SCENARIO, AND THE MOST LIKELY

Vox's Zack Beauhamp has written a long, sobering article about the ways our current democracy crisis might resolve. Nearly all the scenarios are bad. I agree with Beauchamp about the dangers, but one of his doomy scenarios strikes me as highly unlikely, and one seems the most plausible.

Here's the one I don't believe is at all likely:
Barbara Walter is one of the world’s leading experts on civil wars....

Her forthcoming book, How Civil Wars Start, summarizes the voluminous research on the question and applies it to the contemporary United States. Its conclusions are alarming.

“The warning signs of instability that we have identified in other places are the same signs that, over the past decade, I’ve begun to see on our own soil,” Walter writes. “I’ve seen how civil wars start, and I know the signs that people miss. And I can see those signs emerging here at a surprisingly fast rate.”

Walter uses the term “civil war” broadly, encompassing everything from the American Civil War to lower-intensity insurgencies like the Troubles in Northern Ireland. Something like the latter, in her view, is more likely in the United States: One of the book’s chapters envisions a scenario in which a wave of bombings in state capitols, perpetrated by white nationalists, escalates to tit-for-tat violence committed by armed factions on both the right and the left.
I really can't imagine this. Can I imagine a wave of bombings of state capitols by white nationalists? Sure. What's implausible is the reaction of the left.

There are violent people on the left, but I can't think of a single faction of leftism or liberalism that's prone to violence and is likely to be angry at an attack on a state capitol. Most of the people on the left who display comfort with politicized violence are radicals, not liberals; they despise the sorts of liberal and left-centrist Democrats who work as governors and state legislators about as much as they despise conservatives. (Many despise the liberals more.) Also, I can't imagine a faction of violent leftists who are strategic. Our most violent lefties have two tactics: (1) head into a gathering of Proud Boys and get into fistfights and (2) head into an area of commercial or government buildings and start mindlessly smashing windows and setting fires. The notion that violent lefties will carefully choose bombing targets that are of strategic importance to the right seems preposterous.

Liberals, meanwhile, will wait patiently and non-violently for the authorities to bring the right-wing bombers to justice, because that's what we always do: cross our fingers and hope the system works. (Maybe we'll mount a couple of non-violent demonstrations, which might or might not be punctuated by Black Bloc knuckleheads breaking windows at a CVS. But thoughtfully targeted retaliatory violence won't happen.)

If you're a regular reader of my blog, you know which scenario in Beauchamp's article seems most plausible to me:
Since coming to power in 2010, Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán has systematically transformed his country’s political system to entrench his Fidesz party’s rule.

Fidesz gerrymandered parliamentary districts and packed the courts. It seized control over the national elections agency and the civil service. It inflamed rural Hungarians with anti-immigrant demagoguery in propaganda outlets and attacked the country’s bastions of liberal cultural power....

The party’s opponents have been reduced to a rump in the national legislature, holding real power only in a handful of localities like the capital city of Budapest....

The fear among democracy experts is that the US is sleepwalking down the same path.
Of course we're sleepwalking down the same path. Liberals and the mainstream media have finally started to bestir themselves in opposition to Trumpian assaults on democracy, but pre-Trump assaults were allowed to proceed unchecked for a decade and a half. ACORN was destroyed, precincts were closed, voter rolls were purged, and so much gerrymandering took place that Democrats can't win legislative power in many states. Those states already are Orban's Hungary.

There was no violence on the left in response to any of this. There was little or no peaceful protest. Unless that changes, we're inviting the GOP to finish the job.

I assume the next all-GOP federal government will sustain the illusion of free and fair elections while rigging the game in the party's favor indefinitely. I hope I'm wrong about this. But if it happens, it's easier to imagine our side doing nothing -- or, again, waiting for established institutions to save us -- than doing whatever might be necessary to prevent it.

THE REPUBLICAN COMEBACK WAS INEVITABLE

Nobody could have foreseen that the Republican Party's image would recover in the year after January 6...
There is no lasting stain on the Republican brand, and though most voters continue to blame Trump for the events as a congressional probe moves through his orbit and homes in on him, they do not appear ready to punish Republicans for the attack on American democracy.

The GOP’s recovering brand

Between August 2020 and immediately after Trump’s supporters raided the Capitol, the share of voters who said the GOP was headed in the “right direction” fell from 32 percent to 24 percent, driven largely by Republicans and independents. But now, sentiment about the Republican Party’s trajectory is slightly better than it was before Jan. 6....

According to the latest data, gathered Dec. 18-20 among 2,000 registered voters ahead of the anniversary of the Jan. 6 attack, 34 percent say the Republican Party is headed in the right direction, matching voter optimism toward the Democratic Party’s own tack. Though improvement was observed across the partisan aisle, it was most notable among Republicans, 65 percent of whom say their party is headed in the right direction — up 14 percentage points since January 2021.

To some extent, the Republican recovery seen in this Morning Consult poll is happening because the notion that Joe Biden is a failed president has calcified into conventional wisdom. To some extent it's because Democrats have struggled to pass their agenda in as public a fashion as possible -- every missed deadline is a public embarrassment, and no one tries to keep the infighting behind the scenes. It's happening because of the persistence of the pandemic, and because gas costs more than $3 a gallon.

But it's also happening because too many Democrats -- not just Joe Manchin and Kyrsten Sinema, but even some who want to change the Senate's filibuster rules -- have endorsed the idea that getting Republican buy-in for their legislation confers legitimacy. They've made a Republican, Liz Cheney, the face of the House January 6 committee. Nancy Pelosi and others say that America needs a "strong Republican Party" -- and while Pelosi also says the GOP is currently in thrall to extremists, she strongly suggests that there are responsible, mainstream Republicans who could wrest control from the crazies at any moment.

Marjorie Taylor Greene, Madison Cawthorn, Paul Gosar, and their ideological allies are the real stars of the GOP, but Democrats never try to make them the faces of the party. They're treated as eccentric outliers who momentarily have our attention. Meanwhile, Republicans have their base convinced that Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and other members of "the Squad" are the real leaders of the Democratic Party, and are more extreme than they actually are.

In the past year, the Republican Party has embraced Trump, January 6, and the notion that Democrats stole the 2020 presidential election -- and the logical conclusion to be drawn from that is that the GOP base has increasingly positive feelings about the party because it takes these positions. But what Democrats say about Republicans is that some of them voted for the infrastructure bill, and some of them (or so Joe Manchin claims) might support a voting rights bill, and two of them are true patriots because they're on the January 6 committee -- so now more Democrats approve of the GOP as well.

Democrats could assert that the GOP is a pariah party, or at least that it should be treated as one. They could assert that extremists are the true leaders of the GOP and that the party's agenda is pure radicalism. Why not? Republicans say every one of these things about Democrats, on a daily basis. They say Democrats aren't real Americans. And it works.

Sunday, January 02, 2022

THOSE POLL NUMBERS ON ANTI-GOVERNMENT VIOLENCE ARE (SOMEWHAT) LESS ALARMING THAN THEY SEEM

Some results from this Washington Post poll are getting a lot of attention:
The percentage of Americans who say violent action against the government is justified at times stands at 34 percent, which is considerably higher than in past polls by The Post or other major news organizations dating back more than two decades. Again, the view is partisan: The new survey finds 40 percent of Republicans, 41 percent of independents and 23 percent of Democrats saying violence is sometimes justified.
The view is partisan, but a lot more Republicans share it.

As noted, this question has been asked in other polls over the years, with much less support for violence:


If you can't read the screenshot, the 34% acceptance of at least some anti-government violence now compares to 23% in 2015, 16% in 2010 and 2011, and 13% and 9% in two polls conducted in 1995.

The wording of the question is "Do you think it is ever justified for citizens to take violent action against the government, or is it never justified?" When CBS asked the same question in 2011, the partisan breakdown was as follows:
Republican 28% yes, 64% no
Democrat 11% yes, 81% no
Independent 11% yes, 81% no
Republicans were much readier for anti-government violence then, too. But to be sure of the pattern, we'd need to see the numbers if the question were asked during a Republican presidency. For some reason, it appears that it's been asked only when a Democrat is in the White House.

In the current poll, respondents who said anti-government violence could sometimes be justified were asked to name circumstances when that would be the case. For the most part, the answers seem ... not unreasonable.


When the question was asked in that 2011 CBS poll, there was some pushback from the left as well as the right. At National Review, Daniel Foster wrote:
... what does surprise me is that 76 percent of respondents, including 64 percent of Republicans, think it is never right to take up arms against the government. Ever.

What about if the government canceled the next election and started seizing first-born; or arbitrarily disappearing whole classes of citizenry; or summarily abolished private property and confiscated all our belongings at the tip of a bayonet? Not even then? Gosh, even Hobbes thought you had a right to violently resist a state that was trying to kill you.
While Robert Farley wrote this at Lawyers, Guns & Money:
... I can’t even imagine answering “No” to such a categorical question; there are obviously a number of situations in which I would consider anti-government violence justified. The United States government (like every government) functions through the implicit threat of violence. It is often unjust to and brutally unrepresentative of the interests of the disadvantaged. I think that if the question were asked again of liberals, but framed in the context of something like the Wounded Knee Incident, the answer might be quite different.
I think the overall numbers are higher than they've been in the recent past because more Americans now can imagine a government that's truly oppressive or anti-democratic -- in the new poll, generally speaking, respondents aren't saying that the government should be overthrown merely because it's not to their taste.

On the other hand, I think Republicans have been more accepting of the idea of anti-government violence because they're told every day by their favorite media outlets that they're on the verge of being victims of government repression. They think there's already been a coup that overthrew the results of a legitimate election. They think the government is already socialist.

So I'd say that Americans support violence against the government for mostly legitimate reasons -- but Republicans, despite being members of the party that's far more likely to turn America post-democratic, are more likely to believe that their subjugation is imminent.

Saturday, January 01, 2022

BREITBART COMMENTERS DON'T THINK THAT RACIST JUDGE IN LOUISIANA DID ANYTHING WRONG

Judge Michelle Odinet has resigned.
A Louisiana judge has resigned weeks after footage from her home appeared to show her repeatedly using the N-word and comparing a burglary suspect to a “roach.” Michelle Odinet was Lafayette City Court Judge until Dec. 31, when she announced her resignation. She was previously on unpaid leave. In a letter to the Louisiana Supreme Court, Odinet wrote that she took “full responsibility for the hurtful words.” ... The video appeared to show one of Odinet’s sons describing her reaction to an attempted burglary of the family’s cars. “And Mom’s yelling n****r, n****r,” the male voice said. A woman soon added “we have a n****r. It’s a n****r, like a roach.” Odinet later blamed the incident on her “fragile” mental state at the time, and sedative use.
Odinet may be the last of a dying breed -- a bigoted public figure in a red state who resigned under circumstances like this instead of going on offense. I've looked at Breitbart comments on her story, and I sense that she would have had plenty of supporters if she'd decided to stay on the job:
It appears a criminal POS, of the black ethnic persuasion, burglarized several vehicles at her home!
I sympathize with her disgust at some turd who resorts to preying on honest productive citizens.
Betcha it wasn't this black turds first outing taking that which isn't his... to sell for an easy profit!
I wonder if he'd been arrested before and released by a George Soros leftist sponsored DA?

****

Why do only blacks have an automatic cancel word? A word that only blacks may say all they want, but if uttered by a non-black it gets their lives ruined. A word we hear every day, but it may only come from black lips. It is important that blacks have their own cancellation term.

****

this is part of the genocide against white people. deny whitey freedom of speech !!!!!! blacks in America, as anywhere on the planet, want to and will kill off all white people as they have done in Africa.

****

Additionally, if the majority of Black comics (especially) couldn't use the term 'MFer', they couldn't complete a sentence.

****

Or this same N word.

****

common everyday language used by blacks. the primitives want to deny white folks freedom of speech. for every one time I have heard a whitey use the N word, I have heard it used 100 times by the primitives,

****

She should apologize for the statement ...

But by all means - NEVER QUIT - especially for a stupid word that many in the Black community use in its every day vocabulary ...

Regressives NEVER give up for any reason - just ask Governors Northam and Cuomo, or PM Trudeau. They only leave when they outlive their political usefulness - it's never an issue of integrity ...
(For the record, Governor Andrew Cuomo resigned in 2021.)
racist racist everything is racist to you liberal white trash,would you let naggers in and rob you off for the sake of harmony with them?would you let naggers come and sexually assault your wife or daughter and do nothing for the sake of racial harmony?pathetic cucks like you are in millions across europe who turn a blind eye to rapes molestations even murders of young euro girls at the dirty hands of illegal termites

****

The fear if riots caused the election results if 2020. Justice is being handled by blackmail and threats.

****

Whites should start a freedom struggle in Europe and America to get rid of non white races in their nations. These blacks, browns, yellow succeeded in driving out whites from their nations exactly by citing the concept of fairer skin tone and nothing else. Before whites went to their nations they were happy to live like slave under whatever king who laid siege to their places!

****

Nah. It is quite simple. Whites need to leave Big Cities and Metropolitan areas.

****

I disagree. Whites need to stand their ground and defend not only themselves, but their heritage and ancestry!

****

Agree. But do consider once the cities are conquered the invasion is complete

****

A real man or a real country will protect their women and most vulnerable. Muslems oppress women, beat women, have Shira laws for women, and we give them safe spaces, no go zones, to commit crimes against women. Yikes.

****

Ever heard stories about Muslim or other Emperor Kings in Africa, India,China etc having orgies with literally any girl or woman he chooses or chopping of heads of his own valued ministers for just not making him laugh? Read history books you jack arsse leftist p-ig. Its whites who evolved and created concepts of rule of law and judge and lawyers. Its not as if Apes like you in Africa were playing NBA or NFL that whites bought you as slaves. Your own black rulers sold you off to the highest bidder you a..hole. Blame your own people for all the misery and if you really want to end all the misery go back to your nations. Your people succeeded in driving out whites from your nations although whites also lived there for like only 200-300 years same like you have been living in white world. . Now why make fake freedom struggles here. What do you want ? To drive out whites from their own nations? Where do you want the whites to go? Oh you want them to die right? Then its better you pack your bags and leave. Only then it will be full circle

****

they didn't drive whites out...they enslaved them and hunt them for sport.

****

stupid n1qqers crawl back to your ghetto your superfat ugly weflfare queen mama gonna serve you watermelon

****

How long before it's legal in America to murder white people for saying the N-word? Even using the N-word on men who have râped your daughter or murdered your cousin? Mind you, this word is used in almost every sentence by the entire black thug population, the George Floyd's of this world if you will.

****

I'll say it. if it wasn't for White people, Black people wouldn't have running water. They should also thank us for not leaving them in the homeland to be raped their kids raped killed, and turned into militia. It's great being White.
Many guardrails are down, but it's still difficult to live down the public use of the N-word. It's only a matter of time, though, before that taboo crumbles. Fairly soon, some officeholder will get caught saying it and reject all calls for resignation. And eventually we'll all get tired of waiting for the comeuppance, which will never arrive.