Friday, May 15, 2015

TSARNAEV'S FATE: GRIM EITHER WAY

There really wasn't much likelihood that this would turn out any other way:
In a sweeping rejection of the defense case, a federal jury on Friday condemned Dzhokhar Tsarnaev to death for his role in the 2013 Boston Marathon bombings.

The jury found that death was the appropriate punishment for six of 17 capital counts -- all six related to Mr. Tsarnaev’s planting of a pressure-cooker bomb, which his lawyers never disputed. Mr. Tsarnaev sat stone-faced as the verdict was announced.

At the same time, the jury rejected the centerpiece of the defense argument, that he was under the influence of his older brother, Tamerlan, a self-radicalized jihadist. Nor did it believe that being locked away in the supermax prison in Colorado would sufficiently restrict Mr. Tsarnaev’s communications with the outside world.

Only two of the 12 jurors said on the verdict form that they believed he had expressed sorrow and remorse for his actions, a stinging rebuke to Sister Helen Prejean, a Roman Catholic nun who had testified for the defense that Mr. Tsarnaev was “genuinely sorry” for what he had done....
I'm inclined to oppose the death penalty on principle, but it's really only on principle that you could reject it in this case, as far as I'm concerned -- this was a horrible crime, and any remorse Tsarnaev seemed to show was likely nothing more than an effort to save his own ass. If you think the judicial system shouldn't kill, that shouldn't matter. If you don't have that scruple, it's hard to make a case for sparing this guy. (Unless, of course, you argue that this will make him a martyr to the cause. I've said before that I think it will. So that's a reason.)

The notion that a supermax wouldn't sufficiently sequester him is, frankly, ridiculous. We already have Richard Reid, Zacarias Moussaoui, and Ramzi Yousef (not to mention Ted Kaczynski, Eric Rudolph, and Terry Nichols) in the supermax where Tsarnaev would have spent his life if he'd been spared. It's not exactly a country club:
If Boston Marathon bomber Dzhokhar Tsarnaev is spared the death penalty, he will likely spend the rest of his life at the most restrictive prison in America, a place so isolating that it has been called a clean version of hell.

The United States Penitentiary Administrative Maximum Facility -- aka ADX, or "supermax" -- is where the federal government sends its worst criminals, from terrorists to traitors....

Even in general population, the ADX imposes extreme isolation. Prisoners spend about 23 hours a day in solitary confinement in 12-by-7-foot cells with a single 4-inch-wide window and walls thick enough to stifle any attempts at communication. A slot in the door is used to deliver meals and for any visits.

Amnesty International last year said the facility breached international standards for the humane treatment of prisoners.

"It breaks down the human spirit, it breaks down the human psyche. It breaks your mind," former supermax inmate Garrett Linderman told CBS' 60 Minutes in 2009.

Thirty-three convicted terrorists have been sent to ADX, ... and since 2002 they have been placed in a special section called "H unit" where they live under even tighter restrictions: no contact with the media or other inmates and personal visits and phone calls only with immediate family, for example.

Ryan Grim of the Huffington Post says:



Yes, but if we choose not to lethally inject a terrorist, we send him to a place like the ADX and subject him to madness-inducing extremes of isolation. Yes, h'll get ten hours a week of exercise, but even that takes place in a cage not unlike the one in which that Jordanian pilot was burned:



The isolation makes people crazy. The New York Times Magazine did a story about ADX in March, and in a post I wrote about Tsarnaev and supermaxes I delicately alluded to what happened to one prisoner there who was driven crazy by solitary. I'm quoting the paragraph now, so you know what the "milder" penalty in this case could have been like. WARNING: This is not for the squeamish.
Over the next decade, Powers, by any rational accounting, lost his mind. He cut off both earlobes, chewed off a finger, sliced through his Achilles’ tendon, pushed staples into his face and forehead, swallowed a toothbrush and then tried to cut open his abdomen to retrieve it and injected what he considered “a pretty fair amount of bacteria-laden fluid” into his brain cavity after smashing a hole in his forehead. In 2005, after slicing open his scrotum and removing a testicle, Powers was sent to the medical center for federal prisoners in Springfield, Mo., for treatment, where a psychiatrist determined he was “not in need of inpatient psychiatric treatment or psychotropic medication” and that his behavior “was secondary to his antisocial disorder.” When he was returned to Springfield four years later, after slashing his wrists and writing “American Gulag” in blood on his bedsheets, the doctor wrote, “Considerations that [Powers] has some form of psychosis, thought disorder or mental illness are unfounded.”
Jack Powers managed to get out of this hellhole, and got back on the road to sanity. But his crimes were nothing compared to Tsarnaev's.

So relax, folks. Tsarnaev was always going to suffer. In his shoes, I wouldn't even appeal.

WOW ... JUST WOW



She's referring to this:



At The American Spectator, Emily Zanotti writes:
You can watch the full interview above. In it, both James and Judith talk about the state of the media today, and how, in the last several years, the attitude -- and, more importantly, the professionalism -- of the once noble Fourth Estate has declined, leaving a profession that is less interested in sniffing out the real story than it is in fortifying it's own pre-determined ideology, and feeding the vast connected network of partisan media on the left red meat to perpetuate their outrage.
No, I didn't make that quote up.

At National Review, John Fund adds:
It might seem an odd pairing...
Well, no, not really.
It might seem an odd pairing, but guerilla documentarian James O’Keefe and former New York Times foreign correspondent Judith Miller hit it off at the recent Right Online conference, a freedom-oriented bloggers conference in Washington. So much so that O’Keefe sat down with Miller for a 50-minute interview.
Right Online? That would be these guys:



Top-billed speaker at this conference? Sharyl Attkisson, naturally.

Fund goes on to write:
[Miller] also gives her candid views on many of her journalistic colleagues. “Skepticism should unite all journalists, and also the desire to hear the other person out and never have a closed mind,” she says. “I find it interesting that I find much more openness at Right Online than I find in many more classic liberal circles....”
I don't think "openness" means what you think it means, Judith.

Oh, and Fund notes a racial cheap shot thrown by Miller (emphasis added below):
The double standard of the mainstream media has been exacerbated of late by two events, Miller believes. First, President Obama has on many issues been given “a pass” because he’s the first black president of the United States. Secondly, the New York Times has moved further left since she left the paper in 2005. “The opinions of the editorial board have drifted and dribbled in the news side” more and more often she believes.
Fund concludes:
The rest of the interview makes for a fascinating session in which a print journalist and a videographer agree that regardless of the way they approach stories, they are both, in Miller’s words, “poking holes in comfortable narratives.” And that should be what good journalism is often about.
Yes, really -- validating a flawed and deceitful case for war that came directly from the White House was part of the process of “poking holes in comfortable narratives,” according to Miller.

I confess I've made it through only seven minutes of the clip above. I turned it off the second time Miller said that certain people are unfit to criticize her because "they don't know me." Did you realize that if you want to criticize the published work of a reporter for the most important newspaper in America, you have to be personally acquainted with that reporter? Me either.

A CURIOUSLY TIMED POLL SHOWS BEN CARSON TIED FOR THE GOP LEAD

This is a surprise:
Following a trio of Republican campaign announcements last week, Ben Carson leaps to the top spot of GOP presidential candidates in the latest Fox News poll tied with presumed GOP front-runner Jeb Bush....

Both Bush and Carson sit atop the Fox poll at 13 percent each among Republican primary voters. That's a seven-point bounce for Carson who was at just 6 percent in the same poll in April.
Or maybe it's not really a surprise, given what we're told in this story (from Crooks and Liars, reprinted from The Washington Times):
GOP Explores Special Debate Rules For Carson, Fiorina

Republicans face a tough task in trying to craft rules for their presidential primary debates - and in particular, making sure they write the rules so that Ben Carson and Carly Fiorina, who are running well behind in the polls, find a place on the stage....

The prospect of Ms Fiorina, the only major announced woman candidate in the field, and Mr. Carson, the only black candidate, being shut out is worrisome to Republicans.

"It doesn't play well into the Republican narrative if those people are not on the stage," said Patrick Griffin, a GOP strategist with Purple Strategies. "The party needs to be reaching out to all kinds of constituencies."

... "We are completely confident that Dr. Carson's campaign and candidacy will 'qualify' him for the sanctioned debates," said Doug Watts, a Carson spokesman.
First, the obvious point: Is the RNC willing to shoehorn Fiorina and Carson into the debates by, y'know, affirmative action? It sure seems that way.

But maybe that won't be necessary. If a few pollsters show the two gaining ground, affirmative action won't be necessary. And, well, what do you know: Carson, at least, is suddenly soaring in the Fox poll. Will Fiorina shoot to the top in a subsequent Fox poll? Or maybe a Rasmussen poll? Or some other ideologically friendly survey -- a mysterious internal GOP poll that's leaked to the press, perhaps?

Hard to know. Maybe the well-heeled Fiorina will be able to arrange a "spontaneous" outpouring of support in the Iowa Straw Poll. Whatever the mechanism, I'm sure we'll get a wave of phony Carlymania just in time for the debate lineup to be finalized.

Thursday, May 14, 2015

MAYBE JEB'S APPLE WATCH CAN OPERATE ON LUIS LANG'S EYES



Yes, that's what he said:
After calling for the repeal of the Affordable Healthcare Act during a Thursday stop at a brewery in Tempe, Ariz., Bush touted the potential of the health apps on his new Apple Watch

"On this device in five years will be applications that will allow me to manage my healthcare in ways that five years ago were not even possible," Bush told his audience. "I'll have the ability, someone will, you know, because of my blood sugar, ... someone will send me a signal it'll come here, I'll get a double beep saying 'you just ate a butterscotch sundae or something like that. You went way over the top. You're a diabetic, you can't do that -- whatever, we'll be able to guide our own healthcare decisions in a way that will make us healthy. Ultimately, we have to get to a health system, away from a disease system."
Dave Weigel sees this as out-of-touch rich-guy-ism:



Which it obviously is. But it's more than that. Think about Luis Lang, who refused to obtain private insurance, then refused to obtain Obamacare, and is now going blind:
Lang, a 49-year-old resident of Fort Mill, S.C., has bleeding in his eyes and a partially detached retina caused by diabetes.

“He will lose his eyesight if he doesn’t get care. He will go blind,” said Dr. Malcolm Edwards, the Lancaster ophthalmologist who examined Lang....

Edwards said he would provide care at no cost, but Lang now requires surgery and follow-up treatment that is beyond his expertise. His Eye & Laser Center has a network of specialists who work on a sliding scale and organizations that sometimes help with donations. But Lang requires such extensive and ongoing work that there’s no way to guarantee there won’t be significant bills, Edwards said.
Hey Jeb, got any apps on that watch that can reattach a retina and do a significant amount of follow-up care?

Yes, it's diabetes that damaged Lang's eyes, and the technology Bush is talking about could conceivably help a patient monitor blood sugar effectively, either on an Apple Watch or the inevitable cheaper knockoffs. But if you don't heed its warnings, or if heeding its warnings doesn't prevent calamitous health consequences, or if something happens to you that falls outside the technology's ability to help you, you're oing to need more medical care than you can get from a toy -- whoops, sorry, a highly sophisticated wearable -- on your wrist.

And while Jeb is a rich guy and Lang was merely a comfortable member of the middle class until his illness took away his ability to work, the two of them -- both Republicans -- suffer from the same problem: failure of imagination and belief that truly bad things don't happen to good (i.e., Republican) people. Jeb is talking as if this wearable tech will magically make the need for real health care go away. Lang believed that there was nothing that could happen to him healthwise that he couldn't handle out of pocket.

But good fortune runs out. Lang gets that now, maybe. Bush? Not so much.

IMAGINE IF SOMEONE IN THE NEWS MEDIA GAVE TO A BUSH CHARITY -- OH, WAIT, SOMEONE DID (updated)

I guess no one cares about any story right now except this one:
ABC News chief anchor George Stephanopoulos has given $50,000 to the Clinton Foundation in recent years, charitable contributions that he did not publicly disclose while reporting on the Clintons or their nonprofit organization, the On Media blog has learned.

In both 2013 and 2014, Stephanopoulos made a $25,000 donation to the 501 nonprofit founded by former President Bill Clinton, the foundation's records show. Stephanopoulos never disclosed this information to viewers....
That would never happen in the case of a Republican ex-president, much less in the case of a Republican ex-president with family members who might also run for president someday -- right?

Oh, sorry, we may never know for sure. (Emphasis added below.)
[The Clinton Foundation is] certainly more transparent than the foundations that George W. Bush and George H.W. Bush established to fund their presidential libraries and other activities. The George W. Bush Foundation raised $361.8 million between 2010 and 2013, according to its latest tax filing. But it does not have a policy of full disclosure for its donors. According to Hannah Abney, the communications director for the George W. Bush Presidential Center, the names of the foundation's major donors are etched into three "donor walls" in the Dallas-based Bush Center at Southern Methodist University, and the "Freedom Registry," located at the entrance to the George W. Bush museum and library, lists donors who have contributed more than $20. No specific donation amounts are noted, and there's a catch: Any donor who wishes to remain anonymous is not named. Moreover, the only way to see the list of nonanonymous donors is to visit the actual museum and look at the walls and the registry. The George W. Bush Foundation does not make its list available in any other form or in any other place.
However, we do know this (again, emphasis added):
Bush Center officials declined to discuss individual donors and focused instead on how the center’s George W. Bush Institute has been a particular draw for philanthropists, corporations and others. The think tank centers on issues like education reform, global health and military service.

Among those giving specifically to the institute, which launched in late 2009: The News Corp. Foundation, AT&T, the Sid W. Richardson Foundation and the Bass Foundation.
So Rupert Murdoch gave to a Bush charity and everyone yawned. Why am I not surprised?

****

UPDATE: And there's a gift from News Corp to the Clinton Foundation:



****

UPDATE: Know who gave more than $1 million (and possibly as much as $5 million) to the Clinton Foundation?

Newsmax Media, Inc.

HOW CAN NEWSMAX OBJECTIVELY COVER THE 2016 ELECTION?????

TASTEFUL!

I'm posting this as a screenshot in case Thompson (yes, it's really him) has an attack of conscience and deletes it:



Thompson's Twitter feed consists exclusively of right-wing one-liners. Most of them are just cornball and irritating. This one exploits a man's death. Nice one, Fred.

Oh, but I forgot -- Democrats and liberals who've pointed out that a fatal train accident happened in a place where a lifesaving technology upgrade hasn't been implemented are the real ghouls. So forget I ever brought this up.

REPUBLICANS NOW MORE EMBARRASSED BY JEB THAN BY GEORGE W.

Are you as surprised as I am to see Republican presidential candidates (and possible candidates) distancing themselves from the Iraq War? If we'd known there were no WMDs, John Kasich says we shouldn't have gone to war. So does Ted Cruz. (Ted Cruz!) So does the usually hawkish Chris Christie. So does Marco Rubio, even though he just gave an incredibly bellicose speech to the Council on Foreign Relations, and even though, on Fox News less than two months ago, he categorically rejected the notion that the Iraq War was a "mistake": "The world is a better place," he said, because Saddam no longer rules Iraq.

Yes, polls show that even many Republicans now think the war was a mistake, but the poll numbers vary widely -- a 2014 New York Times/CBS poll said that 63% of Republicans think the war was not "worth the costs" -- but in an NBC/Wall Street Journal poll that same year, 46% of Republicans said the war was worth it, as opposed to 44% who didn't.

What's more, a 2015 Fairleigh Dickinson University survey reported that 51% of Republicans think WMDs actually were found in Iraq, as do 52% of Fox viewers. Oh, and George W. Bush has an 88% favorable rating among Republicans, according to a 2014 Gallup poll.

So why does the entire GOP presidential field seem to be running away from the war? I think it has less to do with W's war than with Jeb's defense of the war (and of his brother). The problem is that Jeb is defensive -- look at the way he defended the decidion to go to war:
[Megyn] Kelly: "On the subject of Iraq, very controversial, knowing what we know now, would you have authorized the invasion?"

Bush: "I would have, and so would have Hillary Clinton, just to remind everybody, and so would almost everybody that was confronted with the intelligence they got."

Kelly: "You don't think it was a mistake?"

Bush: "In retrospect, the intelligence that everybody saw, that the world saw, not just the United States, was faulty. And in retrospect, once we invaded and took out Saddam Hussein, we didn't focus on security first, and the Iraqis in this incredibly insecure environment turned on the United States military because there was no security for themselves and their families. By the way, guess who thinks that those mistakes took place as well? George W. Bush."
He's defending it from a defensive crouch. He's using Hillary Clinton as a human shield. He's opening himself up to attacks from the "liberal media," and he's acting as if he expects such attacks, and believes they're completely understandable.

The Republican base embraces politicians who are on offense against liberals, Democrats, and the media. If you're attacking, and if you have the enemy (us) sputtering angrily at what you're saying, you're a hero. But as soon as you're the subject of our mockery and scorn, you're a loser. That's what's happened to Sarah Palin, Chris Christie, and Bobby Jindal, as well as, to some extent, Ted Cruz and Ben Carson. By contrast, Scott Walker has large amounts of screw-the-liberals capital from his union fight and three election victories in Wisconsin -- which is a big reason why, even though he's down from his peak, he's still near the top of the GOP polls, despite not being an establishment or media darling.

If Jeb had given a defiant, unyielding answer like the one Rubio gave on Fox in March, we'd be horrified, but he'd be cheered on the right (apologies for this faulty transcript, which is directly from Fox):
RUBIO: The world is a better place because Saddam Hussein does not in Iraq. Here's what I think might have happened, had we not gone. And you might had an arms race to put Iraq in Iran, they are both would purse the weapon. I will be dealing with two problems, not just one. We forget that Iraq, at the time of the invasion, was an open defiance of numerous United Nations Security Council resolutions, that the United Nations refused to enforce. They were, they were, they were refused to comply with allowing inspectors in. Repeatedly, this was a country whose leader had gassed his own people on numerous occasions. So I think, Hindsight is always 20/20, but we don't know what the world would look like if Saddam Hussein was still there. But I doubt it would look better in terms of -- it will be worst -- or we are just bad for different reasons.

... Saddam Hussein was an open violation of United Nations Security Council resolutions, including not allowing inspectors to come in on the ground, et cetera, and the world refused to enforce it. So that, that's another point that means to be remembered that after time of that invasion, Saddam Hussein was an open defiance of numerous Security Council resolutions to refuse to comply with.
Similarly, if Jeb had acknowledged his brother as an advisor openly and proudly, rather than in a statement at a closed-door meeting that was leaked to the press, the reaction would have been different. Jeb could have said, Did my brother make mistakes? Sure. All presidents make mistakes. But he understood the nature of the threat, which is radical Islam. He knew that American strength and resolve are needed, not weakness and vacillation. A president's first order of business is to keep America safe and free, and my brother never forgot that.

Jeb, that's what the rubes want. You blew it, and now everyone's running away -- not from your brother, but from you.

Wednesday, May 13, 2015

SO APPARENTLY IT SHOULD BE MANDATORY FOR RICH PEOPLE TO DONATE TO RELIGIOUS MUSEUMS

Not far from where I'm sitting, Manhattan's Museum of Biblical Art is hosting its final exhibition before closing. In the New York Post, Naomi Schaefer Riley tells us that it's closing because rich people are hateful bigots:
The surprising truth about the Bible & modern bigotry

In a little more than a month, the Museum of Biblical Art is going to close. It’s a small museum on the Upper West Side, but it has consistently put on high-quality exhibits and the fact that it will disappear is a shame.

But what’s even worse is the reason that it can’t keep its doors open -- it’s too religious.

The museum, founded in 1997, took a clearly secular perspective on its work -- suggesting that the “Bible is a culturally foundational text, which has greatly influenced artists historically and continues to inspire the creation of countless important works of art today.”

But apparently too many donors were wary even of that. As one former publicist for the museum recently told The New York Times, “Just having the world ‘Bible’ in the name says to many people that we’re a conservative, right-wing group, and that could not be further from the case.”

Which should tell you something about where the cultural elite is right now.
If I'm following that logically, it's not the Jesus that's preventing rich donors from giving, it's the perception of conservatism. So that's bigotry now? Should we have mandatory donations across ideological lines?

In fact, as we learn from The New York Times -- which has, by the way, called the museum's current exhibition "beautiful" and "soul-stirring" -- the museum is closing because it's housed in the American Bible Society's headquarters, and the ABS is moving to Philadelphia, which means the museum would be facing a steep rent hike in an extremely pricey real estate market:
... in looking at possible Manhattan sites for a new home, it concluded that it would need $1.5 million to $5 million more per year to cover rent, over its average annual operating budget of $2.5 million to $3.5 million. And depending on the kind of space it found, it might also have to raise millions more for capital renovation costs.
But, yes, fund-raising has been tough. Why are rich people so hateful? Why do they blackball religious museums?

Oh, wait -- in the Post, Riley tells us that a new religious museum in Washington, D.C., is opening soon:
The eight-story, 430,000-square-foot Museum of the Bible broke ground earlier this year and is scheduled to open in 2017.

It’ll include everything from ancient texts to multimedia exhibits to tell museumgoers about the Bible’s history, its impact and its narrative....

The museum is the brainchild of the Green family, which made its fortune with the Hobby Lobby chain and is now famously associated with a Supreme Court victory over the Affordable Care Act....
So why didn't the Green family pony up some money to keep the Museum of Biblical Art open in Manhattan? Or, for that matter, why wasn't money put up by some of the Greens' financial partners (who, we're told, include "Jewish groups, Eastern Orthodox Christians and even the Vatican")? Maybe they had bigoted feelings toward a museum of biblical art that treats the Bible as "a culturally foundational text" rather than as the undisputed word of God. Hatemongers!

For that matter, since this article appears in the New York Post (and is linked at Fox Nation), why didn't Rupert Murdoch (net worth: $13.5 billion) put up some scratch?

Oh, sorry, I forgot -- financing religious museums should be mandatory only for liberal "cultural elites."

A PALINESQUE DEFENSE OF KIRSTEN POWERS'S NON-THREATENED FREE-SPEECH RIGHTS

Fox News pseudo-Democrat Kirsten Powers has a tendentious new book out. It's called The Silencing: How the Left Is Killing Free Speech.
Lifelong liberal Kirsten Powers blasts the Left's forced march towards conformity in an exposé of the illiberal war on free speech. No longer champions of tolerance and free speech, the "illiberal Left" now viciously attacks and silences anyone with alternative points of view. Powers asks, "What ever happened to free speech in America?"
In it, she alleges free-speech violations that aren't violations at all:



She insists, of course, that they really are violations:



(I'm pretty sure people were writing letters to newspapers demanding the firing of certain pundits long before most members of today's intolerant left were born. And I'm pretty sure we still had a First Amendment then. Also, if you put your reason for wanting a pundit fired into an old-fashioned letter to the editor or a newfangled online petition, that's an argument, right?)

Now Republican operative Richard Grenell has posted a defense of Powers at Fox News Opinion. In it, we get a brand-new definition of unconstitutional speech suppression:
In one sense, the Left’s immediate meltdown over Kirsten Powers’ new book highlighting its intolerance was perfectly timed to sell a book. But in another way, “The Silencing: How the Left is Killing Free Speech” predicted the reaction from the Left before a word was even published. Either way, the book is explosive. It carefully details the fall of free speech and the rise of the new intolerants on the left.

Oliver Willis, a research fellow at Media Matters, went after Powers’ credibility within a few hours of the book’s release. He and his employer know that if they can push Powers out of the real Democratic Party, then she isn’t the credible insider she says she is. In order to take away her credibility as someone critiquing the party from the inside, they need to define her as someone on the outside. If Media Matters can successfully turn Powers into something other than a card-carrying Democrat, then her strong condemnation of the Left’s new tactics will fall flat. It’s the classic campaign strategy to “attack the messenger” while not engaging on the damaging message.
Here's what Grenell is reacting to:



So Powers is asserting that her book is worthy of consideration because of some aspects of her biography. Willis, according to Grenell, is engaging in a "silencing" of Powers by reminding people on Twitter of other aspects of her biography. Publishing accurate information about Powers, in other words, is speech suppression.

This is a new variation of the Palin theory of the First Amendment, s articulated by the former vice presidential candidate during the 2008 campaign:
Palin told WMAL-AM that her criticism of Obama's associations, like those with 1960s radical Bill Ayers and the Rev. Jeremiah Wright, should not be considered negative attacks. Rather, for reporters or columnists to suggest that it is going negative may constitute an attack that threatens a candidate's free speech rights under the Constitution, Palin said.

"If [the media] convince enough voters that that is negative campaigning, for me to call Barack Obama out on his associations," Palin told host Chris Plante, "then I don't know what the future of our country would be in terms of First Amendment rights and our ability to ask questions without fear of attacks by the mainstream media."
Palin's argument was: If you say bad things about my speech, you're suppressing it. Grenell, on behalf of Powers, is taking that a step further -- he's saying, If you report basic biographical information about Powers that fleshes out the selective biography she's chosen to put forward, you're suppressing all the speech to which she's attached that biography.

For the record, despite the fascistic tweets of Willis, just this week Powers has either published articles or been written about in the following publications: the Daily Beast, National Review, Christianity Today, Breitbart, the Frisky, Real Clear Politics, the Washington Examiner, The Washington Times...

But she's being silenced. Right. Got it.

WHY AREN'T FAR-RIGHTISTS AS UPSET ABOUT TPP AS THEY ARE ABOUT JADE HELM 15?

I know all about the feud within the Democratic Party on trade -- but I'm curious as to why the far right is relatively quiet about the trade deal. Yes, you can see it denounced at Alex Jones's Infowars, which says that the Trans-Pacific Partnership is "Congress giving away its authority" and "surrendering to 'global busybodies.'" Yes, Larry Pratt of Gun Owners of America is warning that "UN-style gun control [could] be rammed down our throats" under TPP. And yet there don't seem to be any angry town-hall meetings, nor are there guys with "Don't Tread on Me" flags and "Molon Labe" T-shirts marching on D.C. brandishing AR-15s in order to stop this. Right-wingers are much more concerned that Jade Helm 15 -- an exercise conducted by our own military -- is a threat to U.S. sovereignty than they are about a trade deal in which U.S. laws actually could be nullified as the result of an agreement with ... furriners!

You know the far right is relatively calm about this because elected Republicans are unafraid to back the trade deal -- there was overwhelming GOP support for the bill that failed yesterday. And even the GOP presidential aspirants from the state where you have to pay lip service to fears about Jade Helm to remain in good standing with the voters are backing the trade deal:
In an April 21 Wall Street Journal op-ed co-authored with Rep. Paul Ryan, R-Wis., [Ted] Cruz said the TPP and another potential trade pact with European nations “would mean greater access to a billion customers for American manufacturers, farmers and ranchers.”

[Rick] Perry also came out in support of the deal. “Gov. Perry has always supported free trade and its positive impact on economic growth and job creation,” a spokesman told Breitbart. “He believes America can achieve robust economic growth and job creation, similar to what has occurred in Texas, with trade agreements like the Trans-Pacific Partnership.”
Yes, but what about Rand Paul, who regularly sides with the far right? Hasn't he declared his opposition to fast-tracking TPP?
“I’ve told leadership I’m a 'no' vote” on trade promotion authority,” Paul said during a campaign stop in New Hampshire.
Well, yes -- but that seems to be strictly because the agreement has been kept secret:
“I’m hesitant to give blanket authority on stuff we haven’t seen,” he said.
Paul, in fact, supports TPP:
Last fall, in a foreign policy address to The National Interest, Paul urged President Obama to make the U.S. pivot to Asia by completing the TPP.

“Instead of just talking about a so-called pivot to Asia the Obama administration should prioritize negotiating the Trans-Pacific Partnership by year’s end,” he said.

“Trade is a critical element of building a productive relationship with other nations, including China,” he said.
I don't get it. I'd say it's because far-rightists don't want to be on the same side as progressives, but that didn't stop some of them from opposing the Iraq War, and there's far-right opposition to NSA surveillance, drones, and GMO foods, all of which also show up on the left.

The far right is usually furious about real or imagined threats to U.S. sovereignty -- but I guess that when the threats come from large corporations, far-rightists stop being Alex Jonesians and revert to pure Foxism, believing that whatever's good for business is good. That's the only explanation I can come up with.

Tuesday, May 12, 2015

HANNITY AND HIS PALS PULL A BREITBART ON MICHELLE OBAMA

If you're a non-conservative African-American and you want to give a speech in which you mention race in America, it's quite possible that you're going to talk about reasons that you've felt disheartened or resentful about the way you and fellow blacks have been treated -- and, after that, you may very well talk about working to transcend those feelings and remain positive.

Here's the thing: If your speech follows that arc, and you're someone conservatives don't like, they'll edit out the part where you talk about moving forward in a positive way. They'll take the part where you talk about racism, isolate that, and feed it to a white conservative media audience that's always eager to feel that those damn black people never stop complaining.

This is what happened to Shirley Sherrod -- but in her case, the omitted part of the speech wasn't available to the public at first. Once it was available, it was clear that Andrew Breitbart had grotesquely distorted Sherrod's views toward white people (which, of course, didn't prevent her from losing her job in the Obama administration).

But the right can play this game even when a speech is available to the public in full. You can read the full transcript of the commencement address Michelle Obama delivered at Tuskegee University on Saturday by going to WhiteHouse.gov. You can read about the speech at any number of news sources.

But chances are you haven't -- so Fox is here to tell you what Michelle Obama said, in carefully edited form. Watch the opening of this clip:



Here's what you see the First Lady saying:
We’ve both felt the sting of those daily slights throughout our entire lives -- the folks who crossed the street in fear of their safety; the clerks who kept a close eye on us in all those department stores; the people at formal events who assumed we were the “help” -- and those who have questioned our intelligence, our honesty, even our love of this country.

And I know that these little indignities are obviously nothing compared to what folks across the country are dealing with every single day -- those nagging worries that you’re going to get stopped or pulled over for absolutely no reason; the fear that your job application will be overlooked because of the way your name sounds....
Cut to Sean Hannity and an outraged panel (in this case, of three black conservatives and one black Obama defender). No other part of the speech is going to be quoted. You're not going to be told that the First Lady went on to say:
But, graduates, today, I want to be very clear that those feelings are not an excuse to just throw up our hands and give up. (Applause.) Not an excuse. They are not an excuse to lose hope. To succumb to feelings of despair and anger only means that in the end, we lose.

But here’s the thing -- our history provides us with a better story, a better blueprint for how we can win. It teaches us that when we pull ourselves out of those lowest emotional depths, and we channel our frustrations into studying and organizing and banding together -- then we can build ourselves and our communities up. We can take on those deep-rooted problems, and together -- together -- we can overcome anything that stands in our way.
You're not going to be told this:
During her speech, Obama talked about Tuskegee’s rich history, one of the top black universities in the US and the training place of the US’s first World War II African American pilots. At the time, the Tuskegee Airmen faced institutionalized discrimination. Official Army reports described the black soldiers as “shiftless,” “childlike,” and “unmoral and untruthful.” Even as highly educated individuals, these men faced an upward battle within their own country....

Yet, when given the opportunity to respond with resilience or a spirit of defeat, they persevered.

“Now, those Airmen could easily have let that experience clip their wings. But as you all know, instead of being defined by the discrimination and the doubts of those around them, they became one of the most successful pursuit squadrons in our military,” the first lady continued.
You're not going to be told this:
Obama described ... how the university's students in the 1800's made bricks by hand to construct campus buildings so future generations could study there.
No, Fox doesn't want its viewers to know that any of that was in the speech. The out-of-context clip is played, and then there's this reaction from Hannity and his panel, as described by Ellen at NewsHounds:
HANNITY: My initial observation is… Barack Hussein Obama got elected by a majority of white America. Why is she so angry?

MICHAEL MEYERS: Which racial ideologue do you know that’s not angry? She sounded like Hillary Clinton in that racial dialect. (He did an imitation that sounded like a monkey).
I was shocked at that "monkey" description. But watch the clip above, between 2:16 and 2:24. The description is accurate.

And this was just Hannity's first segment on the speech. It was followed by a segment with Ann Coulter:
“Yes, America does owe black America for slavery, for the Democratic policies of Jim Crow,” Coulter said. “I think we’ve -- we’re making it up now. When, you know, you’re getting admitted to Princeton when you can’t read, is that enough yet?”

It's unclear what Coulter's reference to Princeton was about. On Tuesday morning, another conservative commentator took to Fox News to say that the first lady, who graduated from Princeton University and Harvard Law School, was the beneficiary of "affirmative action" by attending the former.
This, of course, is having the intended effect of raising conservative America's level of hatred for Michelle Obama. Little Green Footballs has collected some of the worst comments in a Breitbart thread about this speech:
You might be African but you sure aren’t American.

[...]

She is a HATE filled Negro, a true RACIST and anti-American.

[...]

How many times have people mistaken her for a tranny?

[...]

I did have a misperception...how did a Wookie become the FLOTUS? Later -- of course -- I was set straight, though it is easy to confuse a Sasquatch with George Luca’s fictional pilot of the Millienium Falcon.

[...]

I’ll be glad when monkey face is gone!
I'll stop there. This is what Fox and the rest of the right-wing media contribute to American society -- every day.

WHEN RON PAUL FANS CHEERED, THEY WERE CHEERING FOR LUIS LANG TO GO BLIND

When he was gainfully employed, Luis Lang refused to buy private insurance and refused to sign up for Obamacare. Now he's going blind, and it's all our fault:
Lang, a 49-year-old resident of Fort Mill, S.C., has bleeding in his eyes and a partially detached retina caused by diabetes.

“He will lose his eyesight if he doesn’t get care. He will go blind,” said Dr. Malcolm Edwards, the Lancaster, S.C., ophthalmologist who examined Lang.

Lang is a self-employed handyman who works with banks and the federal government on maintaining foreclosed properties. He has done well enough that his wife, Mary, hasn’t had to work....

But he has never bought insurance. Instead, he says, he prided himself on paying his own medical bills.

...[He's] suffered several mini-strokes. He ran up $9,000 in bills and exhausted his savings. Meanwhile, his vision worsened and he can’t work, he says.

That’s when he turned to the Affordable Care Act exchange. Lang learned two things: First, 2015 enrollment had closed earlier that month. And second, because his income has dried up, he earns too little to get a federal subsidy to buy a private policy.

Lang, a Republican, says he knew the act required him to get coverage but he chose not to do so. But he thought help would be available in an emergency. He and his wife blame President Obama and Congressional Democrats for passing a complex and flawed bill.
As Josh Marshall notes:
Since Lang now has no income, he should be eligible for the ACA's expanded Medicaid coverage, for which the federal government picks up tab. But Lang lives in Fort Mill, South Carolina. And South Carolina refused to accept Medicaid expansion. So he's out of luck on that front too.
We've met Luis Lang before -- but when we last met him, he didn't have a name. Luis Lang, you see, is the real-life version of the hypothetical uninsured individual Ron Paul was asked about in a 2011 Republican presidential debate. As you'll recall, Paul said the hypothetical man should just "assume responsibility for himself," because "That’s what freedom is all about, taking your own risks." And the crowd cheered.



WOLF BLITZER: Thank you, Governor. Before I get to Michele Bachmann, I want to just -- you’re a physician, Ron Paul, so you’re a doctor. You know something about this subject. Let me ask you this hypothetical question.

A healthy 30-year-old young man has a good job, makes a good living, but decides, you know what? I’m not going to spend $200 or $300 a month for health insurance because I’m healthy, I don’t need it. But something terrible happens, all of a sudden he needs it.

Who’s going to pay if he goes into a coma, for example? Who pays for that?

PAUL: Well, in a society that you accept welfarism and socialism, he expects the government to take care of him.

BLITZER: Well, what do you want?

PAUL: But what he should do is whatever he wants to do, and assume responsibility for himself. My advice to him would have a major medical policy, but not be forced --

BLITZER: But he doesn’t have that. He doesn’t have it, and he needs intensive care for six months. Who pays?

PAUL: That’s what freedom is all about, taking your own risks. This whole idea that you have to prepare and take care of everybody --

(APPLAUSE)
Paul went on to talk about two possible options for his hypothetical patient: charity on the medical community's part and charity from the churches:
BLITZER: But Congressman, are you saying that society should just let him die?

PAUL: No. I practiced medicine before we had Medicaid, in the early 1960s, when I got out of medical school. I practiced at Santa Rosa Hospital in San Antonio, and the churches took care of them. We never turned anybody away from the hospitals.

(APPLAUSE)

PAUL: And we’ve given up on this whole concept that we might take care of ourselves and assume responsibility for ourselves. Our neighbors, our friends, our churches would do it.
There's your answer, folks. Obamacare was designed to make it unnecessary for Americans to have to beg for medical care -- yes, there's a price to pay if you don't obtain coverage during the enrollment period, but Lang should be able to obtain coverage through the expansion of Medicaid now that he can't work. Unfortunately for him, his party doesn't want him to be able to do that in his state.

Since conservatives have made Obamacare more porous than it was intended to be in South Carolina, we should be looking at the remedy conservatives recommend in this situation. You guys reshaped the health care landscape to the extent you could, and you guys encouraged people like Lang to be Obamacare refuseniks -- so you solve his problems. Churches should take up a collection for him. Doctors and hospitals should treat him and not expect payment. That's the system you think is better. So show us it's better.

And then repeat as necessary for all the Luis Langs who can't get the press to write about them.

Or back the hell off and let Obamacare do its work.

JEB BUSH AND MEGYN KELLY TELL ZOMBIE LIE ABOUT HILLARY CLINTON SPEECH ON WOMEN

Jeb Bush gave an interview to Fox's Megyn Kelly on Saturday, after his commencement address at the school Jerry Falwell founded, Liberty University. The interview aired last night.



As Paul Waldman has written, in the commencement address Bush chose to "embrace a narrative of victimhood" on behalf of Christians. (Sample sentence: "There are consequences when you don’t genuflect to the latest secular dogmas.") Bush continued this in the Kelly interview, starting with the first exchange, in which he agreed with Kelly that Hillary Clinton is one of the secular fascists who seek to oppress Christians. This is based on a distortion of a recent Clinton speech, as I'll explain below.

Here's the exchange, which comes right at the beginning of the interview. (Transcript via the Daily Caller; emphasis added):
KELLY: So I listened to your speech today at Liberty University, and you focused a lot on faith and commitment to Christian conscience. Which was interesting, because just recently Hillary Clinton came out and said those who hold a deep-seated religious belief have to change them, that those religious beliefs need to be changed, in particular, to allow reproductive freedom for women. Your response to her?

BUSH: Look, it’s okay I guess in the secular work to be someone who is religious. But you can’t act on your faith, you can’t have a conscience and act on it? That was the basic purpose of this speech, was to say that in this incredible country of ours, we need enough space for people to be able to act on their faith.

And by the way, when they do, they do good. They feed the hungry, they take care of the homeless, they protect people, they love people. That’s the beauty of our heritage and our faith.

I was deeply troubled by Hillary’s statement that somehow, you have to put your faith and your convictions in some lockbox I guess, and not be able to act on them.

KELLY: That’s going to be the line, though, that Republicans who are social conservatives are looking to trample on women’s rights from abortion to contraception.

BUSH: I don’t think they’re right about that, but at the same time I don’t think it’s appropriate for people on the left or people that don’t have a guiding faith to be able to say to others, ‘Look, you can’t do anything.’

This is kind of the world we’re moving towards, that the First Amendment rights only exist for people that don’t have faith. I mean, if we reflect on this the right way, I think we’ll realize that we’re a big enough country to allow for the dissenting views on any subject.
This is based on Hillary Clinton's recent speech to the Women in the World Summit. As I pointed out a couple of weeks ago, right-wingers attacked Hillary along these lines. (Sample headline: "Hillary On Abortion: ‘Deep-Seated Cultural Codes, Religious Beliefs And Structural Biases Have To Be Changed.’")

But the right was taking her words out of context. She was discussing the status of women worldwide, and she was talking about education access, freedom from rape, and a host of other issues, only one of which was "reproductive health care," which she linked with "safe childbirth."

Here's my transcript of the relevant part of that speech, which starts at 6:31 in the video below. I've added some emphasis:
All the evidence tells us that despite the enormous obstacles that remain, there has never been a better time in history to be born female. Think about that. A girl born twenty years ago in Tanzania could not hope to one day own or inherit property. Today she can. If she were born in Nepal, there was a tragically high chance that her mother and even she would die in childbirth. Today, thankfully, that is far less likely. A girl born twenty years ago in Rwanda grew up in the shadow of genocide and rape. Today she can be proud that women have led the way out of that dark time, and now there are more women serving in her country's parliament than anywhere else in the world.

But the data leads to a second conclusion: that despite all this progress, we're just not there yet. Yes, we've nearly closed the global gender gap in primary school. But secondary school remains out of reach for so many girls around the world. Yes, we've increased the number of countries prohibiting domestic violence. But still, more than half the nations in the world have no such laws on the books, and an estimated one in three women still experience violence. Yes, we've cut the maternal mortality rate in half. But far too many women are still denied critical access to reproductive health care and safe childbirth.

All the laws we've passed don't count for much if they're not enforced. Rights have to exist in practice, not just on paper. Laws have to be backed up with resources and political will, and deep-seated cultural codes, religious beliefs, and structural biases have to be changed.



The right loves to do this -- twist and distort the words of liberals and Democrats, then endlessly repeat the misreading until it becomes the standard interpretation of what was said. "You didn't build that." "Spread the wealth around." And on and on.

I saw that the right-wing media was distorting what Hillary Clinton said in this speech, but I didn't realize that the Republican presidential front-runner was going to pile on. Now I know.

Monday, May 11, 2015

WOULD RUBIO GIVE THE SAME ANSWER AS JEB ON THE IRAQ WAR?

The conventional wisdom is that Jeb Bush and Marco Rubio are the two leading "moderate," "mainstream" presidential aspirants on the Republican side. Of course, "moderate" Jeb has now passed on the opportunity to repudiate his brother's war in Iraq:
Fox News' Megyn Kelly asked [Jeb] Bush a straightforward, concise question: "Knowing what we know now, would you have authorized the invasion?" Bush's answer was an unhesitating yes.

"I would have, and so would have Hillary Clinton, just to remind everybody," Bush said, "and so would have almost everybody that was confronted with the intelligence they got."

"You don't think it was a mistake?" asked Kelly.

"In retrospect, the intelligence that everybody saw, that the world saw, not just the United States, was faulty," Bush answered.
There's a case to be made that Jeb wasn't really answering the question Kelly asked him, as Mediaite's Evan McMurry wrote yesterday (emoticon in original):
To be clear, there appears to be some confusion between Kelly’s question and Bush’s answer. Kelly asked Bush whether, knowing what he knows now, he would still invade, whereas Bush appears to answer according to the available intelligence in 2003, which was wrong but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.
But Bush refused to question the decision to invade -- and as Byron York notes, that puts him somewhat to the right of the GOP's last presidential nominee:
In 2011, [Mitt] Romney said: "Well, if we knew at the time of our entry into Iraq that there were no weapons of mass destruction -- if somehow we had been given that information, why, obviously we would not have gone in."
So what about the other Florida-based, allegedly respectable, allegedly non-crazy GOP presidential wannabe? Well, I think Marco Rubio generally avoids talking about the Iraq War -- as far back as 2012, he gave what was billed as a major foreign policy speech at the Brookings Institution and didn't mention Iraq once -- but there have been hints of his view. In a 2010 debate during his Senate campaign, there was this exchange:
MODERATOR: Mr. Rubio, is America safer and better off for having gone to war in Iraq?

RUBIO: I think ultimately, yes. First of all, the world is better off because Saddam Hussein is no longer in charge. He is no longer in charge of that country. Let’s understand one thing. Right now we’re worrying about Iran possessing a nuclear weapon. If Saddam Hussein was still there you’d have a full-blown arms war the way you’ve seen between Pakistan and India. So the world is a safer place not to mention the Iraqi people are better off than they were under Saddam Hussein. [...]
There's also the speech he gave in London in December 2013 in which he referred to the Iraq War as one of the "vitally important achievements" of the alliance between the U.S. and Britain.

And, backtracking to 2012, let's not forget that his words about George W. Bush were almost as kind as Jeb's are now:
George W. Bush, in my opinion, did a fantastic job as president over eight years, facing a set of circumstances during those eight years that are different from the circumstances that a President Romney would face.
All of which makes me hope that someone will ask Marco Rubio precisely the same question Jeb was asked: Knowing what we know now, would you have authorized the invasion? Rubio might be shrewd enough to evade the question, but if he answers it, my guess is that is answer will be a lot like Jeb's.

KRUGMAN DECLARES PARTIAL VICTORY OVER DODD-FRANK FOES, PREMATURELY

Paul Krugman warns us that right-wingers still really want to kill Dodd-Frank, and that we're going to have to keep our guard up to prevent them from doing that -- but he also says that they seem to be abandoning one line of attack on it:
When right-wing think tanks do try to claim that regulation is a bad thing that will hurt the economy, their hearts don’t seem to be in it. For example, the latest such “study,” from the American Action Forum, runs to all of four pages, and even its author, the economist Douglas Holtz-Eakin, sounds embarrassed about his work.
I don't really know what right-wing think tanks are up to, but several Republican presidential candidates are still talking as if Dodd-Frank is crushing the economy's spirit. Here was The Hill last month, reporting on Carly Fiorina:
Likely GOP presidential candidate Carly Fiorina wants to abolish the sweeping Wall Street reform law.

The former Hewlett-Packard CEO told The Hill that if she were elected president, she'd nix the 2010 Dodd-Frank legislation entirely and begin anew.

“We should get rid of Dodd-Frank and start again,” Fiorina told The Hill.

Fiorina argues the law will do little to prevent another financial crisis and has instead introduced regulations that are holding back the economy.
In a Breitbart interview last month, Fiorina said this:
... now we have three thousand community banks that have gone out of business. And they’ve gone out of business because they can’t handle the complexity and the requirements.
Meanwhile, Jeb Bush said this last month in an appearance in New Hampshire:
"On my last trip to New Hampshire, I think I met the guy who founded the first and only bank since Dodd-Frank passed, since the financial crisis. One bank in the country."
PolitiFact said that claim was "mostly false" -- "Depending on the data set you choose, it’s either the second, fourth, ninth or 20th." While it's true that the number of new banks has dwindled, a Federal Reserve report says that's probably because there's not much money in it these days -- the economy has remained weak, and, of course, interest rates are low. (The report finds that historically there's been a strong correlation between low interest rates and low bank formation.)

And let's not forget that Marco Rubio last year proposed a law that would drastically limit regulation:
Congress would establish a National Regulatory Budget, say at $1.75 trillion, and then the new review board would have the power to prohibit government agencies from issuing new regulations until their costs were estimated and old regulations with equivalent costs were taken off the books.
So every regulation would be treated as primarily a money suck, and there'd be a ceiling on regulations as a result.

So maybe Krugman is right, and the think tanks aren't saying that financial regulation strangles the economic. They're just letting the GOP presidential candidates say that instead.

ONE BIG REASON RIGHT-WINGERS AREN'T GOING TO WANT TO DEFEND SEYMOUR HERSH

Seymour Hersh's big story claiming that Everything You Thought You Knew About The Death Of Osama Bin Laden Is A Lie is up at the London Review of Books ... and I don't see a lot of right-wingers embracing it wholeheartedly, even though you'd think an "Obama LIED!!!1!1!1" story would be irresistible to the right.

One reason the story is unsatisfying to the right is obvious right away: If Hersh's version of how the U.S. learned about bin Laden's whereabouts were to prove true, it would end forever the discussion of whether torture had anything to do with bin Laden's death, and not in the right's favor. Hersh writes:
It began with a walk-in. In August 2010 a former senior Pakistani intelligence officer approached Jonathan Bank, then the CIA’s station chief at the US embassy in Islamabad. He offered to tell the CIA where to find bin Laden in return for the reward that Washington had offered in 2001. Walk-ins are assumed by the CIA to be unreliable, and the response from the agency’s headquarters was to fly in a polygraph team. The walk-in passed the test. ‘So now we’ve got a lead on bin Laden living in a compound in Abbottabad, but how do we really know who it is?’ was the CIA’s worry at the time, the retired senior US intelligence official told me.
So, if Hersh is right, bin Laden wasn't located because we tracked his courier -- and if that's the case, this discussion is over:
After Osama bin Laden was killed by US special operations forces, the pro-torture CIA crowd pointed to the raid as evidence that human-rights-abusing questioning can produce essential intelligence. And this debate was revived when the film Zero Dark Thirty implied the same point. During these dust-ups, Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.), the chair of the Senate intelligence committee, said her committee's years-long investigation of the CIA interrogation program showed that the agency's use of harsh techniques did not lead it to bin Laden's hideaway in Pakistan. The torture report she released today -- that is, the 535-page executive summary of the 6,600-page full report -- states bluntly that CIA torturing had nothing to do with finding bin Laden. A footnote reports that the CIA, naturally, takes issues with this and says the committee report "incorrectly characterizes the intelligence we had." That footnote adds, "This is incorrect."
That's from a Mother Jones story on the report released by the Senate in December 2014. CIA director John Brennan subsequently insisted that the report was wrong:
"It is our considered view that the detainees who were subjected to enhanced interrogation techniques provided information that was useful and was used in the ultimate operation to go against Bin Laden," Brennan said.
The right loves torture. The next Republican president will openly and unabashedly torture. So if this is true, it's buzzkill.

Sunday, May 10, 2015

DEAR CONSERVATIVES: IT WAS ONLY TODAY THAT YOU REALIZED MARK HALPERIN IS AN IDIOT?

So it just dawned on right-wingers that Mark Halperin is an obnoxious and ridiculous human being?

Much of the right, you see, has spent the day pointing to an op-ed by Ruben Navarrette about Halperin's recent interview of Ted Cruz:
Watching Mark Halperin of Bloomberg Politics interview Cruz recently, I wasn't just uncomfortable. I was actually nauseated.

... the host asked a series of questions intended to establish his guest's Hispanic bona fides. What kind of Cuban food did Cruz like to eat growing up? And what sort of Cuban music does Cruz listen to even now?

I've known Ted for more than a decade and I could tell he was uncomfortable. But he played along, listing various kinds of Cuban food and saying that his musical taste veers more toward country.

I kept waiting for Halperin to ask Cruz to play the conga drums like Desi Arnaz while dancing salsa and sipping cafe con leche -- all to prove the Republican is really Cuban.

Just when I thought I'd seen the worst, it got even more offensive. Earlier that day, independent Sen. Bernie Sanders, of Vermont, had entered the presidential race. So, Halperin said: "I want to give you the opportunity to directly welcome your colleague Sen. Sanders to the race, and I'd like you to do it, if you would, en español."

What nerve, treating a U.S. senator like a trained seal! Who does this guy think he is, trying to evaluate how well a Hispanic speaks Spanish? And what does that have to do with being authentic anyway?
Here are the key moments from that interview:



So right-wingers don't like Halperin now? Welcome to the club -- what took you so long to get here? Oh, right -- you actually liked it when Halperin wrote that, for him and his fellow insider political journalists, "Matt Drudge rules our world." You were pleased when he all but begged Hugh Hewitt to take him seriously as a journalist because he agreed with right-wing charges of liberal media bias. You defended Halperin when he was temporarily suspended from his MSNBC's Morning Joe for calling President Obama a "dick" on the air.

But let's leave ideology aside. Halperin is a buffoon. Liberals have known that for years. We knew it in 2011 when he posted on his Time magazine blog a Photoshopped image of Senator Mary Landrieu with hair in the style of Cameron Diaz from the famous semen hair gel scene in There's Something About Mary:



We've known for a long time that Halperin's obnoxiousness and immaturity are on regular display. Remember, Halperin is the guy who brought Senator Bernie Sanders on his show and pressured him to read dialogue from old Seinfeld episodes, because it's allegedly rumored that Sanders was the voice of George Steinbrenner on Seinfeld. And Halperin is the guy who brought Senator Orrin Hatch on his show and did this:



Halperin is a clown. Now we now he's a racist clown, but we knew he was a clown a long time ago. Glad you're catching on, right-wingers.

SO WALKER'S RHETORICAL FLOURISH WAS A GAFFE, BUT RUBIO'S WAS AN APPLAUSE LINE?

A couple of months ago, Scot Walker said something about foreign policy that was widely derided as a gaffe:
"I want a commander-in-chief who will do everything in their power to ensure that the threat from radical Islamic terrorists does not wash up on American soil," Walker said. "If I can take on 100,000 protesters, I can do the same across the world."
What a silly thing to say! Wow, Walker was really making it obvious that he has no foreign policy experience! That really cut into his credibility as a potential president!

In fact , Dave Weigel reminds us that Walker has since "dropped that line," doing so "after some pushback and mockery."

So how does a real presidential candidate talk about foreign policy? A serious aspirant with serious foreign policy chops? Let's take a look:
Republican presidential candidate Marco Rubio summed up his hawkish foreign policy in a speech at the South Carolina Freedom Summit on Saturday with a reference to the 2008 thriller Taken.

“On our strategy on global jihadists and terrorists, I refer them to the movie Taken. Have you seen the movie Taken? Liam Neeson. He had a line, and this is what our strategy should be: 'We will look for you, we will find you, and we will kill you,'” the Florida senator said in Greenville.

The line -- referring to Neeson's character, a CIA operative threatening a human trafficker who had kidnapped his daughter -- earned the top-tier candidate thunderous applause.
How thoughtful! How well-informed! How nuanced! You sure can tell that Rubio is a seasoned, experienced member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, and not some hick college dropout governor!

I'm not snarking off in order to defend what Walker said -- I'm just trying to point out that the level of simplemindedness in Walker's statement was just about average for the Republican field. (Remember: Republicans think Ronald Reagan said something surpassingly brilliant when he told America that his Cold War strategy was "We win, they lose.")

And, of course, if we're going to take Rubio seriously, we ought to recall that Neeson's threat is made in the first Taken movie, and while Neeson makes good on that threat (by torturing that particular antagonist to death), there are still two more sequels' worth of brutality for Neeson to deal with (and respond to with his own brutality) -- which means that Rubio is recommending as an object lesson a fictional world in which you can't fully deter extremely committed bad guys by being really, really angry and threatening toward them in the way Rubio recommends.

But at least we're getting advance warning that Bush-style cowboy rhetoric is coming back with a vengeance in a Rubio presidency.

Saturday, May 09, 2015

FROM PLAUSIBLE TO CRAZY WITH THE RIGHT-WING SCANDAL MACHINE

At the Daily Beast, as part of his effort to explain why character attacks don't hurt the Clintons, Jeff Greenfield writes:
For close to a quarter-century now, the willingness -- make that eagerness -- of voices on the Right to embrace every accusation against the Clintons has proven to be a pearl of great price for Bill and Hillary, serving to insulate them politically from allegations that were, in fact, credible. (No, the Clintons did not murder Vince Foster, nor profit from the Whitewater deal. Yes, there was something distinctly non-kosher about how Hillary Clinton made so much money trading cattle futures. No, the Clintons did not hang pornographic toys on a White House Christmas tree; yes, the Marc Rich pardon was indefensible).
I like the fact that, when enumerating Clinton non-scandals, Greenfield lumps together a story that could conceivably have uncovered wrongdoing but didn't (Whitewater), one that needed to be checked out as a matter of due diligence but was always far-fetched as a scandal (whether Vince Foster was murdered), and one that was just utter lunacy (the sex toys on the Christmas tree). That's appropriate, because the right is a scndalmongering machine, and that's true regardless of the plausibility of the (real or fake) scandals. The right milks them in different ways, but they all get milked.

And so on the right at this moment we have the alleged plot to seize control of Texas by means of the Jade Helm 15 military exercises; most Republicans whove talked about Jade Helm have said, in effect, Well, I don't think there's anything to worry about, but with these Obama people you just never know, do you? And then, at the "respectable" end of the spectrum, there's Benghazi, a scandal that Republicans expect to milk for another year and a half:
GOP slow-plays Benghazi investigation

Presidential hopeful Hillary Clinton has agreed to testify before the Benghazi committee this month but don’t expect Republicans to be satisfied with her appearance.

House Republicans have now spent a full year investigating the 2012 terrorist attacks in Libya -- including whether any of the former secretary of State’s actions may have contributed to the incident -- and there are few indications there will be a speedy conclusion to their inquiries.

Rep. Trey Gowdy (R-S.C.), chairman of the Select Committee on Benghazi, signaled he’s prepared to drag out his investigation well into 2016 if Clinton and the Obama administration continue to stonewall his requests for documents and answers....
It's obvious that there's no there there, but Republicans will continue to try to convey the sense that the smoking gun has yet to be discovered -- just as they continue to talk as if the Clinton murder of Vincent Foster has simply never been proven:
Peter Schweizer and conservative radio host Dana Loesch speculated that Schweizer could be murdered by "the Clinton machine" over his new book Clinton Cash.

During a May 4 appearance on The Dana Show, Loesch told Schweizer "there is always that concern for anyone who goes up against the Clinton machine that they could be Vince Fostered" and asked if he considered that possibility when "getting himself security." Schweizer replied: "Yeah, I mean look -- there are security concerns that arise in these kinds of situations."
The right just can't let go of any scandal, real or fake. This actually works for Republicans in non-presidential years, because it keeps the GOP voter base fired up and ready to turn out when Democratic voters won't. But it fails them in presidential elections -- as Greenfield says, the constant attacks on the Clintons actually boost their popularity, and help them downplay what might otherwise be legitimate scandals. To some extent, that's true of President Obama as well -- the people who tried to attack him over Benghazi seemed to be the same people who'd demanded to see his birth certificate; because he was a president, less engaged voters saw him as the victim of unsubstantiated attacks, and treated the attackers as lacking credibility about anything.

I'm pleased that Republicans scandalmongering often fails -- though I wish it failed all the time. In any event, it's practically all Republicans have got.

THE ENDLESSLY RECURRING "FEMA RAILCARS WITH SHACKLES" STORY

Are we still talking about the Obama administration's evil plan to put Texas under martial law by means of the Jade Helm 15 military exercise? Gail Collins writes about it today, and NPR's On the Media did a snarky segment on it last night, featuring Texas-born NPR reporter Wade Goodwyn. Goodwyn blogged about this last week on the NPR site, and he could barely contain his contempt for the believers:
Let's walk over by the fence where nobody can hear us, and I'll tell you the story.

You see, there are these Wal-Marts in West Texas that supposedly closed for six months for "renovation." That's what they want you to believe. The truth is these Wal-Marts are going to be military guerrilla-warfare staging areas and FEMA processing camps for political prisoners. The prisoners are going to be transported by train cars that have already been equipped with shackles.

Don't take my word for it. That comes directly from a Texas Ranger, who seems pretty plugged in, if you ask me.
So what exactly is that (anonymous) Texas Ranger saying about the train cars with shackles? Gooodwyn's link leads us to a post from radio broadcaster Dave Hodges of The Common Sense Show. The Ranger's letter to Hodges says in part:
Let me drop a bombshell that I have not seen you address. There are trains moving throughout Texas that have shackles inside some of the cars. I have not personally seen them, but I know personnel that have seen this. This indicates that these trains will be used to transport prisoners of some sort. I know from reading your articles that your default belief will be that these are for American political prisoners and will be transported to FEMA detention camps of some sort. We have been told by Homeland that these trains are slated for transporting captured terrorists, non-domestic. We are not sure we can trust this explanation because Homeland is keeping a lot from us and we are growing increasingly uncomfortable with their presence in Texas.
Railcars with shackles? FEMA? This is supposedly a brand-new "bombshell," but it sounds familiar to me....

Oh, yeah: it does because I wrote a post about rumors of FEMA railcars with shackles ... in 2009. And it was a well-established conspiracy theory then.

At that time, Orly Taitz, the queen of the birthers, was recounting some of her other concerns to Esquire magazine. Among the steps she urged skeptics to take:
Google an article in the San Francisco Chronicle about train cars with shackles.
She's right -- this actually was mentioned in a San Francisco Chronicle op-ed. Here it is. But while Taitz (in 2009) was claiming that Obama had FEMA railcars with shackles at the ready, the authors of the Chronicle op-ed (in 2008) were warning about this as a concern in the waning days of the Bush administration.

The authors of that op-ed were Lewis Seiler and Dan Hamburg. Hamburg is a former Democratic congressman who's since run as a Green Party candidate for governor of California. They wrote:
Beginning in 1999, the government has entered into a series of single-bid contracts with Halliburton subsidiary Kellogg, Brown and Root (KBR) to build detention camps at undisclosed locations within the United States. The government has also contracted with several companies to build thousands of railcars, some reportedly equipped with shackles, ostensibly to transport detainees.
So lefties bandied this idea about in the Bush era (though I guess it goes back to the Clinton era), and the company responsible was the evil Halliburton. Elsewhere, however, the company responsible for the sinster plot was Gunderson. A 2004 article at the conspiracy site Rense.com named Gunderson, drawing fevered conclusions about the company:
Speaking on anonymity, an employee of a manufacturer of railcars stated that Gunderson Rail Car Co. received a contract to build over 400 boxcars. These boxcars were ordered and paid for by the UN. They were white and they had shackles built into them. Shackles possibly for a brother, a sister, a mother, or you. Another company was making the boxcars as well. A company called Thrall Railcar.

Thrall Rail Car merged with Trinity Industries, Inc. in October of 2001 to form the Trinity Rail Group. For those of you who believe in David Icke's views on occult symbolism in corporate logos, I'll simply add that Trinity Industries has "3 pyramids" in their logo.
But in the Renseb article, it was an evil Bush conspiracy:
... I'll also add that on the Board of Directors of Trinity Rail Group is Craig J. Duchossois. He is a heavy contributor to the Bush-Cheney 04, Inc. re-election campaign and labeled a Pioneer. A Pioneer is someone who has contributed more than $100,000 to the re-election campaign. Craig J. Duchossois is also Chairman of the The Chamberlain Group. A group that sells access and security products for homes and businesses around the world including biometrics.
Did I mention that, according the Rense story, this was all connected to the UN?
Many researchers have cited the existence of over 107, white, UN railroad cars that have been built by independent contracters in the United States. These cars can hold dozens of prisoners and have, on numerous occasions, been shown to have 135 human shackes in each car. These would be the cars that FEMA would transfer such terrorists/dissidents to their forced labor, internment, or concentration camps.
Note the number of railroad cars: 107. That number later showed up in other reports as 107,000, or 107,200, or 102,000. (Very specific!) And often, we're told, the railcars have guillotines.

The FEMA concentration camp story was too far-fetched even for Glenn Beck, who rejected the notion in 2009. But the craziness never goes away, and now, of course, Texas politicians are giving it all credence -- even though a former Texas governor used to be the would-be dictator behind it all.